Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Catholic Identity Conference 2027 -- now open for early-bird registration: catholicidentityconference.org/index.php/cic2027-register-today
Donate to keep the videos FREE: remnantnewspaper.com/donate-today
In his first major public debrief since the SSPX’s July episcopal consecrations, U.S. District Communications Director James Vogel takes on the controversy head-on. Why does the SSPX believe a state of necessity exists? Does disobedience necessarily mean schism? And what are the deeper principles at stake in the battle over Tradition? Hear the SSPX’s case directly from the inside, in a candid exchange with Michael Matt at CIC 2026.
0:00 Michael Matt: Where Is the Line in the Sand?
2:51 James Vogel: Why the SSPX Is So Controversial
7:53 The Crisis in the Church—and Why It Matters
12:49 Catholic Obedience: When Can a Catholic Resist Authority?
18:21 What Does “Full Communion” With the Church Mean?
24:00 Can Church Authority Be Resisted in a Crisis?
32:35 The SSPX Case for a “State of Necessity”
38:16 Michael Matt Asks: Is the SSPX Really in Schism?
42:45 Are the New Bishops Creating a “Parallel Church”?
46:12 Michael Matt on Tradition, the TLM, and Working With Diocesan Priests
Subscribe to Remnant Newspaper: remnantnewspaper.com/subscribe
Support Us: remnantnewspaper.com/donate-today
Sign up for Michael Matt's Weekly E-Letter: remnantnewspaper.com/free-remnant-updates
Follow Michael Matt on X: https://x.com/Michael_J_Matt
Check out my website: remnantnewspaper.com
Listen to Michael Matt's podcasts:
SPOTIFY: open.spotify.com/show/1AdkCDFfR736CqcGw2Uvd0
APPLE: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-michael-j-matt-show/id1563298989
Catholic Identity Conference 2027 -- now open for early-bird registration: catholicidentityconference.org/index.php/cic2027-register-today
Donate to keep the videos FREE: remnantnewspaper.com/donate-today
In his first major public debrief since the SSPX’s July episcopal consecrations, U.S. District Communications Director James Vogel takes on the controversy head-on. Why does the SSPX believe a state of necessity exists? Does disobedience necessarily mean schism? And what are the deeper principles at stake in the battle over Tradition? Hear the SSPX’s case directly from the inside, in a candid exchange with Michael Matt at CIC 2026.
0:00 Michael Matt: Where Is the Line in the Sand?
2:51 James Vogel: Why the SSPX Is So Controversial
7:53 The Crisis in the Church—and Why It Matters
12:49 Catholic Obedience: When Can a Catholic Resist Authority?
18:21 What Does “Full Communion” With the Church Mean?
24:00 Can Church Authority Be Resisted in a Crisis?
32:35 The SSPX Case for a “State of Necessity”
38:16 Michael Matt Asks: Is the SSPX Really in Schism?
42:45 Are the New Bishops Creating a “Parallel Church”?
46:12 Michael Matt on Tradition, the TLM, and Working With Diocesan Priests
Subscribe to Remnant Newspaper: remnantnewspaper.com/subscribe
Support Us: remnantnewspaper.com/donate-today
Sign up for Michael Matt's Weekly E-Letter: remnantnewspaper.com/free-remnant-updates
Follow Michael Matt on X: https://x.com/Michael_J_Matt
Check out my website: remnantnewspaper.com
Listen to Michael Matt's podcasts:
SPOTIFY: open.spotify.com/show/1AdkCDFfR736CqcGw2Uvd0
APPLE: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-michael-j-matt-show/id1563298989








