Uploaded November 2021 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
The claim that neuroscience has debunked free will has become fairly widespread and Rationality Rules, one of the most prominent atheist YouTubers, is at the forefront preaching this exact message. He proclaims that “science is telling us loud and clear and unequivocally that while our feelings of free will are real free will itself is an illusion.” His case is based on what are arguable the two most often-cited studies in neuroscience which presumably showed that determinism is true and free will doesn’t exist (which means that by watching my video you’ll not only get to see my response to @rationalityrules but you’ll learn about the nuts and bolts that are behind the popular claim that neuroscience has debunked free will). The first one is the work of Benjamin Libet, a pioneering neuroscientist who published a groundbreaking study in the early 1980s. The second one is the work of Chun Siong Soon. This video is part #1 of my response to Stephen’s case (part #2 will follow later) and it deals exclusively with Stephen’s treatment of Libet’s work. One of the most eye-opening lessons you will learn is that Benjamin Libet himself never thought of his work as providing evidence for determinism and against free will. Quite the opposite, actually. This means that Rationality Rules has essentially hijacked and abused Libet’s work for a case that Libet himself would never have supported. But that’s just the tip of the iceberg… I hope you will enjoy this video which deals with a key theme in Christian apologetics and in debates between skeptics and Christians.
Stephen's original video: youtube.com/watch?v=j4Oyi1T-HmU&t=375s
For most of my criticism, I follow Albert R. Mele’s work “Free: Why Science Hasn’t Disproved Free Will” (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014).
A big THANK YOU to my friend Dan Miller who helped me a great deal to think carefully about the issues pertaining to free will and determinism.
0:00 Intro & Disclaimers
2:37 Libet's Study
6:01 Problem #1: Libet vs Stephen
8:44 Problem #2: Random vs Non-random Decisions
12:11 Problem #3: 50% Data Missing!
15:56 Preview
--- YOU MIGHT ALSO ENJOY ---
The Trinity in the Old Testament: youtu.be/nBOnFI7VaGY
My Cumulative Case Against Cosmic Skeptic: youtu.be/i44EOOtiAes
Cosmic Skeptic EXPOSED: He's Got NO ETHICS At All! youtu.be/L117Iw9Gh4M
Basics of Intelligent Design: Still NO Fossils!!? youtube.com/watch?v=z-F8NJgLAkA&t=2s
Does the Trinity Make Sense? youtu.be/VUJm0ga424Q
A Lovely Conversation with Apostate Prophet: youtu.be/c-xXUcYzZo4
Basics of Intelligent Design: Darwin’s Nightmare: youtu.be/KZpIXDjXzHw
The Reason Why The Christian Story MUST Be TRUE (The Peterson-Fry Conversation): youtu.be/egjZxQ2E9ow
Cosmic Skeptic’s Ethics is Utterly ABSURD! youtu.be/1Zc4zHI6_6k
Do Churches Influence You Emotionally? Yes & No: youtu.be/FeVyJqjLTLg
No, It's ALEX's Problem: He DEBUNKED Atheism! youtu.be/g2S-oWzk-Ns
THIS Is Why People Are Leaving the Church! (The Peterson-Barron Conversation): youtu.be/1T35glENMyQ
How Women & Coca-Cola Prove the RESURRECTION: youtu.be/yNaVLNSrB_A
YOUR STORY and MY STORY Converge HERE! youtu.be/rumE_KN1TI8
CosmicSkeptic: TORN between FREE WILL, HOMOSEXUALITY & MORALITY: youtu.be/2mJi7uhJSGQ
Why Neuroscience CANNOT Debunk the Immaterial Soul – Interview with JP Moreland: youtu.be/Phu8yMOUzAY
Why Being Skeptical Proves that God Exists: The Free-Thinking Argument with Dr. Tim Stratton: youtu.be/pSs0xhyvniU
Atheism REALLY IS a BELIEF according to PHILOSOPHERS ("Atheism is NOT a Belief" – DEBUNKED #3): youtu.be/XeiXA10U96c
SLAVERY in the BIBLE: THIS is what you NEED to KNOW – Interview with PAUL COPAN: youtu.be/-CIeBCv_h2A
Why ATHEISM Really IS a BELIEF (and the LOGICAL Problems of Saying it’s NOT)!: youtu.be/730ZdM-k1vk
My Interview with WILLIAM LANE CRAIG on CHRISTIAN EXCLUSIVISM: youtu.be/7wGswSbXYmk
RELIGIOUS Beliefs are NOTHING BUT the Result of EVOLUTION!: youtu.be/ulM-rNj6wuI
Rationality Rules is WRONG About MATH and GOD: youtu.be/dC7UAMwLfqE
On the Crusades, Corruption in the Church and other Religious Evils - youtu.be/5TAYu8RM1jM
Belief in God is just a Psychological Crutch - DEBUNKED: youtu.be/9sfhMGwOl1k
Rationality Rules and the Great Cost of the Kalam - DEBUNKED: youtu.be/TeWCOLbUTVw
The Problem of Evil Assumes God's Existence: youtu.be/nwCtgQ71KV4
The claim that neuroscience has debunked free will has become fairly widespread and Rationality Rules, one of the most prominent atheist YouTubers, is at the forefront preaching this exact message. He proclaims that “science is telling us loud and clear and unequivocally that while our feelings of free will are real free will itself is an illusion.” His case is based on what are arguable the two most often-cited studies in neuroscience which presumably showed that determinism is true and free will doesn’t exist (which means that by watching my video you’ll not only get to see my response to @rationalityrules but you’ll learn about the nuts and bolts that are behind the popular claim that neuroscience has debunked free will). The first one is the work of Benjamin Libet, a pioneering neuroscientist who published a groundbreaking study in the early 1980s. The second one is the work of Chun Siong Soon. This video is part #1 of my response to Stephen’s case (part #2 will follow later) and it deals exclusively with Stephen’s treatment of Libet’s work. One of the most eye-opening lessons you will learn is that Benjamin Libet himself never thought of his work as providing evidence for determinism and against free will. Quite the opposite, actually. This means that Rationality Rules has essentially hijacked and abused Libet’s work for a case that Libet himself would never have supported. But that’s just the tip of the iceberg… I hope you will enjoy this video which deals with a key theme in Christian apologetics and in debates between skeptics and Christians.
