Uploaded September 2023 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
In April 2023, twenty-nine prominent scholars published a public letter in the Journal of Controversial Ideas titled, "In Defense of Merit in Science." The question raises itself: Merit in science is a controversial idea?
"In Defense of Merit in Science" is an eloquent statement of a principle: science can only thrive if it embodies the best minds, who are allowed unfettered access to scientific frontiers. Yet, the academic science ecosystem is increasingly dominated by an administrative class that seeks to control scientists and curtail their freedom. This raises a second question: How can the principle effectively be defended? Can scientists do it from within the academy? Can faculty wrest their independence back?
Join the National Association of Scholars on Friday, September 15, at 4 pm ET to discuss "Does Merit Matter?"
This event will feature Bernhardt L. Trout, Professor of Chemical Engineering at MIT, and Luana Maroja, Professor of Biology at Williams College. The event will be moderated by Scott Turner.
In April 2023, twenty-nine prominent scholars published a public letter in the Journal of Controversial Ideas titled, "In Defense of Merit in Science." The question raises itself: Merit in science is a controversial idea?
"In Defense of Merit in Science" is an eloquent statement of a principle: science can only thrive if it embodies the best minds, who are allowed unfettered access to scientific frontiers. Yet, the academic science ecosystem is increasingly dominated by an administrative class that seeks to control scientists and curtail their freedom. This raises a second question: How can the principle effectively be defended? Can scientists do it from within the academy? Can faculty wrest their independence back?
Join the National Association of Scholars on Friday, September 15, at 4 pm ET to discuss "Does Merit Matter?"
This event will feature Bernhardt L. Trout, Professor of Chemical Engineering at MIT, and Luana Maroja, Professor of Biology at Williams College. The event will be moderated by Scott Turner.





![Subboor Ahmad: On the Intersection of Science and Faith
In this episode of One Universe, Two Books, Subboor Ahmad joins Scott Turner and Ian Oxnevad to explore the complex relationship between science, religion, and philosophy, focusing on evolution, teleology, and the role of faith in scientific discovery.
Subboor Ahmad is a prominent British Muslin who has a particular interest in the relationship of Islam with science.
They discuss historical perspectives, the impact of Darwin, and the potential for faith and science to collaborate on existential questions about consciousness and purpose.
One important issue in the interface of science and faith is the issue of mind, namely is there a mind at work in the structure and function of the universe. The question is acute for the living world, which seems more intuitively to be at work in life. Is it possible to apply the epistemology of materialism and reduction to the scientific study of something that has a mind of its own?
#science
#religion
#evolution
#teleology
#faith
#philosophy
#Darwin
#natural philosophy
#secularism
#theology
key topics
The historical relationship between science and religion
Darwins impact on secularism and atheism
The role of teleology and design in biology
The potential for faith to inform scientific discovery
The philosophical limits of scientific explanation
The relationship between Islam, Christianity, and science
The cultural shift from religious to secular worldviews
The importance of dialogue between faith and science
sound bites
Evidence of good design is everywhere in nature.
Darwins mechanism provided a satisfying explanation for many.
Science has become the default worldview in our culture.
Chapters
00:00 Introduction and guest introduction
01:34 Personal backgrounds and perspectives on evolution
04:00 Historical relationship between science and religion
07:25 Design in biology and cultural perceptions
10:34 Darwins influence and the materialist shift
13:35 The cultural and historical impact of Darwinism
16:19 Science as a new religion and secularization
22:50 The concept of mind and consciousness in science and faith
33:29 The role of faith in scientific pursuit and moral values
36:35 The potential for collaboration between faiths on existential issues
52:29 The relationship between Islam, Christianity, and science
55:54 The moral and societal implications of secularism and scientism
01:00:07 The role of purpose and design in biology and evolution
01:02:04 The diversity of views within faith communities on evolution
01:04:07 Closing remarks and appreciation.
[Show notes partly compiled by AI.] Subboor Ahmad: On the Intersection of Science and Faith](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/vxlEawJn95w/mqdefault.jpg)




