Uploaded November 2019 | Updated November 2026, 1 hour ago
Richard Heinberg interviewed by Michael Dowd in an episode of Dowd's "Post-doom Conversations," filmed the autumn of 2019. Title: "Living the Limits to Growth." Note: Richard Heinberg died July 2026; Michael Dowd died October 2023. They both have wikipedia pages.
00:16 - PREVIEWS
03:00 - MD (Michael Dowd): "Doom is the midpoint between denial and regeneration — with or without us. Post-doom is the space that opens up when we remember who we are, accept what's inevitable, and invest in what is pro-future and soul-nourishing."
04:33 - RH (Richard Heinberg) - summarizes his work as a writer, mostly on environmental subjects, sustainability, Post-Carbon Institute, peak oil, climate, limits to growth paradigm.
06:56 - MD: speaks of his learnings from Heinberg's writings; queries on terminology preferences
08:09 - RH: terms he uses: overshoot (Catton), collapse, historical cycles (Turchin)
10:03 - MD Q: heart of this series is recounting your journey in worldview shifts
11:44 - RH: tells his story: early exploration of spirituality, eastern religions, then anthropology for diversity of human possibilites and limitations; our species predicament; role of religion
15:48 - MD: Edward Goldsmith writings (lifeways) and Ronald Wright (progress traps)
18:08 - RH: story continues; focus on fossil fuels effects on society and destruction
20:10 - MD: shared mentorship by the late Jay Hanson (overshoot loop); Walter Youngquist
20:42 - RH: learnings from Goldsmith, Youngquist, Hanson, Catton; fracking studies
23:14 - RH: shift in focus of Post-Carbon Institute to climate change; economic constraints
24:12 - MD: role in helping 2nd edition of Walter Youngquist's "GeoDestinies"
25:14 - MD Q: How has the larger perspective of life history informed you?
25:52 - RH: Big Picture is background, not foreground except now for "Fermi Paradox". His own solution to the paradox is that fossil fuel equivalents inherently promote overuse, overshoot, collapse (or conscious self-limitation).
28:51 - MD: We wrongly attribute "advanced" and "progress" to things that will be our undoing.
29:52 - RH: Human language that abstracts us from reality is unique and dangerous
31:18 - MD: Walter Ong on orality to literacy shift; Paul Kingsnorth
32:02 - RH: writings as the primordial technology of language, then mechanized power
33:04 - MD: Thomas Berry critiqued "the environment" language
33:46 - RH: that "the economy" takes precedence is understandable yet dangerous
34:28 - MD Q: What is your understanding of human nature in our societal predicament?
34:44 - RH: writing now about consequences of "Maximum Power Principle" in evolution; promotes instead intentional adoption of an "Optimum Power Principle"
38:50 - RH: need to give up economic growth (Johan Rockstrom, Herman Daly); also reduce population — yet these are "thoughts that can't be entertained."
40:55 - MD Q: How have you emotionally dealt with your sense of societal contraction?
41:29 - RH: "I've had a generally pessimistic view of the human prospect my whole adult life, since first reading The Limits to Growth in 1972. My whole adult life I've spent in the place where Greta Thunberg is. ... Of course one still has hopes ... celebrate the little victories."
43:00 RH: his story of emergency evacuation in 2017 owing to Calif wildfire
46:40 MD Q: What is beyond our control and where can we still make a difference?
47:03 RH: "We don't need to know the answer." How in 1970s deeply affected by Hindu story of Krishna and Arjuna ... "Life is a battlefield. Enter it and take selfless action. Do good for good's sake. Don't be attached to the results."
50:22 MD Q: Gifts experienced "on the other side of the post-doom doorway"?
50:59 RH: Most regenerative is connecting with other people who share his perspective; also his playing the violin, "If human life is worth preserving, then we should focus on what makes it worth preserving" ... actions that "produce great beauty."
Youtube playlist of all Post-Doom video conversations:
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLcAlqMeyeaW91q0fUuOWHKEaGTCL41ItE
Post-Doom Conversations website (videos, audios, and resources):
postdoom.com
Richard Heinberg's website:
richardheinberg.com
PostCarbon Institute:
postcarbon.org
Richard Heinberg interviewed by Michael Dowd in an episode of Dowd's "Post-doom Conversations," filmed the autumn of 2019. Title: "Living the Limits to Growth." Note: Richard Heinberg died July 2026; Michael Dowd died October 2023. They both have wikipedia pages.
