Peter Kareiva - Avoiding Species Extinction @CSERCambridge
Peter Kareiva - Avoiding Species Extinction  @CSERCambridge
Uploaded January 2017 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
This talk was given at the Cambridge Conference on Catastrophic Risk on December 12-14 2016

Abstract

Why we are unlikely to foresee an environmental apocalypse, and what to do about it

Famine and pestilence are common Malthusian narratives that link human avarice and fertility with planetary catastrophe. These Biblical judgement days have been with us for centuries, with little supporting evidence. Equally unreal are the counter-narratives of blind techno-optimism, whereby whatever problem arises, is surely solved by human ingenuity – so why worry? What then are the environmental catastrophes that could threaten human existence?

1. The first is no surprise: global climate disruption. Environmental scientists, national security experts, and global businesses all recognise climate change as a potentially catastrophic threat. Society, businesses, and governments are taking action but the risk is that positive feedbacks will accelerate warming and proceed so rapidly that efforts to reduce emissions happen too late.

2. After climate, loss of soil looms as a potential global disaster. Currently, soil is being lost at ten times the rate it is being generated, which prompted the UN to declare 2015 to be labelled the “International Year of Soils”.

3. Emerging diseases represent a third disaster waiting to happen. HIV jumped from monkeys to humans and has killed 35 million people since the first diagnosed case in 1959. HIV has a low transmission rate —the worry is that something with a much higher transmission rate might jump to the human species.

All of these ominous risks are exacerbated by an absence of modularity and the highly nonlinear and strong interactions that reverberate throughout human-natural systems. Hence, a local famine can produce a massive exodus of people who then destabilise either the ecosystem or political system into which they move. Alternatively, in the absence of adequate migration, the local disaster becomes so severe that instead of migrating people exporting stress, dust or pollutants are transported globally.

Especially disturbing is the possibility that environmental science is ill-equipped to foresee existential threats. Three scientific shortcomings expose the world to environmental catastrophe. First, there is a tendency to overstate certain “popular” threats and thereby inadvertently divert attention away from the real risks. Second, in the face of extreme change and environmental shocks, we show little ability to manage for change or to take radical action in the face of severe degradation. Instead, there remains a tendency to preserve ecosystems in historical states in direct opposition to the changing world around us and to be locked into rigid regulatory approaches as opposed to experimental management. And the last and perhaps most ominous environmental threat are our ignorance of ecosystems, and our failure to invest in collecting or using data that might provide real-time signals of potential disasters. Instead, the environmental and conservation community focuses on obscure indices and expert opinions that are infrequently updated. It is analogous to a medical doctor taking no physiological measurements, but assessing one’s health by looking at family photos and talking with several family friends to construct mysterious indices of health.
Peter Kareiva - Avoiding Species ExtinctionBlavatnik Public Lecture with Prof. Paul EhrlichMeet the CSER Researcher: Dr Lara ManiCCCR 2022 Jenty Kirsch-Wood & Panel - UNDRR’s Preparation for Systemic and Cascading GCRsExistential Risk Dialogues: Personal journeys into global catastrophic researchIntroduction to the 2018 Cambridge Conference on Catastrophic RiskCCCR 2022 Lightning Talk: Anders SandburgCCCR 2022 Lightning Talk: Aaron TangCCCR 2022 Lightning Talk: Bear HaonCCCR 2020 Sheri Wells Jensen - Grand futures: Who Will Be There?CCCR 2022 Tina Park & Panel - Addressing the Challenges of Inclusive Practises in AI DevelopmentZabta K. Shinwari - Young Researchers & Responsible Conduct of Science: Successes and failures
CSER Cambridge |

Peter Kareiva - Avoiding Species Extinction

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER