Uploaded August 2026 | Updated November 2026, 15 hours ago
Butter that got too warm & greasy may not be safe to use for creaming with sugar, even after it’s been refrigerated again!
That’s because butter is an emulsion of water & fat, and once it’s broken, it’s nearly impossible to get back without a whole lotta mixing.
(Anyone remember making butter by hand in grade school?)
If you’ve dealt with unexpectedly flat cookies, sunken cakes, or greasy frosting, this could be the culprit. Instead, mark and set aside this butter for recipes where it’ll be melted or browned (or for spreading on your morning toast!).
Be sure to follow me for more baking tips! I’ve graduated culinary school, written 2 cookbooks, and have been publishing recipes online since 2009. I have a LOT of opinions about baking 🫣
Butter that got too warm & greasy may not be safe to use for creaming with sugar, even after it’s been refrigerated again!
That’s because butter is an emulsion of water & fat, and once it’s broken, it’s nearly impossible to get back without a whole lotta mixing.
(Anyone remember making butter by hand in grade school?)
If you’ve dealt with unexpectedly flat cookies, sunken cakes, or greasy frosting, this could be the culprit. Instead, mark and set aside this butter for recipes where it’ll be melted or browned (or for spreading on your morning toast!).
Be sure to follow me for more baking tips! I’ve graduated culinary school, written 2 cookbooks, and have been publishing recipes online since 2009. I have a LOT of opinions about baking 🫣