00:16 - PREVIEWS
03:00 - MD (Michael Dowd): "Doom is the midpoint between denial and regeneration — with or without us. Post-doom is the space that opens up when we remember who we are, accept what's inevitable, and invest in what is pro-future and soul-nourishing."
04:33 - RH (Richard Heinberg) - summarizes his work as a writer, mostly on environmental subjects, sustainability, Post-Carbon Institute, peak oil, climate, limits to growth paradigm.
06:56 - MD: speaks of his learnings from Heinberg's writings; queries on terminology preferences
08:09 - RH: terms he uses: overshoot (Catton), collapse, historical cycles (Turchin)
10:03 - MD Q: heart of this series is recounting your journey in worldview shifts
11:44 - RH: tells his story: early exploration of spirituality, eastern religions, then anthropology for diversity of human possibilites and limitations; our species predicament; role of religion
15:48 - MD: Edward Goldsmith writings (lifeways) and Ronald Wright (progress traps)
18:08 - RH: story continues; focus on fossil fuels effects on society and destruction
20:10 - MD: shared mentorship by the late Jay Hanson (overshoot loop); Walter Youngquist
20:42 - RH: learnings from Goldsmith, Youngquist, Hanson, Catton; fracking studies
23:14 - RH: shift in focus of Post-Carbon Institute to climate change; economic constraints
24:12 - MD: role in helping 2nd edition of Walter Youngquist's "GeoDestinies"
25:14 - MD Q: How has the larger perspective of life history informed you?
25:52 - RH: Big Picture is background, not foreground except now for "Fermi Paradox". His own solution to the paradox is that fossil fuel equivalents inherently promote overuse, overshoot, collapse (or conscious self-limitation).
28:51 - MD: We wrongly attribute "advanced" and "progress" to things that will be our undoing.
29:52 - RH: Human language that abstracts us from reality is unique and dangerous
31:18 - MD: Walter Ong on orality to literacy shift; Paul Kingsnorth
32:02 - RH: writings as the primordial technology of language, then mechanized power
33:04 - MD: Thomas Berry critiqued "the environment" language
33:46 - RH: that "the economy" takes precedence is understandable yet dangerous
34:28 - MD Q: What is your understanding of human nature in our societal predicament?
34:44 - RH: writing now about consequences of "Maximum Power Principle" in evolution; promotes instead intentional adoption of an "Optimum Power Principle"
38:50 - RH: need to give up economic growth (Johan Rockstrom, Herman Daly); also reduce population — yet these are "thoughts that can't be entertained."
40:55 - MD Q: How have you emotionally dealt with your sense of societal contraction?
41:29 - RH: "I've had a generally pessimistic view of the human prospect my whole adult life, since first reading The Limits to Growth in 1972. My whole adult life I've spent in the place where Greta Thunberg is. ... Of course one still has hopes ... celebrate the little victories."
43:00 RH: his story of emergency evacuation in 2017 owing to Calif wildfire
46:40 MD Q: What is beyond our control and where can we still make a difference?
47:03 RH: "We don't need to know the answer." How in 1970s deeply affected by Hindu story of Krishna and Arjuna ... "Life is a battlefield. Enter it and take selfless action. Do good for good's sake. Don't be attached to the results."
50:22 MD Q: Gifts experienced "on the other side of the post-doom doorway"?
50:59 RH: Most regenerative is connecting with other people who share his perspective; also his playing the violin, "If human life is worth preserving, then we should focus on what makes it worth preserving" ... actions that "produce great beauty."
Youtube playlist of all Post-Doom video conversations:
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLcAlqMeyeaW91q0fUuOWHKEaGTCL41ItE
Post-Doom Conversations website (videos, audios, and resources):
postdoom.com
Richard Heinberg's website:
richardheinberg.com
PostCarbon Institute:
postcarbon.org
![Terry Patten: Post-doom with Michael Dowd
Terry Patten interviewed by Michael Dowd in an episode of Dowds Post-doom Conversations, filmed November 2019. Title: Light on the Other Side. Time-coded list of topics:
00:18 PREVIEWS
03:32 MD (Michael Dowd) - introduction to the Post-doom series and Terrys role as a leader in the realm of Integral philosophy
05:10 TP (Terry Patten) - summarizes his life and mentors since childhood, his entry into human potential movement, and his early years in an ashram. Problem: The focus on subjective transformation did not loop back into his childhood family experience of social responsibility. Collaboration with Ken Wilber, coauthorship of Integral Life Practice. Ecological concern compelled his 2018 book, A New Republic of the Heart.
