Uploaded May 2014 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
An ETH sponsored meeting and debate between Nassim Taleb and Didier Sornette. Edited to eliminate the parts of the conversation not involving either but otherwise comprehensive.
A "diplomatic debate" is defined by Taleb as a conversation in which one looks for synthesis (as opposed to one in which one is trying, as in war, to win the argument, as with political debates). Clearly this type of debate only works when the two parties have mutual respect for each other.
An ETH sponsored meeting and debate between Nassim Taleb and Didier Sornette. Edited to eliminate the parts of the conversation not involving either but otherwise comprehensive.
A "diplomatic debate" is defined by Taleb as a conversation in which one looks for synthesis (as opposed to one in which one is trying, as in war, to win the argument, as with political debates). Clearly this type of debate only works when the two parties have mutual respect for each other.

![A medical paper that does not replicate. Why?
Case study in non-replicability of a medical paper. I discuss it with Dr. Fouad Fayad from U.S.J. in Lebanon. Details are in Retraction Watch: apparently the only reply to his case by the lead author is of the fact-free data-free sort he doesnt like me which does not appear to have a statistical explanation (nor does it explain why the paper does not replicate).
https://retractionwatch.com/2022/08/04/doctor-faces-apparent-retaliation-after-alleging-data-manipulation-in-published-trial/
Note: Retraction Watch did a great job presenting facts, as well as the attempt to retaliate against Dr. Fayad. Note that the 4 expert reports were not attached [I attach them below]. Also note that the paper violated FDA rules (and those of the corresponding European agency).
Expert reports finding evidence of manipulation and confirming Dr Fayads claim are at https://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/Fayad.pdf A medical paper that does not replicate. Why?](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/wyFyKzT9FVg/mqdefault.jpg)





