Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 13 hours ago
Is Star Citizen actually a SCAM?
That's a word I keep seeing in my comments whenever we talk about Star Citizen. People call it a scam, vaporware, a tech demo, a game that will never release... so today we're going to actually talk about it.
First, we're reacting to videos from some of Star Citizen's critics and hearing their arguments. Are they raising legitimate concerns about Cloud Imperium Games, development time, funding, bugs and Squadron 42? Or has the “Star Citizen is a scam” argument become an easy way to dismiss what is actually playable today?
And instead of just arguing about it...
We're going to PLAY IT. 😂
We're jumping into Star Citizen and attempting to actually get some gameplay done while keeping track of everything that goes wrong.
Every elevator that betrays us. Every broken mission. Every bizarre NPC. Every server problem. Every genuine bug we encounter gets added to the evidence.
But we're also going to give Star Citizen credit when it works — because some of the experiences I've had in this game are unlike anything I've experienced in another space sim.
As a long-time Elite Dangerous Commander who's been spending a lot more time discovering Star Citizen, I'm interested in separating the memes from the reality.
Is Star Citizen really a scam?
Or is it an incredibly ambitious game with an incredibly complicated development history that has given people plenty of legitimate reasons to be skeptical?
Let's find out together.
💬 QUESTION FOR CHAT:
What would Star Citizen actually need to deliver before YOU considered the project a success?
And if you've never played it — would you spend $45 to try Star Citizen today?
Grab a drink, join the discussion and prepare the bug counter. I have a feeling we're going to need it. 😂
o7 Commanders & Citizens! 🚀
#StarCitizen #StarCitizenLive #Squadron42 #EliteDangerous #SpaceGames
Is Star Citizen actually a SCAM?
That's a word I keep seeing in my comments whenever we talk about Star Citizen. People call it a scam, vaporware, a tech demo, a game that will never release... so today we're going to actually talk about it.
First, we're reacting to videos from some of Star Citizen's critics and hearing their arguments. Are they raising legitimate concerns about Cloud Imperium Games, development time, funding, bugs and Squadron 42? Or has the “Star Citizen is a scam” argument become an easy way to dismiss what is actually playable today?
And instead of just arguing about it...
We're going to PLAY IT. 😂
We're jumping into Star Citizen and attempting to actually get some gameplay done while keeping track of everything that goes wrong.
Every elevator that betrays us. Every broken mission. Every bizarre NPC. Every server problem. Every genuine bug we encounter gets added to the evidence.
But we're also going to give Star Citizen credit when it works — because some of the experiences I've had in this game are unlike anything I've experienced in another space sim.
As a long-time Elite Dangerous Commander who's been spending a lot more time discovering Star Citizen, I'm interested in separating the memes from the reality.
Is Star Citizen really a scam?
Or is it an incredibly ambitious game with an incredibly complicated development history that has given people plenty of legitimate reasons to be skeptical?
Let's find out together.
💬 QUESTION FOR CHAT:
What would Star Citizen actually need to deliver before YOU considered the project a success?
And if you've never played it — would you spend $45 to try Star Citizen today?
Grab a drink, join the discussion and prepare the bug counter. I have a feeling we're going to need it. 😂
o7 Commanders & Citizens! 🚀
#StarCitizen #StarCitizenLive #Squadron42 #EliteDangerous #SpaceGames