09:55 TP - Not doom or post-doom. Rather, not-knowing; the future is emergent. How can I make myself a vessel through which emergence might take place? But positive orientation can easily slip into denial — in me and in everyone, so important to reckon with what is real.
13:03 MD - intent of Post-Doom term.
13:51 TP - shares with MD the loss of myth of progress, and thus feels kinship with Deep Adaptation Forum and Shaun Chamberlin.
15:40 MD - mentions books of John Michael Greer, William Catton, and how post-doom focus is expressed by Roy Scrantons title, Were Doomed; Now What? but beginning only with societal collapse — not necessarily human extinction. Respects Pattens call for epistemic humility.
17:28 TP - It is such a profound voyage to let go of the certainty of a future like we knew. Personal story of his giving up a sense of legacy from book writing. It is crushing of so many of the sources of meaning that we have had. The challenge is, when giving up the old narrative to not fall into the comfort of thinking there is something knowable about a new narrative. Could be technological breakthroughs, consciousness breakthroughs, shift in human presence in ecologies.
21:03 MD - not epistemically humble on the felt need for humanity to align with ecology; ecology as the new theology; must live within the carrying capacity of Earth; must regain intimate relationship with time
23:32 TP - reflection pros and cons on Jem Bendell Deep Adapation paper; helped mediate when Jeremy Lent attacked Bendells paper. Key problem: A belief in collapse [as inevitable] could help bring about collapse. Yet, we do know that the current trajectory will be interrupted — which is a shock in itself. Important to encourage emotional processing in community. They are our honest brothers and sisters within an honest, heart-felt reckoning with reality.
30:01 TP - Im not interested in flimsy hopefulness on this side of that dark night; I continue to go through this dark night journey ... the light on the other side of the darkness is so different; lets not confuse them ... this culture of denial makes us feel so lonely; we need more fellowship among people who are taking seriously our moral responsibility to the future of life.
31:12 TP - Personal transformation still necessary, but the inner work needs to be connected to outer work: to do what we can do to help. Also need the interpersonal work. Think of this predicament as an infinitely deep Zen koan: we are stopped, and then transformed by having been counfounded. No individual response will be adequate.
33:20 TP - Challenges Dowd: This is asking me to change, and its even asking me to ask you to change.... so that together we can become a catalyst for something that has never happened before.... evolutionary emergence ... not a blame game, even in the midst of what is so wrong.
36:11 TP - Can something come out of [all this learning and discovery] so that there are seeds for the future, so that this result is not just ugly.
37:26 MD - There are many ways into a post-doom heart and mind. Joanna Macy and Richard Rohr both agreed post-doom is a timely meme.
40:00 TP - 3 groups consider future: ecologists / innovators / evolutionaries
44:39 TP - challenges Dowd to be less certain (Y2K experience)
47:50 TP - recites stanza from Drew Dellinger poem, once you knew, what did you do? Problem of finding redemption within a middle class lifestyle; what risks to take
49:25 TP - Both Arctic and Amazon are burning. Conversation with Karen OBrien (scientist)
50:35 MD - If I can be at peace with a worst-case scenario, then it has no power over me. .. My faith is in life; it is no longer human-centered.
53:13 TP: potential for us to navigate this evolutionary squeeze point [and keep it going] ... a teleological pull
57:07 - several photos from Ghost Ranch NM 2016
Youtube playlist of all Post-Doom video conversations:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLcAlqMeyeaW91q0fUuOWHKEaGTCL41ItE
Post-Doom Conversations website (videos, audios, and resources):
https://www.postdoom.com/
Terrys website:
https://www.terrypatten.com/ Terry Patten: Post-doom with Michael Dowd](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/VOGTH6CZJ8k/mqdefault.jpg)




![Daniel Dancer: Post-doom with Connie Barlow and Michael Dowd
Postdoom conversation filmed July 2019; edited August 2020.
