Same Data, Different Politics, Different Results @HeterodoxAcademy
Same Data, Different Politics, Different Results  @HeterodoxAcademy
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
What happens when 158 social scientists get the exact same data? In a recent study, their views on immigration showed up in their results.

They worked in 71 teams, each with the same dataset and the same task: test whether immigration reduces public support for social welfare programs. Pro-immigration teams tended to find more positive effects, and anti-immigration teams more negative ones. The moderate teams found basically no effect, and peer reviewers rated their work more highly.

Did the moderates get it right? Not necessarily. No one knows the correct answer here, and moderates can be biased too. Dylan Selterman thinks the study makes the case for viewpoint diversity on research teams.

Full explainer on our channel: "Can Scientists Keep Their Politics Out of Their Results?"

Narrated by social psychologist Dylan Selterman of Heterodox Academy, from Dylan's Free the Inquiry article "Scientists Are People" (freetheinquiry.com).
Study: George J. Borjas and Nate Breznau, "Ideological bias in the production of research findings," Science Advances (2026).

#ViewpointDiversity #SocialScience #Science
Same Data, Different Politics, Different ResultsFounding Fathers Genius: Designing Society Like Engineers! #shortsHow HxA Changed My Class | Abigail SaguyHow Can We Get Viewpoint Diversity in Higher EdTeaching Viewpoint Diversity in a Divided Classroom - Jennifer TownsendThis Is Why Top Scientists Are Walking Away | Dorian AbbotCan a Public University Stay Politically Neutral? with Ed SeidelHow Ideological Bubbles Hurt Counseling Psychology - HxCanada Fall ConferenceConservative Sociology: What Is It and Do We Need It?Are Students Being Punished for Opinions?Surprising Findings from 14,000 AI-Facilitated Student ConversationsCharlie Kirk Case: Why Universities Choose Silence
Heterodox Academy |

Same Data, Different Politics, Different Results

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER