Uploaded April 2018 | Updated September 2026, 2 weeks ago

---

There's been a strange mystery online for about a decade now. Hundreds upon hundreds of users have been raving about a certain "key lime pie" that has never existed. The conversations that people have with each other about said pie are nothing short of odd. In this one, Elder's Vault and I will tackle this long-time mystery and bring it to the limelight.

🎡Visit Liminal Land: liminalland.net
📧Submit a mystery: NightmareExpo@gmail.com
📲Follow me: twitter.com/NexpoYT
🖤Support the channel: patreon.com/Nexpo

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
KeyLimeWTF's post: reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/527bkj/captain_kutchies_famous_pies_that_never_existed
Findings: reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/5c7g4m/what_the_captain_kutchie_of_the_key_lime_pies
BBQ site: barbequelovers.com/recipes/desserts/easy-keylime-pie-recipe

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music by CO.AG: youtube.com/channel/UCcavSftXHgxLBWwLDm_bNvA
Outro music by Zach J: youtube.com/channel/UCPxcXX_BdsPNXum315e-f2A