Uploaded November 2022 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Sal and Cindi Lincoln talk about Aron's Ra recent e-mails to them.
Aron, Dr. Chris, Cindi gave permission for Sal to release those e-mails publicly.
===========
Cindi,
This is a teachable moment, and I'll show you how the other side can't even state my argument accurately:
"Sal is going on and on about this stupid protein orchard argument. He will not let it go. Any molecular biologist would just stare at him in shock and dismay. Whatever happened 3.5 billion years ago where the first protocells formed, encapsulated trillions of different small peptide sequences. Proteins do not have a fucking common ancestor. Sal thinks this is a big problem for evolution because he is that stupid. This is a fallacy of composition. He thinks because organisms had a common ancestor then all of the parts of organisms must have had a common ancestor as well. Now if that were true then a primordial cell would have had to function with ONE protein."
It's frustrating for me that you have hours to waste listening to idiots lie to you, but you can hardly spare a moment for someone who can prove they're telling the truth.
Some of what was said was correct, some false. This part was correct, I wish I could put it in a creationist textbook and at creationist museum exhibit. : - )
Proteins do not have a fucking common ancestor.
This part however mis-represented what my argument actually was, it was a strawman:
Sal thinks this is a big problem for evolution because he is that stupid. This is a fallacy of composition. He thinks because organisms had a common ancestor then all of the parts of organisms must have had a common ancestor as well. Now if that were true then a primordial cell would have had to function with ONE protein."
The bolded part is a FALSE claim about my beliefs. I know it's false because I don't believe that now, nor have I ever in the past, nor have I ever said I believed it publicly.
What my critics are doing is sowing a "sprit of confusion". But "God is not the author of confusion" (1 Cor 14:33), so you know that a wicked spirit is at work here where the argument about the protein orchard is made confusing by these people making a false statement about my beliefs.
The bolded segment is an example of a strawman argument where they attribute an argument to me that I never made nor believed. I said the proteins would not have a common ancestor because it would be infeasible, just like expecting the parts of a car (spark plug, piston, radiator, battery) to evolve conceptually from a common ancestral form through an engineer's incremental improvement of the starting form. I said so July 23, 2022 at the Creation Research Conference, and went on record publicly on Youtube here a few days later:
youtu.be/iMZOdbR8fYs
So Aron's criticism, which proceeds from the scientists he contacted, is based on a falsehood about what I believe and what I actually said. They are sowing confusion, and such a spirit of confusion does not come from God. I've called my critics out repeatedly on their misrepresentations of me, and they persist spreading falsehoods. What sort of spirit then is in them that they would keep repeating the same falsehood about me over and over again! More reason you shouldn't trust the evolutionist industry.
They could try to engage the real argument I'm making rather than knocking down a strawman and pretending victory. You might want to read a book on logical fallacies. Evolutionism is built on such fallacies, and I'm showing you one such example! In any case, they made a pretty good admission:
Proteins do not have a fucking common ancestor.
It might be irreverent to say, "Praise the Lord" after hearing such an admission from an evolutionists, but I felt like saying "Praise the Lord" on seeing that!
The problem is that there is NO gradual "descent with modification" of an arbitrary protein/DNA sequence into the would-be ancestral protein/gene sequence that becomes the founding ancestor of a major protein family like those we highlighted in our debate...
[will post the rest in the video]
==============
The opening music was from the end credits of "The Silent Service"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gj8GY...
The closing music was performed by Anna Federova on AVROTROS Klassiek:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppJ5u...
The shore scene was from Naturaleza Viva:
youtu.be/_Al8valACfA
Evidence And Reasons for the Christian Faith (sister channel)
https://www.youtube.com/EvidenceAndRe...
Evidence Reasons Academy (the sister Academic Channel)
https://www.youtube.com/evidencereaso...
Website:
EvidenceAndReasons.org
If you feel this channel has blessed you and others, you're invited to donate gifts via PayPal:
https://www.paypal.com/donate/?cmd=_s...
#Science #Christianity #Evolutionism #Creationism #IntelligentDesign #YEC #OEC #Religion #Faith
Sal and Cindi Lincoln talk about Aron's Ra recent e-mails to them.
