Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
This is Chapter 2 of a multi-chapter book published in 1980. Chapter 1 was uploaded to youtube on October 7, 2026. A timecoded table of topics (primarily the section titles) is below. Highly recommended to first watch Chapter 1, which is accessible here: youtu.be/4ZYc5duBlvQ?si=Zl64utQ_I1zMNnIm
00:02 Chapter 2: "The Tragic Story of Human Success"
NOTE: Catton himself posted the FULL TEXT of this chapter on the "Resilience" website on 3 May 2005, accessible here: resilience.org/stories/2005-05-03/tragic-story-human-success
00:07 2A. "Origins of Man's Future"
00:36 Table 1, "Enlarging Earth's Carrying Capacity for the Human Species," appears for the rest of the chapter.
01:42 2B. "In the Beginning" - HUNTING & GATHERING as the economy, amplified by simple tools and fire.
04:36 2C. "Increased Hunting Proficiency" - spearthrower (atlatl), bow & arrow.
06:24 2D. "Learning to Manage Nature" - HORTICULTURE as the economy, via plant cultivation.
08:34 2E. "Compound Interest" - population increases naturally (but slowly) through exponential growth.
09:38 2F. "Tools, Organization, and Living Standards" - innovation of metal tools, increase in division of labor, and amplification of social organization.
11:12 2G. AGRARIAN economy begins with invention of the plow, then enhanced by domesticating draft animals to pull it. Iron tools replace the early bronze tools.
13:13 2H. "Firearms" - the small crews on ocean-going ships from Europe were able to conquer and displace peoples in the Western Hemisphere, Australia, and New Zealand owing to the invention of hand-carried firearms.
15:50 2I. "Abundance" - The Age of Exuberance begins, and the prevailing worldview of "changelessness" shifts to a grandiose belief in ongoing change and thus "limitlessness." Literacy and leisure expands, thus facilitating even more innovation. New technologies underpin the sense that progress is underway. As technologies enhance human abilities to extract resources, human numbers expand. The distinction between enlarging and degrading Earth's carrying capacity for humanity via resource extraction was not perceived nor abided.
20:25. "The TAKEOVER Method" - Carrying capacity for a given tract of land is enlarged when hunting & gathering societies are displaced by horticultural economies and again when agrarian/farming cultures take over the land. Properly managed, the TAKEOVER method can be both PERMANENT and cumulative.
25:01 "In this take-over process, man was behaving as all creatures do.... By explaining this human displacement episode as a special case of the ecological principle of 'competitive exclusion,' we can at least take note of how common the takeover method has been in the ecological history of the world."
26:39 "The DRAWDOWN Method: Stealing Resources from the Future" - INDUSTRIAL economy began with and depends on fossil fuels. Products that enlarge carrying capacity include tractors for farming, chemical fertilizers, irrigation machinery. But DRAWDOWN is only a TEMPORARY enlargement of carrying capacity. When the limited resources of Earth's geological processes are depleted, carrying capacity plummets.
32:26 "OVERSHOOT aggravated" - Population soared in the last 150 years owing to medical innovations that yielded "death control" (antiseptics, hygiene, vaccination, antibiotics, etc. The existing "carrying capacity deficit" deepened and drawdown of finite resources accelerated, while the social benefits excelled.
36:47 Technological optimism induced a failure to admit that the "the Myth of Limitlessness" had become obsolete.
37:19 "Back to Hunting and Gathering" - Hunting (exploring) for nonrenewable geological resources and then gathering (extracting) them for human uses. Fossil fuels and copper are the two resources used as examples of the "temporary" DRAWDOWN method that is "stealing resources" from future generations. "Our species has been an enormous biological success, but success carried to excess can be disastrous."
Michael Dowd is well known for his breadth of public talks and educational videos posted on youtube at this channel:
youtube.com/@UCudybZWmETRQgRBMUX5uzUw
A large audience also appreciates his audio narrations of books and essays by authors he admires, posted in video format here:
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLcAlqMeyeaW-N2SSItU0heLaipjM-iXm6&si=NOWVEWATEPxlj1wv
Dowd's website (thegreatstory.org ) includes a "Tribute to William R. Catton":
thegreatstory.org/william-catton.html
Catton Wikipedia page: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_R._Catton_Jr.
