Uploaded December 2025 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
New York’s Court of Appeals denied habeas corpus to Happy the elephant, but two judges dissented. Justice Wilson argued that an animal’s qualities, not a legal label of 'person', should determine access to rights, and he rejected the idea that rights require reciprocal duties. He also dismissed fears of a flood of petitions as an inadequate reason to deny relief.
The episode summarises the dissent, points you to the Cambridge Center for Animal Rights Law for the case, and previews the next story about Cecilia the chimpanzee and a different judicial approach in Argentina.
Animal Rights Tour is written by Sean Butler, hosted by Carly McCann, and fact-checked by Paulina Siemieniec.
This podcast is produced by the Cambridge Centre for Animal Rights Law, an academic centre of competence dedicated to the study of fundamental rights for non-human animals and based in Cambridge, UK. Learn more about the Centre at animalrightslaw.org (animalrightslaw.org/) .
New York’s Court of Appeals denied habeas corpus to Happy the elephant, but two judges dissented. Justice Wilson argued that an animal’s qualities, not a legal label of 'person', should determine access to rights, and he rejected the idea that rights require reciprocal duties. He also dismissed fears of a flood of petitions as an inadequate reason to deny relief.
The episode summarises the dissent, points you to the Cambridge Center for Animal Rights Law for the case, and previews the next story about Cecilia the chimpanzee and a different judicial approach in Argentina.
Animal Rights Tour is written by Sean Butler, hosted by Carly McCann, and fact-checked by Paulina Siemieniec.
This podcast is produced by the Cambridge Centre for Animal Rights Law, an academic centre of competence dedicated to the study of fundamental rights for non-human animals and based in Cambridge, UK. Learn more about the Centre at animalrightslaw.org (animalrightslaw.org/) .









![Animal Rights Law Lecture 16 [University of Cambridge, 2021-2022]
These lectures were given in the Law Faculty at the University of Cambridge to Law students taking the Part II Tripos degree. They are made available to the public with the kind permission of the University of Cambridge.
The Cambridge Centre for Animal Rights Law is an academic centre dedicated to the study, understanding and promotion of fundamental rights for non-human animals, based in Cambridge, UK. Find more information at https://animalrightslaw.org/ Animal Rights Law Lecture 16 [University of Cambridge, 2021-2022]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/kDbkwtzpKUg/mqdefault.jpg)
![Animal Rights Law Lecture 3 [University of Cambridge, 2021-2022]
These lectures were given in the Law Faculty at the University of Cambridge to Law students taking the Part II Tripos degree. They are made available to the public with the kind permission of the University of Cambridge.
The Cambridge Centre for Animal Rights Law is an academic centre dedicated to the study, understanding and promotion of fundamental rights for non-human animals, based in Cambridge, UK. Find more information at https://animalrightslaw.org/ Animal Rights Law Lecture 3 [University of Cambridge, 2021-2022]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/kOQ85TZu6C0/mqdefault.jpg)