Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Can a pastor who lost his platform over a moral failing come back to ministry, and who gets to tell that story? Esau, Mike, and Malcolm discuss a new book and a Wall Street Journal feature from former Hillsong NYC pastor Carl Lentz and his wife, who say they've decided to stay together after Carl had multiple affairs.
Mike recounts the background and notes that Lentz describes the relationship as consensual while one of the women involved does not. Esau shares his own philosophy, that a pastor who crosses a boundary with a member of his congregation faces a lifetime disqualification. He also explains why he doubts anyone should monetize a story that involves people who didn't agree to take part. Mike argues that redemption doesn't mean the absence of consequences and that pastors can turn the role into an idol, and Malcolm describes a pastoral culture that prizes charisma over character and points to Jesus's rebuke of the Pharisees.
π¬ Can someone return to ministry after they've had a moral failing? What do you think, and how should the church balance grace with accountability? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.
Watch the full episode here π youtu.be/B8uS1Me_2Ko
0:00 β A Pastor's New Book on Infidelity
1:25 β Can Carl Lentz Return to Ministry?
2:29 β A Lifetime Disqualification
3:26 β Should This Story Be Monetized?
5:21 β Would Giving the Money Away Help?
7:05 β The Boss Who Wrote a Book
7:48 β Counseling After Infidelity
8:37 β Must You Live It to Teach It?
9:31 β Redemption Doesn't Erase Consequences
10:24 β When Pastoring Becomes an Idol
10:48 β Disqualification, Not a Time-Out
11:36 β Esau's Position on Affairs
12:31 β Why Clergy Scandals Weigh on Esau
13:15 β Charisma Over Character
14:53 β Marriage as a Picture of Christ
16:15 β Celebrity Culture and Pastors
17:08 β Humility and the Pharisees
Resources and Links:
β Join Holy Post Plus for bonus content, extended interviews, and much more! Sign up today at holypost.com/plus
π§‘ Support us on Patreon: patreon.com/holypost
π° Join the Holy Post Substack: holypost.substack.com
π Holy Post Website: holypost.com
π Holy Post Merch Store: holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
π Like & subscribe for more conversations on faith, culture, politics, and more!
Follow & Connect with Holy Post:
Instagram: instagram.com/holypostpod
TikTok: tiktok.com/@holypostmedia
X / Twitter: https://x.com/holypostpod
Facebook: facebook.com/holypostpod
#ChurchLeadership #Redemption #FaithAndCulture #EsauMcCaulleyPodcast #HolyPostMedia #HPM
Can a pastor who lost his platform over a moral failing come back to ministry, and who gets to tell that story? Esau, Mike, and Malcolm discuss a new book and a Wall Street Journal feature from former Hillsong NYC pastor Carl Lentz and his wife, who say they've decided to stay together after Carl had multiple affairs.
Mike recounts the background and notes that Lentz describes the relationship as consensual while one of the women involved does not. Esau shares his own philosophy, that a pastor who crosses a boundary with a member of his congregation faces a lifetime disqualification. He also explains why he doubts anyone should monetize a story that involves people who didn't agree to take part. Mike argues that redemption doesn't mean the absence of consequences and that pastors can turn the role into an idol, and Malcolm describes a pastoral culture that prizes charisma over character and points to Jesus's rebuke of the Pharisees.
π¬ Can someone return to ministry after they've had a moral failing? What do you think, and how should the church balance grace with accountability? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.
Watch the full episode here π youtu.be/B8uS1Me_2Ko
0:00 β A Pastor's New Book on Infidelity
1:25 β Can Carl Lentz Return to Ministry?
2:29 β A Lifetime Disqualification
3:26 β Should This Story Be Monetized?
5:21 β Would Giving the Money Away Help?
7:05 β The Boss Who Wrote a Book
7:48 β Counseling After Infidelity
8:37 β Must You Live It to Teach It?
9:31 β Redemption Doesn't Erase Consequences
10:24 β When Pastoring Becomes an Idol
10:48 β Disqualification, Not a Time-Out
11:36 β Esau's Position on Affairs
12:31 β Why Clergy Scandals Weigh on Esau
13:15 β Charisma Over Character
14:53 β Marriage as a Picture of Christ
16:15 β Celebrity Culture and Pastors
17:08 β Humility and the Pharisees
Resources and Links:
β Join Holy Post Plus for bonus content, extended interviews, and much more! Sign up today at holypost.com/plus
π§‘ Support us on Patreon: patreon.com/holypost
π° Join the Holy Post Substack: holypost.substack.com
π Holy Post Website: holypost.com
π Holy Post Merch Store: holypost.com/shop
The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
π Like & subscribe for more conversations on faith, culture, politics, and more!
Follow & Connect with Holy Post:
Instagram: instagram.com/holypostpod
TikTok: tiktok.com/@holypostmedia
X / Twitter: https://x.com/holypostpod
Facebook: facebook.com/holypostpod
#ChurchLeadership #Redemption #FaithAndCulture #EsauMcCaulleyPodcast #HolyPostMedia #HPM










