Uploaded February 2017 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Can a Robot Be Grateful? Beyond Logic, Towards Religion
Professor Stanislaw Krajewski
Theology Lecture Room, Gibson Building, Oxford
_______________________________________________
Computer enthusiasts point towards a new Pythagoreanism. Most of us try to retain the belief in the permanence of the human superiority over robots. To justify this, Gödel’s theorem has been invoked, but this is not sufficient. The realm of human relations and attitudes seems more promising. Insights from the philosophy of dialogue can help. They suggest an ultimate extension of the Turing test. It seems that in order to justify the belief in human superiority one must rely on individual experience pointing to a religious realm.
STANISLAW KRAJEWSKI is a professor at the Institute of Philosophy of the University of Warsaw and currently chairs the institute’s Academic Council. He has conducted research in logic and the philosophy of mathematics as well as in the philosophy of dialogue, Jewish thought, and interreligious dialogue. He has co-authored the post-war section of the core exhibition in the Museum of the History of Polish Jews in Warsaw. His books include Gödel’s Theorem and Its Philosophical Interpretations: from Mechanism to Post-modernism; Does Mathematics Belong to the Humanities?; and Theology in Mathematics?. Some of his papers are available at
https://uw.academia.edu/StanislawKrajewski/Papers
_______________________________________________
This event is organised by the Ian Ramsey Centre for Science and Religion and the Humane Philosophy Project.
Ian Ramsey Centre for Science and Religion, University of Oxford, Gibson Building, Radcliffe Observatory Quarter, Woodstock Road, Oxford OX2 6GG
Tel: +44 (0) 1865 270790
ianramseycentre.ox.ac.uk
_________________________________
Can a Robot Be Grateful? Beyond Logic, Towards Religion
Professor Stanislaw Krajewski
Theology Lecture Room, Gibson Building, Oxford
_______________________________________________
Computer enthusiasts point towards a new Pythagoreanism. Most of us try to retain the belief in the permanence of the human superiority over robots. To justify this, Gödel’s theorem has been invoked, but this is not sufficient. The realm of human relations and attitudes seems more promising. Insights from the philosophy of dialogue can help. They suggest an ultimate extension of the Turing test. It seems that in order to justify the belief in human superiority one must rely on individual experience pointing to a religious realm.
STANISLAW KRAJEWSKI is a professor at the Institute of Philosophy of the University of Warsaw and currently chairs the institute’s Academic Council. He has conducted research in logic and the philosophy of mathematics as well as in the philosophy of dialogue, Jewish thought, and interreligious dialogue. He has co-authored the post-war section of the core exhibition in the Museum of the History of Polish Jews in Warsaw. His books include Gödel’s Theorem and Its Philosophical Interpretations: from Mechanism to Post-modernism; Does Mathematics Belong to the Humanities?; and Theology in Mathematics?. Some of his papers are available at
https://uw.academia.edu/StanislawKrajewski/Papers
_______________________________________________
This event is organised by the Ian Ramsey Centre for Science and Religion and the Humane Philosophy Project.
Ian Ramsey Centre for Science and Religion, University of Oxford, Gibson Building, Radcliffe Observatory Quarter, Woodstock Road, Oxford OX2 6GG
Tel: +44 (0) 1865 270790
ianramseycentre.ox.ac.uk
_________________________________





![In Defence of the Soul - Dr Ralph Weir
On Wednesday 23 November at 4pm, in the Chapel of Pusey House as part of their “Recollection Series,” Dr Ralph Weir of the University of Lincoln asked what a culturally and scientifically informed person should think about the idea of the soul. He discussed a number of common misconceptions, and reflected on why the idea of the soul evokes such intense hostility in todays intellectual climate. He concluded by explaining why he thinks the idea of the soul is here to stay.
RALPH WEIR is Lecturer in Philosophy at the University of Lincoln, and an Associate Member of the Faculty of Theology and Religion at the University of Oxford.