Dowd Wikipedia page: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Dowd
This is Chapter 2 of a multi-chapter book published in 1980. Chapter 1 was uploaded to youtube on October 7, 2026. A timecoded table of topics (primarily the section titles) is below. Highly recommended to first watch Chapter 1, which is accessible here: youtu.be/4ZYc5duBlvQ?si=Zl64utQ_I1zMNnIm
00:02 Chapter 2: "The Tragic Story of Human Success"
NOTE: Catton himself posted the FULL TEXT of this chapter on the "Resilience" website on 3 May 2005, accessible here: resilience.org/stories/2005-05-03/tragic-story-human-success
00:07 2A. "Origins of Man's Future"
00:36 Table 1, "Enlarging Earth's Carrying Capacity for the Human Species," appears for the rest of the chapter.
01:42 2B. "In the Beginning" - HUNTING & GATHERING as the economy, amplified by simple tools and fire.
04:36 2C. "Increased Hunting Proficiency" - spearthrower (atlatl), bow & arrow.
06:24 2D. "Learning to Manage Nature" - HORTICULTURE as the economy, via plant cultivation.
08:34 2E. "Compound Interest" - population increases naturally (but slowly) through exponential growth.
09:38 2F. "Tools, Organization, and Living Standards" - innovation of metal tools, increase in division of labor, and amplification of social organization.
11:12 2G. AGRARIAN economy begins with invention of the plow, then enhanced by domesticating draft animals to pull it. Iron tools replace the early bronze tools.
13:13 2H. "Firearms" - the small crews on ocean-going ships from Europe were able to conquer and displace peoples in the Western Hemisphere, Australia, and New Zealand owing to the invention of hand-carried firearms.
15:50 2I. "Abundance" - The Age of Exuberance begins, and the prevailing worldview of "changelessness" shifts to a grandiose belief in ongoing change and thus "limitlessness." Literacy and leisure expands, thus facilitating even more innovation. New technologies underpin the sense that progress is underway. As technologies enhance human abilities to extract resources, human numbers expand. The distinction between enlarging and degrading Earth's carrying capacity for humanity via resource extraction was not perceived nor abided.
20:25. "The TAKEOVER Method" - Carrying capacity for a given tract of land is enlarged when hunting & gathering societies are displaced by horticultural economies and again when agrarian/farming cultures take over the land. Properly managed, the TAKEOVER method can be both PERMANENT and cumulative.
25:01 "In this take-over process, man was behaving as all creatures do.... By explaining this human displacement episode as a special case of the ecological principle of 'competitive exclusion,' we can at least take note of how common the takeover method has been in the ecological history of the world."
26:39 "The DRAWDOWN Method: Stealing Resources from the Future" - INDUSTRIAL economy began with and depends on fossil fuels. Products that enlarge carrying capacity include tractors for farming, chemical fertilizers, irrigation machinery. But DRAWDOWN is only a TEMPORARY enlargement of carrying capacity. When the limited resources of Earth's geological processes are depleted, carrying capacity plummets.
32:26 "OVERSHOOT aggravated" - Population soared in the last 150 years owing to medical innovations that yielded "death control" (antiseptics, hygiene, vaccination, antibiotics, etc. The existing "carrying capacity deficit" deepened and drawdown of finite resources accelerated, while the social benefits excelled.
36:47 Technological optimism induced a failure to admit that the "the Myth of Limitlessness" had become obsolete.
37:19 "Back to Hunting and Gathering" - Hunting (exploring) for nonrenewable geological resources and then gathering (extracting) them for human uses. Fossil fuels and copper are the two resources used as examples of the "temporary" DRAWDOWN method that is "stealing resources" from future generations. "Our species has been an enormous biological success, but success carried to excess can be disastrous."
Michael Dowd is well known for his breadth of public talks and educational videos posted on youtube at this channel:
youtube.com/@UCudybZWmETRQgRBMUX5uzUw
A large audience also appreciates his audio narrations of books and essays by authors he admires, posted in video format here:
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLcAlqMeyeaW-N2SSItU0heLaipjM-iXm6&si=NOWVEWATEPxlj1wv
Dowd's website (thegreatstory.org ) includes a "Tribute to William R. Catton":
thegreatstory.org/william-catton.html
Catton Wikipedia page: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_R._Catton_Jr.
Dowd Wikipedia page: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Dowd