Aron, Dr. Chris, Cindi gave permission for Sal to release those e-mails publicly.
===========
Cindi,
This is a teachable moment, and I'll show you how the other side can't even state my argument accurately:
"Sal is going on and on about this stupid protein orchard argument. He will not let it go. Any molecular biologist would just stare at him in shock and dismay. Whatever happened 3.5 billion years ago where the first protocells formed, encapsulated trillions of different small peptide sequences. Proteins do not have a fucking common ancestor. Sal thinks this is a big problem for evolution because he is that stupid. This is a fallacy of composition. He thinks because organisms had a common ancestor then all of the parts of organisms must have had a common ancestor as well. Now if that were true then a primordial cell would have had to function with ONE protein."
It's frustrating for me that you have hours to waste listening to idiots lie to you, but you can hardly spare a moment for someone who can prove they're telling the truth.
Some of what was said was correct, some false. This part was correct, I wish I could put it in a creationist textbook and at creationist museum exhibit. : - )
Proteins do not have a fucking common ancestor.
This part however mis-represented what my argument actually was, it was a strawman:
Sal thinks this is a big problem for evolution because he is that stupid. This is a fallacy of composition. He thinks because organisms had a common ancestor then all of the parts of organisms must have had a common ancestor as well. Now if that were true then a primordial cell would have had to function with ONE protein."
The bolded part is a FALSE claim about my beliefs. I know it's false because I don't believe that now, nor have I ever in the past, nor have I ever said I believed it publicly.
What my critics are doing is sowing a "sprit of confusion". But "God is not the author of confusion" (1 Cor 14:33), so you know that a wicked spirit is at work here where the argument about the protein orchard is made confusing by these people making a false statement about my beliefs.
The bolded segment is an example of a strawman argument where they attribute an argument to me that I never made nor believed. I said the proteins would not have a common ancestor because it would be infeasible, just like expecting the parts of a car (spark plug, piston, radiator, battery) to evolve conceptually from a common ancestral form through an engineer's incremental improvement of the starting form. I said so July 23, 2022 at the Creation Research Conference, and went on record publicly on Youtube here a few days later:
youtu.be/iMZOdbR8fYs
So Aron's criticism, which proceeds from the scientists he contacted, is based on a falsehood about what I believe and what I actually said. They are sowing confusion, and such a spirit of confusion does not come from God. I've called my critics out repeatedly on their misrepresentations of me, and they persist spreading falsehoods. What sort of spirit then is in them that they would keep repeating the same falsehood about me over and over again! More reason you shouldn't trust the evolutionist industry.
They could try to engage the real argument I'm making rather than knocking down a strawman and pretending victory. You might want to read a book on logical fallacies. Evolutionism is built on such fallacies, and I'm showing you one such example! In any case, they made a pretty good admission:
Proteins do not have a fucking common ancestor.
It might be irreverent to say, "Praise the Lord" after hearing such an admission from an evolutionists, but I felt like saying "Praise the Lord" on seeing that!
The problem is that there is NO gradual "descent with modification" of an arbitrary protein/DNA sequence into the would-be ancestral protein/gene sequence that becomes the founding ancestor of a major protein family like those we highlighted in our debate...
[will post the rest in the video]
==============
The opening music was from the end credits of "The Silent Service"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gj8GY...
The closing music was performed by Anna Federova on AVROTROS Klassiek:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppJ5u...
The shore scene was from Naturaleza Viva:
youtu.be/_Al8valACfA
Evidence And Reasons for the Christian Faith (sister channel)
https://www.youtube.com/EvidenceAndRe...
Evidence Reasons Academy (the sister Academic Channel)
https://www.youtube.com/evidencereaso...
Website:
EvidenceAndReasons.org
If you feel this channel has blessed you and others, you're invited to donate gifts via PayPal:
https://www.paypal.com/donate/?cmd=_s...
#Science #Christianity #Evolutionism #Creationism #IntelligentDesign #YEC #OEC #Religion #Faith










