Should You Always Give to the Poor? @BrianHoldsworth
Should You Always Give to the Poor?  @BrianHoldsworth
Uploaded September 2025 | Updated November 2026, 14 hours ago
Are modern panhandlers the same as the begging poor of Jesus' time?

Sponsor: realestateforlife.org
Join: brianholdsworth.locals.com

Christians today face a real dilemma at every street corner: how do we obey Christ’s command to love the poor without enabling vice or being naïve about modern homelessness? In this video, I reflect on how panhandling in our cities differs from the “begging poor” of biblical times, explain why Christian concern for the poor is unique, and draw on St. Thomas Aquinas and Scripture to show how prudence and mercy work together. If you’ve ever wondered whether to hand cash to a panhandler or how to direct your almsgiving, this episode offers a thoughtful, Catholic perspective.

0:00 – Introduction: Jesus identifies with the poor
1:29 – Homelessness today
3:16 – A uniquely Christian concern
7:14 – The poor in Jesus' time
8:27 – Panhandling vs. institutional safety nets today
10:19 – Substance abuse and vice
12:07 – St. Thomas Aquinas answers
12:43 – Justice vs. mercy
14:04 – Scriptural support for prudence in giving
14:00 – Order of Love

Music written and generously provided by Paul Jernberg. Find out more about his work as a composer here: pauljernberg.com

Podcast Version: brianholdsworth.libsyn.com
Should You Always Give to the Poor?No Christianity, No Science!The Problem With Women PriestsIf the Screwtape Letters Were Written TodayIs Christianity Going Mainstream?How to Tell Fake Catholics vs Bad CatholicsThe Infinite Regress Argument Against CatholicismWhen Hopes Fail to Satisfy UsThe Harsh Truth About Invalid SacramentsWhy Are Modern Churches So Ugly and Why it Matters?Asking ChatGPT About Church HistoryIs NFP Evil?
Brian Holdsworth |

Should You Always Give to the Poor?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER