Uploaded March 2025 | Updated November 2026, 12 hours ago
USA has no future in the modern economy if it cannot establish itself as a viable producer of the full rare earth value chain. Persistent flaws affecting all U.S. Projects:
1. China's Structural Advantages & Subsidies Make Western Competition Impractical. These Disparities Can Be Offset If The Resource Producer Transfers REEs Below Market Price, But China Can Simply Move REE Concentrate Prices Lower.
2. Without An Uninterruptible Domestic Source Of Tb, Dy & Ho All Efforts Remain Futile.
3. The Current Rare Earth Production Tax Credit Bill Is Fundamentally Flawed. Amendments Must Be Made To Prevent Windfall Profits For The Production Of Low-Grade Magnets Caldera Is Offering A Solution To All Of The Above Through Integration Of The Value Chain & Prospective Amendments To The REE Magnet Production Tax Credit Bill.
China's Advantages in 4 Parts:
1) Massive overcapacity in the mid and downstream for rare earths materials processing (concentration, separation, metals & magnets) - built on low cost / no cost capital.
a. Excess capacity allows for below-cost REE separation and metallics, relative to non-Chinese entities subject to normal capital costs
b. This prevents competitive REE separation, metallics and magnet fabrication outside of China
1) Coordinated integration / consolidation of rare earth markets. For example:
a. The government sets production, import and export quotas
b. In 2016 China had "The Big 6" and now there are just 2 state sponsored rare earth companies
c. On March 4, 2022 the Chinese government announced that REE prices were too high and that companies should "bring them back to reasonable levels" Downward price movement began the next day and continued for 24 months
2) China maintains a 13% VAT tax on the export of upstream REE materials and a VAT rebate on the export of post-metallic materials and magnets
a. This acts as a subsidy to upper and midstream producers inside China because the VAT is reflected in global pricing and boosts in-country margins
Jim Kennedy presented at 2025 MDSM (Motor, Drive Systems & Magnetics) Conference on 2025-02-19. Jim can be contacted via: threeconsulting.com
Version notes: 20250219 Jim Kennedy MSDM Florida v20250324g
USA has no future in the modern economy if it cannot establish itself as a viable producer of the full rare earth value chain. Persistent flaws affecting all U.S. Projects:
1. China's Structural Advantages & Subsidies Make Western Competition Impractical. These Disparities Can Be Offset If The Resource Producer Transfers REEs Below Market Price, But China Can Simply Move REE Concentrate Prices Lower.
2. Without An Uninterruptible Domestic Source Of Tb, Dy & Ho All Efforts Remain Futile.
3. The Current Rare Earth Production Tax Credit Bill Is Fundamentally Flawed. Amendments Must Be Made To Prevent Windfall Profits For The Production Of Low-Grade Magnets Caldera Is Offering A Solution To All Of The Above Through Integration Of The Value Chain & Prospective Amendments To The REE Magnet Production Tax Credit Bill.
China's Advantages in 4 Parts:
1) Massive overcapacity in the mid and downstream for rare earths materials processing (concentration, separation, metals & magnets) - built on low cost / no cost capital.
a. Excess capacity allows for below-cost REE separation and metallics, relative to non-Chinese entities subject to normal capital costs
b. This prevents competitive REE separation, metallics and magnet fabrication outside of China
1) Coordinated integration / consolidation of rare earth markets. For example:
a. The government sets production, import and export quotas
b. In 2016 China had "The Big 6" and now there are just 2 state sponsored rare earth companies
c. On March 4, 2022 the Chinese government announced that REE prices were too high and that companies should "bring them back to reasonable levels" Downward price movement began the next day and continued for 24 months
2) China maintains a 13% VAT tax on the export of upstream REE materials and a VAT rebate on the export of post-metallic materials and magnets
a. This acts as a subsidy to upper and midstream producers inside China because the VAT is reflected in global pricing and boosts in-country margins
Jim Kennedy presented at 2025 MDSM (Motor, Drive Systems & Magnetics) Conference on 2025-02-19. Jim can be contacted via: threeconsulting.com
Version notes: 20250219 Jim Kennedy MSDM Florida v20250324g


![Thermochemistry of Molten Salt Solutions by Dr. Raluca Scarlat @ TEAC8
http://heatandmass.ep.wisc.edu/ Dr. Raluca Scarlat guides student researchers working with molten salts at University of Wisconsin-Madisons Department of Engineering Physics. Understanding the peculiarity of molten salts complex ions helps the engineering of molten salt technology.
Dr. Raluca Scarlats team works on development, design, and safety analysis of advanced reactors that can be deployed with urgency, to address the energy, climate, and air pollution challenge, and to be economically competitive with other sources of energy.
Presented at TEAC8 ( Thorium Energy Alliance Conference #8 ) on 2017-08-21 ( August 21st, 2017 ). http://ThoriumEnergyAlliance.com/
Music by KiloWatts: https://soundcloud.com/kilowatts
Salt timelapse photography by http://www.gregoryvershbow.com/
Edited by Gordon McDowell and captured for use in future Thorium Remix iterations. http://ThoriumRemix.com/
Citations in Slides...
01:06 The PB-FHR Mark-1 Core
C. Andreades et al. Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power. 136 (6) 2014
C. Andreades et al. Nuclear Technology, Vol. 195, pp. 223–238, September 2016.
03:49 FLiBe Phase Diagram
[1] K. A. Romberger, J. Branstein, et al., ‘New Electrochemical Measurements of the Liquidus in the LiF-BeF2 System’, J. Phys. Chem., vol. 76, no. 1970, pp. 1154–1159, (1972).
[2] Ricci. Guide to phase diagrams of the fluoride systems. ORNL-2396.
07:26 Ellingham Diagram - Reactions in Li2BeF4 solvent
Baes. The Chemistry and Thermodynamics of Molten Salt Reactor Fuels. Nuclear Metallurgy. 15 (1969).
09:57 Metal solubility in liquid fluorides
[102] M. A. Bredig. Mixtures of Metals with Molten Halides. Technical Report ORNL-3391, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, 1963.[103]
10:27 Activity Coefficients and Complex Ions in High Temperature Ionic Liquids
[1] L. M. Toth, J. Bates, et al., ‘Raman Spectra of Be2F7 and Higher Polymers of Beryllium Fluorides in the Crystalline and Molten State’, vol. 77, no. 2, (1972).
[2] F. Carotti, R. O. Scarlat. et al. Experimental and Modeling Studies of Over-Cooling Transients in FHR. NURETH-16. (2015). Chicago, IL.
[3] Olander, Fukuda, Baes. “Equilibrium pressures over BeF2/LiF (flibe) molten mixtures” Fusion Science and Technology. 41 (2002) 141 - 150.
14:11 Engineering Challenge: Tritium Management
Photos by Dr. Gregory Vershbow
Acknowledgements: Terrestrial Energy Inc., NEUP, NEUP. Department of Energy NEUP 15-8352. NRC Grant NRC-HQ-1121288. Department of Energy NEUP 16-10647 Thermochemistry of Molten Salt Solutions by Dr. Raluca Scarlat @ TEAC8](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/jzHdqr-9EFM/mqdefault.jpg)







