Uploaded June 2012 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
How Plato got it exactly the wrong way around. Reality isn't a poor projection of a perfect "platonic realm", but rather we create within our minds a "platonic" representation of reality, in which the irregularities, the minute differences between one aspect of reality and another, are ignored, and "things" are imagined as "instances" of mental categories. Our understanding of reality goes off the rails when we think that those categories that we create within our minds and that we communicate to other humans are, in fact, real.
My apologies to those who will recognise that I'm rehashing a number of themes from videos I made last week, but it's clear that I didn't express some of the ideas I presented there very well. I have to admit to that when some listeners can come away from those videos thinking that I'm saying nonsense like "a planet isn't really there until we look at it". If that's what people think I'm saying, I've failed miserably at saying what I needed to say. So I'll try one more time to clarify it here.
How Plato got it exactly the wrong way around. Reality isn't a poor projection of a perfect "platonic realm", but rather we create within our minds a "platonic" representation of reality, in which the irregularities, the minute differences between one aspect of reality and another, are ignored, and "things" are imagined as "instances" of mental categories. Our understanding of reality goes off the rails when we think that those categories that we create within our minds and that we communicate to other humans are, in fact, real.
My apologies to those who will recognise that I'm rehashing a number of themes from videos I made last week, but it's clear that I didn't express some of the ideas I presented there very well. I have to admit to that when some listeners can come away from those videos thinking that I'm saying nonsense like "a planet isn't really there until we look at it". If that's what people think I'm saying, I've failed miserably at saying what I needed to say. So I'll try one more time to clarify it here.