00:05 Title: An Apology and a Promise • 2 previews and introduction
02:09 Q by Michael Dowd (MD): What does the term post-doom bring to mind for you? A: Daniel Dancer (DD) - accepting that collapse is imminent ... the tipping points have been crossed ... Ive always liked the Bahais word for collapse: The Grand Chastisement.
03:37 DD: I have life-centered hope big-time for the planet; I trust the arc of evolution.
05:01 Q by Connie Barlow (CB): How can you be working with kids on this topic in such a joyful way?
06:29 DD: Story of his solo environmental art made of found objects. His book, Desperate Prayers, describes putting prayer into form on ravaged ecosystems, as an appeal to the Mystery for healing — and as a way to apologize for my species for what weve done.
07:24 DD: Story of how he got the idea of Art for the Sky when he collaborated with crop artist Stan Herd in Kansas (a book resulted from that). A boy who had been one of 500 kids who formed the beads on the headband of the 25 acre Indian filmed from the sky.... said it was the only thing he remembered from elementary school. So that ignited something within me: to start doing this in schools. Collaboration with Bill McKibben entailed putting the number 350 into each project [and teaching kids why that number is important]. And then I started putting the current number in — using art to track whats happening with the climate.
10:20 Graphic of The 6 Teachings DD gives to teachers for understanding the range of learnings available from the project: Intention, Gratitude, Collaboration, Sky Sight, Impermanence, and Interconnection.
10:45 DD: I love working with kids; theres so much joy and innocence. In the final assembly I always apologize to them for the world that theyve inherited from us — that we dropped the ball. Theres things that could have been done that we didnt do. And they also know that each image thats created is an apology to the Earth and Sky for how weve treated the planet and a promise to do better.
11:45 DD: Theres always a ton of joy — even though I doubt that theyll be able to live out their natural lives.... Its all the more reason to bring joy and to celebrate the sky and our need to change.
12:20 Q: In 2000 you werent apologizing to the kids already were you? DD: Oh, yes. Ive always apologized for the kind of planet weve left them.
12:32 DD tells the story of his awareness of human impacts since age 9 (he was 68 at the time of this interview). His father taught one of the first environmental studies classes in California. The first big word I learned to spell was apocalypse, and all the reports I did at school were on overpopulation, deforestation, global warming.
14:14 DD: Gathering photos for book produced by Doug Tompkins, Overdevelopment, Overpopulation, Overshoot. Dave Foreman in early days of Earth First was a hero for DD, so he learned then of Catton, Paul Shepard, and Gary Snyder.
15:01 DD and MD: clip of their 2018 phone conversation with Guy McPherson.
16:45 CB: Reflects on past experiences with DD, Youre such a joyful person. I never knew I could talk with you about this!
17:16 DD: His experience working with Tompkins, gathering photos for the OverOverOver book. I did a lot of grieving when I did that book... now Im sort of past the grieving stage.... It just heightens everything; puts me in kind of a sweet spot — now I just bless and apologize all at the same time.
20:13 CB: reads from DD website, Each Sky Art creation begins with an intention to make the world a better place for the creature we embody on the field, to be kind to our schoolmates, to always do our best, and to begin a new relationship with the Sky.
21:42 DD: I was conceived in the redwoods. CB reflects on how DDs life story comes together in his Art for the Sky projects.
23:09 Kant on seeing the whole first. DD: We need to learn to see through the eyes of all beings and through the eyes of future generations. DD: quotes Mad Farmers Manifesto by Wendell Berry: Be joyful though you have considered all the facts. Expect the end of the world. Laugh. Practice resurrection.
25:38 CB quotes from DD webpage: The experience of BEING the art ... and then releasing it — is a lesson in impermanence. DD: Its a preview of collapse ... a blessing, a celebration, an apology.
27:42 MD narrates the the big picture response DD wrote: that learning history of civilizational collapses brings forth equanimity.
30:00 CB and DD on importance of boomers apologizing to kids. David Holmgrens The Apology as exemplar.
35:24 MD narrates DD writing: Death is the mother of beauty.... To live and say goodbye within the question, celebrating at every turn the beauty and blessing of having been alive on Earth feels like my highest calling.
39:58 Daniels music video, Get Your Skysight On.
Website: Postdoom.com Daniel Dancer: Post-doom with Connie Barlow and Michael Dowd](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/X9wtQCEF_eM/mqdefault.jpg)