Stephen's original video: youtube.com/watch?v=j4Oyi1T-HmU&t=375s
For most of my criticism, I follow Albert R. Mele’s work “Free: Why Science Hasn’t Disproved Free Will” (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014).
A big THANK YOU to my friend Dan Miller who helped me a great deal to think carefully about the issues pertaining to free will and determinism.
0:00 Intro & Disclaimers
2:37 Libet's Study
6:01 Problem #1: Libet vs Stephen
8:44 Problem #2: Random vs Non-random Decisions
12:11 Problem #3: 50% Data Missing!
15:56 Preview
--- YOU MIGHT ALSO ENJOY ---
The Trinity in the Old Testament: youtu.be/nBOnFI7VaGY
My Cumulative Case Against Cosmic Skeptic: youtu.be/i44EOOtiAes
Cosmic Skeptic EXPOSED: He's Got NO ETHICS At All! youtu.be/L117Iw9Gh4M
Basics of Intelligent Design: Still NO Fossils!!? youtube.com/watch?v=z-F8NJgLAkA&t=2s
Does the Trinity Make Sense? youtu.be/VUJm0ga424Q
A Lovely Conversation with Apostate Prophet: youtu.be/c-xXUcYzZo4
Basics of Intelligent Design: Darwin’s Nightmare: youtu.be/KZpIXDjXzHw
The Reason Why The Christian Story MUST Be TRUE (The Peterson-Fry Conversation): youtu.be/egjZxQ2E9ow
Cosmic Skeptic’s Ethics is Utterly ABSURD! youtu.be/1Zc4zHI6_6k
Do Churches Influence You Emotionally? Yes & No: youtu.be/FeVyJqjLTLg
No, It's ALEX's Problem: He DEBUNKED Atheism! youtu.be/g2S-oWzk-Ns
THIS Is Why People Are Leaving the Church! (The Peterson-Barron Conversation): youtu.be/1T35glENMyQ
How Women & Coca-Cola Prove the RESURRECTION: youtu.be/yNaVLNSrB_A
YOUR STORY and MY STORY Converge HERE! youtu.be/rumE_KN1TI8
CosmicSkeptic: TORN between FREE WILL, HOMOSEXUALITY & MORALITY: youtu.be/2mJi7uhJSGQ
Why Neuroscience CANNOT Debunk the Immaterial Soul – Interview with JP Moreland: youtu.be/Phu8yMOUzAY
Why Being Skeptical Proves that God Exists: The Free-Thinking Argument with Dr. Tim Stratton: youtu.be/pSs0xhyvniU
Atheism REALLY IS a BELIEF according to PHILOSOPHERS ("Atheism is NOT a Belief" – DEBUNKED #3): youtu.be/XeiXA10U96c
SLAVERY in the BIBLE: THIS is what you NEED to KNOW – Interview with PAUL COPAN: youtu.be/-CIeBCv_h2A
Why ATHEISM Really IS a BELIEF (and the LOGICAL Problems of Saying it’s NOT)!: youtu.be/730ZdM-k1vk
My Interview with WILLIAM LANE CRAIG on CHRISTIAN EXCLUSIVISM: youtu.be/7wGswSbXYmk
RELIGIOUS Beliefs are NOTHING BUT the Result of EVOLUTION!: youtu.be/ulM-rNj6wuI
Rationality Rules is WRONG About MATH and GOD: youtu.be/dC7UAMwLfqE
On the Crusades, Corruption in the Church and other Religious Evils - youtu.be/5TAYu8RM1jM
Belief in God is just a Psychological Crutch - DEBUNKED: youtu.be/9sfhMGwOl1k
Rationality Rules and the Great Cost of the Kalam - DEBUNKED: youtu.be/TeWCOLbUTVw
The Problem of Evil Assumes God's Existence: youtu.be/nwCtgQ71KV4










