Should Government Mandate Vaccines? Gostin vs. Carson @SteamboatInstitute
Should Government Mandate Vaccines? Gostin vs. Carson  @SteamboatInstitute
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Should the government have the power to mandate vaccines?

Steamboat Institute, in partnership with ASU's School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership, is proud to present a compelling debate on the following resolution:

Be it resolved, the government should have the power to mandate vaccines.

Arguing the affirmative is Lawrence Gostin, Distinguished University Professor and Director of the WHO Center on Global Health Law at Georgetown University.

Arguing the negative is Dr. Ben Carson, Neurosurgeon and former US Secretary of Housing and Urban Development.

Moderator is Kaylee McGhee White, Editor-in-Chief for Independent Women Features; Fox News Contributor; Steamboat Institute Fellow.

Watch live as both sides make their case, and see where the room lands.

The speakers' views are their own.
Should Government Mandate Vaccines? Gostin vs. CarsonI dont think we solve the Iran problem without a new regime in placeWhat has President Trump accomplished so far—and where has he fallen short?How Hasan Piker is pulling down those that continue to support him.What do Harvard’s students think of the United States being a global superpower?We could cut a trillion dollars out of the spending..and no one in this room would noticeGraham Platner officially exits the race, and his announcement video.Will Gen Z Turn Toward Socialism or Preserve the Blessings of Liberty?Carine on Progress in NegotiationsThose are systems of energy that we know are reliable, stable, and affordableWhat does the socialist dream offer?“This is pretty common sense”
Steamboat Institute |

Should Government Mandate Vaccines? Gostin vs. Carson

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER