Uploaded June 2025 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Emma Waters and Ruxandra Teslo debate the ethics of IVF and embryo selection, focusing on whether discarding genetically tested embryos constitutes an ethical violation or a valid reproductive choice.
Full episode: youtu.be/nhYc_TP4ptA
In this discussion hosted by Zach Weissmueller and Liz Wolfe, Emma Waters and Ruxandra Teslo debate the ethics and implications of genetic testing and selection in the context of in vitro fertilization (IVF). Waters raises concerns about the destruction of embryos based on genetic risk scores and argues for a consistent life ethic that values embryos as human beings. Teslo defends the use of IVF and genetic testing as tools to reduce suffering, particularly for women at risk of miscarriage, and emphasizing that participation in such technologies should remain a matter of personal choice. The conversation centers on the ethical boundaries of embryo selection, the purpose of reproductive technologies, and diverging views on what constitutes human life.
chapters
0:00 Introduction to embryo genetic testing
1:12 Emma’s critique of selection-based technologies
2:09 Ruxandra questions the focus and reframes priorities
3:19 Discussion of current IVF limitations and accessibility
4:04 Ethical concerns around expanding embryo testing
5:15 Questions about the reliability of genetic screening
6:10 Social and cultural concerns around embryo selection
7:14 Clarifying PGTA and its impact on miscarriage
8:25 Diverging views on suffering and embryo selection
9:50 Linguistic and ethical framing of embryo decisions
11:00 Core ethical disagreement: what is an embryo?
13:05 Emma on life-affirming genetic interventions
14:03 Ethical weight of discarding embryos
15:26 Autonomy, choice, and the embryo’s agency
17:02 Ruxandra responds to the definition of an embryo
19:36 Trust and ethical standards around embryo treatment
21:06 Closing exchange on embryo status and IVF ethics
22:14 Final ethical stance on embryo destruction
Subscribe
YouTube: youtube.com/@reasonJustAskingQuestions/featured
Apple: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/just-asking-questions/id1719355507
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/5SpySKAH3LuVyxXk0MF7tl
Text and links to sources available here: reason.com/podcast/2025/06/06/debating-the-science-and-ethics-of-ivf-emma-waters-vs-ruxandra-teslo
Emma Waters and Ruxandra Teslo debate the ethics of IVF and embryo selection, focusing on whether discarding genetically tested embryos constitutes an ethical violation or a valid reproductive choice.
Full episode: youtu.be/nhYc_TP4ptA
In this discussion hosted by Zach Weissmueller and Liz Wolfe, Emma Waters and Ruxandra Teslo debate the ethics and implications of genetic testing and selection in the context of in vitro fertilization (IVF). Waters raises concerns about the destruction of embryos based on genetic risk scores and argues for a consistent life ethic that values embryos as human beings. Teslo defends the use of IVF and genetic testing as tools to reduce suffering, particularly for women at risk of miscarriage, and emphasizing that participation in such technologies should remain a matter of personal choice. The conversation centers on the ethical boundaries of embryo selection, the purpose of reproductive technologies, and diverging views on what constitutes human life.
chapters
0:00 Introduction to embryo genetic testing
1:12 Emma’s critique of selection-based technologies
2:09 Ruxandra questions the focus and reframes priorities
3:19 Discussion of current IVF limitations and accessibility
4:04 Ethical concerns around expanding embryo testing
5:15 Questions about the reliability of genetic screening
6:10 Social and cultural concerns around embryo selection
7:14 Clarifying PGTA and its impact on miscarriage
8:25 Diverging views on suffering and embryo selection
9:50 Linguistic and ethical framing of embryo decisions
11:00 Core ethical disagreement: what is an embryo?
13:05 Emma on life-affirming genetic interventions
14:03 Ethical weight of discarding embryos
15:26 Autonomy, choice, and the embryo’s agency
17:02 Ruxandra responds to the definition of an embryo
19:36 Trust and ethical standards around embryo treatment
21:06 Closing exchange on embryo status and IVF ethics
22:14 Final ethical stance on embryo destruction
Subscribe
YouTube: youtube.com/@reasonJustAskingQuestions/featured
Apple: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/just-asking-questions/id1719355507
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/5SpySKAH3LuVyxXk0MF7tl
Text and links to sources available here: reason.com/podcast/2025/06/06/debating-the-science-and-ethics-of-ivf-emma-waters-vs-ruxandra-teslo










