Uploaded February 2025 | Updated November 2026, 3 days ago
Detecting Psi-Missing in Forced-Choice Data
Peter A. Bancel
Institut Métapsychique International
Paris, France
Forced-choice experiments have long been a standard in psi research. Forced-choice psi tasks involve an intervention (choice) that yields an outcome that is deemed successful or not (hit or miss). Examples are various tests of PMIR, some precognitive experiments of Bem and others, online RV studies, etc. Experiments often give trial-by-trial feedback, and this may evoke unconscious participant responses, which lead to psi-missing. Psi-missing is characterized as outcomes where psi operates opposite the intended direction of the task. Psi-missing is generally recognized as a possible experimental outcome, but it is often considered a nuisance that can obscure the presence of psi when psi-hitting is the primary test of evidence.
Here, I describe ways to detect psi-missing when studies run sessions with multiple trials, and each trial is a forced-choice psi task. Because analyses usually look for psi-hitting, a mixture of hitting and missing can cause tests to lose power, even when strong psi is present. I present models of psi-missing, along with ways to detect it statistically. It’s found that the raw variance and trial autocorrelations can detect psi-missing in a wide range of scenarios. Of course, when psi-missing is absent, traditional mean tests are far more powerful.
The tests can be combined to attain a broader reach without too great a cost in statistical power. This is helpful for framing hypothesis tests in a parsimonious way. The model-based approach can also guide post-hoc analyses that aim to determine how psi-hitting and psi-missing are distributed in data. This can provide helpful input to psychological theories of psi performance.
---
Peter Bancel holds a PhD in experimental physics from the University of Pennsylvania. Following a post-doc at IBM Research, he moved to France to work with the Centre National de Recherche Scientifique in Paris and Nantes. His research interests have included quasicrystals, phase transitions in two-dimensional systems and protein crystal growth. Peter began working in psi research shortly after the US terror attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, when he joined a small group looking at data from the Global Consciousness Project. He has published work on state-induction approaches to improving psi effect sizes, theoretical assessments of meta-analyses in psi databases and experiments with meditator cohorts on precognition. Peter works at the Institut Métapsychique International in Paris, France.
---
Program chaired by Jacob W. Glazier. Download the Abstracts at parapsych.org/uploaded_files/pdfs/00/00/00/01/26/2023_pa_abstracts_of_presented_papers.pdf
Find us:
Facebook - facebook.com/ParapsychologicalAssociation
X - https://x.com/parapsych
Instagram - instagram.com/parapsychologicalassociation
LinkedIn - linkedin.com/company/parapsychological-association-inc-
Donations to support the mission of the PA can be made by reaching office@parapsych.org or using this link: parapsych.org/section/11/support_the_pa.aspx
Detecting Psi-Missing in Forced-Choice Data
Peter A. Bancel
Institut Métapsychique International
Paris, France
Forced-choice experiments have long been a standard in psi research. Forced-choice psi tasks involve an intervention (choice) that yields an outcome that is deemed successful or not (hit or miss). Examples are various tests of PMIR, some precognitive experiments of Bem and others, online RV studies, etc. Experiments often give trial-by-trial feedback, and this may evoke unconscious participant responses, which lead to psi-missing. Psi-missing is characterized as outcomes where psi operates opposite the intended direction of the task. Psi-missing is generally recognized as a possible experimental outcome, but it is often considered a nuisance that can obscure the presence of psi when psi-hitting is the primary test of evidence.
Here, I describe ways to detect psi-missing when studies run sessions with multiple trials, and each trial is a forced-choice psi task. Because analyses usually look for psi-hitting, a mixture of hitting and missing can cause tests to lose power, even when strong psi is present. I present models of psi-missing, along with ways to detect it statistically. It’s found that the raw variance and trial autocorrelations can detect psi-missing in a wide range of scenarios. Of course, when psi-missing is absent, traditional mean tests are far more powerful.
The tests can be combined to attain a broader reach without too great a cost in statistical power. This is helpful for framing hypothesis tests in a parsimonious way. The model-based approach can also guide post-hoc analyses that aim to determine how psi-hitting and psi-missing are distributed in data. This can provide helpful input to psychological theories of psi performance.
---
Peter Bancel holds a PhD in experimental physics from the University of Pennsylvania. Following a post-doc at IBM Research, he moved to France to work with the Centre National de Recherche Scientifique in Paris and Nantes. His research interests have included quasicrystals, phase transitions in two-dimensional systems and protein crystal growth. Peter began working in psi research shortly after the US terror attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, when he joined a small group looking at data from the Global Consciousness Project. He has published work on state-induction approaches to improving psi effect sizes, theoretical assessments of meta-analyses in psi databases and experiments with meditator cohorts on precognition. Peter works at the Institut Métapsychique International in Paris, France.
---
Program chaired by Jacob W. Glazier. Download the Abstracts at parapsych.org/uploaded_files/pdfs/00/00/00/01/26/2023_pa_abstracts_of_presented_papers.pdf
Find us:
Facebook - facebook.com/ParapsychologicalAssociation
X - https://x.com/parapsych
Instagram - instagram.com/parapsychologicalassociation
LinkedIn - linkedin.com/company/parapsychological-association-inc-
Donations to support the mission of the PA can be made by reaching office@parapsych.org or using this link: parapsych.org/section/11/support_the_pa.aspx






![Christine Simmonds Moore | Traversing Boundaries and Accessing the Invisible
Invited Speaker Address: Traversing Boundaries and Accessing the Invisible
Christine Simmonds-Moore
University of West Georgia, Carrollton, Georgia, United States of America
In this presentation, I will explore the idea that [receptive] psi emerges in the context of healthy mindbody-other systems that are open, porous, sensitive, and strongly interconnected. Such systems may also be associated with richer fractal signatures. Syncretic tendencies (including synesthesia) contribute to facilitating the conscious awareness of some usually invisible or intangible information, that otherwise may remain inaccessible or invisible. Several correlates of psi will be discussed from this perspective.
Christine Simmonds-Moore is a UK native with a PhD from the University of Northampton that explored “Schizotypy as an anomaly-prone personality”. She is a Professor of Psychology at the University of West Georgia where she teaches classes on parapsychology, transpersonal psychology, and other topics pertinent to consciousness studies. She has research interests in parapsychology, exceptional experiences, psychological boundaries, paranormal beliefs and disbeliefs, mental health correlates of exceptional experiences, synesthesia, ASMR, altered states of consciousness, healing and placebo effects. She is the recipient of several Bial grants to study exceptional experiences and the author of several articles and texts on exceptional experiences.
Program chaired by Jacob W. Glazier. Download the Abstracts at https://parapsych.org/uploaded_files/pdfs/00/00/00/01/26/2023_pa_abstracts_of_presented_papers.pdf
Find us:
Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/ParapsychologicalAssociation
X - https://x.com/parapsych
Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/parapsychologicalassociation
LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/company/parapsychological-association-inc-/
Donations to support the mission of the PA, including the funding of research initiatives, can be made by reaching office@parapsych.org or using this link: https://parapsych.org/section/11/support_the_pa.aspx Christine Simmonds Moore | Traversing Boundaries and Accessing the Invisible](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/lN0YMmjl-Lo/mqdefault.jpg)



