OTHER MOMMY Movie Review — This Horror Movie COMPLETELY Surprised Me @ZachPopeReviews
OTHER MOMMY Movie Review — This Horror Movie COMPLETELY Surprised Me  @ZachPopeReviews
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Zach Pope reviews OTHER MOMMY, Rob Savage’s new supernatural horror movie starring Jessica Chastain, Arabella Olivia Clark and Jay Duplass — and this was a COMPLETE surprise.

OTHER MOMMY is the kind of horror movie that reminds me why execution matters just as much as originality.

Is this movie always unpredictable?

No.

There are jump scares you might see coming.

There are story beats you can probably piece together before the characters do.

There are moments where you know EXACTLY what kind of creepy image is about to appear.

But honestly?

I DID NOT CARE.

Because Rob Savage knows how to make this movie MOVE.

OTHER MOMMY follows Bela, an eight-year-old girl living inside a home already strained by her parents’ troubled marriage.

Then something appears.

A sinister entity emerges from inside Bela’s home and looks almost exactly like her mother.

Bela calls it:

OTHER MOMMY.

And the more this presence appears?

The more manipulative, aggressive and dangerous it becomes.

Jessica Chastain plays both Bela’s real mother and the entity wearing her face, which gives the entire movie one of its creepiest ideas:

What happens when the person who is supposed to make you feel safest suddenly becomes the thing you’re most afraid of?

But what really surprised me about OTHER MOMMY is that underneath the supernatural horror?

There is a genuinely emotional story about FAMILY.

Specifically:

WHAT A BROKEN FAMILY CAN LOOK LIKE TO A CHILD.

Bela is surrounded by adults dealing with their own problems.

Marriage issues.

Arguments.

Fear.

Frustration.

Things a child may not fully understand but absolutely FEELS.

And then this monster arrives offering something that appears easier.

Something comforting.

Something pretending to understand her.

That’s where the movie became more interesting to me than simply:

“Creepy woman comes out of the closet.”

Arabella Olivia Clark is FANTASTIC as Bela.

That performance has to work.

If we don’t believe Bela?

Nothing else lands.

Clark gives the movie this innocence and fear while still making Bela feel like an actual kid instead of the generic “creepy horror child.”

And then Jessica Chastain gets to have a TON of fun.

As Bela’s real mother, she gives the family drama genuine emotional weight.

But as Other Mommy?

She gets WEIRD.

Physical.

Unsettling.

Manipulative.

And visually terrifying.

Rob Savage also directs the hell out of this thing.

The jump scares are FUN.

The visual language keeps changing.

There are sequences here that feel incredibly creative and energetic.

And even when you KNOW a scare is coming?

Savage understands that knowing something is coming doesn’t automatically mean it can’t still be entertaining.

That’s the thing.

OTHER MOMMY never stopped being FUN for me.

It’s lean.

Fast.

Constantly moving.

And the movie understands when to throw another visual or scare at you before the momentum dies.

My biggest problem?

IT MIGHT BE TOO LEAN.

OTHER MOMMY runs around 93 minutes. (Cinemark)

And usually?

I LOVE when horror movies get in and get out.

But here?

I actually wanted another 10 or 15 minutes.

Give me more mythology.

Give me a little more time with the family.

Let certain emotional moments breathe.

Let some of the crazier horror imagery build for longer.

Because I was enjoying this world enough that when it ended?

I wasn’t thinking:

“Finally.”

I was thinking:

“WAIT…THAT’S IT?!”

And that’s honestly a pretty good complaint to have.

In my full OTHER MOMMY movie review, I’m discussing Jessica Chastain, Arabella Olivia Clark, Jay Duplass, Rob Savage’s direction, the jump scares, the creature/entity design, the family themes, the predictability, the visuals and why this ended up being one of the more enjoyable horror surprises I’ve had recently.

OTHER MOMMY is directed by Rob Savage from a screenplay by Nathan Elston and is based on Josh Malerman’s bestselling novel INCIDENTS AROUND THE HOUSE.

The film comes from Blumhouse Atomic Monster and producer James Wan. (NBCUNIVERSAL MEDIA)

Jessica Chastain stars in dual roles as Bela’s mother and Other Mommy, with Arabella Olivia Clark as Bela and Jay Duplass as her father. Dichen Lachman, Arian Moayed and Karen Allen also appear. (NBCUNIVERSAL MEDIA)

OTHER MOMMY opens in theaters October 9.

My final verdict?

A COMPLETE SURPRISE.
Creative.
Fast.
Fun.
Creepy.
Sometimes predictable.
But never BORING.
And honestly?
I wanted another 15 minutes.
What did YOU think of OTHER MOMMY?
Did the scares work for you? And what did you think of Jessica Chastain as OTHER MOMMY?
Let me know down below!

#OtherMommy #JessicaChastain #RobSavage #Horror
Find Me!
Instagram: instagram.com/zachhpope/?hl=en
Twitter(X): twitter.com/popetheking
Tiktok: tiktok.com/@zachhpope?lang=en
Business Inquires: Zachpopereviews@gmail.com
OTHER MOMMY Movie Review — This Horror Movie COMPLETELY Surprised MeRED IS A DAD NOW?! Angry Birds 3 TRAILER Reaction #ShortsCHATGPT IS GETTING A MOVIE WITH ANDREW GARFIELD!? (TRAILER REACTION)THE EXORCIST: MARTYRS Looks TERRIFYING (TRAILER REACTION)Zootopia 2 Is Actually BETTER Than the First Movie! (Movie Review)Did We Really NEED Insidious Out of The Further!? (Movie Review)TOP 5 BEST SUMMER 2026 MOVIES PART TWORESIDENT EVIL (2026) Out of Theater ReactionNOAH JUPE CAST IN AVENGERS SECRET WARS!? | FRANKLIN RICHARDSAVENGERS ENDGAME ENCORE JUST CHANGED THE ENDING (SPOILERS)FORGOTTEN ISLAND IS ONE OF DREAMWORKS BEST MOVIES (REVIEW)LANTERNS EPISODE 7 SPOILER REVIEW & REACTION (WE FOUND SINESTRO)
Zach Pope |

OTHER MOMMY Movie Review — This Horror Movie COMPLETELY Surprised Me

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER