Uploaded August 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Read literally, the Constitution seems to let the vice president preside at his own impeachment trial. Akhil Reed Amar shows why that cannot be the right answer.
This lecture introduces holistic reading: interpreting the Constitution as one whole document rather than word by word. Amar traces the absurdity canon to Blackstone, the era's leading legal authority, and applies it to the impeachment puzzle and to the rule that no one can be a judge in their own case. He then turns to McCulloch v. Maryland, where John Marshall upheld a national bank with no "bank clause" by reading the document as a whole in light of its purposes.
Chapters:
00:00 From written to unwritten Constitution
01:18 Who presides at the vice president's impeachment
05:15 Blackstone and the absurdity canon
09:56 No one can be a judge in their own case
11:52 Why the chief justice presides at presidential trials
18:10 McCulloch v. Maryland and the missing bank clause
๐ Learning objectives:
After watching, you'll be able to:
- Explain the technique of reading the Constitution holistically
- Trace Blackstone's absurdity canon to the vice presidential impeachment puzzle
- Analyze how McCulloch v. Maryland justifies a national bank without a bank clause
- Distinguish the main object of a law from its absurd, peripheral applications
๐บ Watch the full playlist on YouTube:
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLABHWcbOLwlY
๐ Enroll on Coursera for assessments and a certificate: coursera.org/learn/unwritten-constitution
๐ Explore more learning opportunities on Yale Online: https://online.yale.edu/courses/americas-unwritten-constitution
Read literally, the Constitution seems to let the vice president preside at his own impeachment trial. Akhil Reed Amar shows why that cannot be the right answer.
This lecture introduces holistic reading: interpreting the Constitution as one whole document rather than word by word. Amar traces the absurdity canon to Blackstone, the era's leading legal authority, and applies it to the impeachment puzzle and to the rule that no one can be a judge in their own case. He then turns to McCulloch v. Maryland, where John Marshall upheld a national bank with no "bank clause" by reading the document as a whole in light of its purposes.
Chapters:
00:00 From written to unwritten Constitution
01:18 Who presides at the vice president's impeachment
05:15 Blackstone and the absurdity canon
09:56 No one can be a judge in their own case
11:52 Why the chief justice presides at presidential trials
18:10 McCulloch v. Maryland and the missing bank clause
๐ Learning objectives:
After watching, you'll be able to:
- Explain the technique of reading the Constitution holistically
- Trace Blackstone's absurdity canon to the vice presidential impeachment puzzle
- Analyze how McCulloch v. Maryland justifies a national bank without a bank clause
- Distinguish the main object of a law from its absurd, peripheral applications
๐บ Watch the full playlist on YouTube:
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLABHWcbOLwlY
๐ Enroll on Coursera for assessments and a certificate: coursera.org/learn/unwritten-constitution
๐ Explore more learning opportunities on Yale Online: https://online.yale.edu/courses/americas-unwritten-constitution