QUOTATIONS FROM THE PRESENTATION
1. Here is a staggering truth: the ontology of the human person currently embraced by the most vocal Christian scholars working on this issue is a view that almost no Christians thought plausible only 100 years ago. Until recently, the dominant view among Christian thinkers has been various forms of mind-body dualism… according to which the human person comprises body and soul. In stark disagreement, many contemporary Christian scholars vigorously advance anti-dualism and defend physicalism, understanding the human person as fundamentally physical. – Brandon Rickabaugh. Alister McGraph’s Anti-Mind-Body Dualism: Neuroscientific and Philosophical Quandaries for Christian Phyiscalism. Trinity Journal 40 (2019) 215–240. P. 215.
2. The enemy has sown spiritual errors by mingling with scriptur the vain and erroneous philosophy of the Greeks, especially of Aristotle… The soul in Scripture signifieth always either the life or the living creature; and the body and soul jointly, the body alive. – Hobbes, Leviathan Ch. xliv
3. Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather, be afraid of the One who can destroy both soul and body in hell. – Matthew 10:28 (NIV)
4. We are always confident and know that as long as we are at home in the body we are away from the Lord… We are confident, I say, and would prefer to be away from the body and at home with the Lord… For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, so that each of us may receive what is due us for the things done while in the body, whether good or bad. – 2 Corinthians 5:6–10 (NIV)
5. It simply won’t do to demonstrate that the NT shows awareness of aspects of human life which appear to be non-material and to conclude from that that some kind of ‘dualism’ is therefore envisaged. – N. T. Wright, Mind, Spirit, Soul and Body: All for One and One for All https://ntwrightpage.com/2016/07/12/mind-spirit-soul-and-body/
6. The fact [Paul in 2 Corinthians 12] can consider the possibility that the experience might not have been ‘in the body’ does indeed indicate that he can contemplate non-bodily experiences, but… I don’t think one can straightforwardly argue from this to what is now meant, in philosophical circles, by ‘dualism’ – N. T. Wright, Mind, Spirit, Soul and Body, https://ntwrightpage.com/2016/07/12/mind-spirit-soul-and-body/
7. Paul is of course clear about… an intermediate existence… But he never names the psyche as the carrier of that intermediate existence… Had the earliest Christians wanted to teach that the ‘soul’ is the part of us which survives death and carries our real selves until the day of resurrection, they could have said so. But, with [a] solitary exception in Revelation [6.9], they never do. – N. T. Wright, Mind, Spirit, Soul and Body: All for One and One for All https://ntwrightpage.com/2016/07/12/mind-spirit-soul-and-body/
8. [For Maimonides] the body and the soul are one unit… body and soul are one. – Avshalom Mizrahi, The Soul and the Body in the Philosophy of the Rambam, Rambam Maimonides Medical Journal 2.2 (2011).
9. When they spoke about souls they were not speaking of things that continue to exist as ghosts of material things that have passed away. What people like Maimonides and Halevi meant, when they said that something has a soul, is that the thing is alive. – Daniel Davies, Theories of the Soul in Medieval Jewish Thought https://jnjr.div.ed.ac.uk/primary-sources/medieval/theories-of-soul-in-medieval-jewish-thought/
10. In the world to come, there is no body or physical form, only the souls of the righteous alone, without a body, like the ministering angels. –Maimonides in Mishneh, Torah, Repentance 8, Chapter 8, trans. by Eliyahy Touger, Moznaim Publishing.
For a complete list, please see:
https://www.ianramseycentre.ox.ac.uk/article/weir-in-defence-of-the-soul
Ralph Stefan Weir is Lecturer in Philosophy at the University of Lincoln and Associate Member of the Faculty of Theology and Religion at the University of Oxford.
Contact: rweir@lincoln.ac.uk In Defence of the Soul - Dr Ralph Weir](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/sY05yu58FCk/mqdefault.jpg)




