Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Gone In The Night The Search For Nancy Guthrie Special Report| BreakTheCase
Join Jen Coffindaffer and an expert panel as we break down the shocking FOX 10 Phoenix special report, “Gone in the Night: The Search for Nancy Guthrie”. We analyze the chilling timeline, the digital forensic footprint, the doorbell camera footage, and the critical missteps in the high-profile investigation out of Tucson, Arizona.
Make sure to connect with our panel across their platforms:
Host: @breakthecase / @breakthecasepod / @CoffindafferFBI
Network / Coverage: @Newsnation
Guests & Experts: GiGi McKelvey (@prettyliesalibis), Matt Murphy, Dr. Colleen Fitzpatrick, Ellen McNamara, and Justin Lum. For the Full episode check our Nancy Guthrie playlist on YouTube ⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️
The Nancy Guthrie Abduction
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMIiEioLVrfUMiWWPhrtYX-wisAXy0NKd
Timestamps
0:00 — Introduction: Gone in the Night (The Search for Nancy Guthrie)
2:15 — Breaking Down the FOX 10 Phoenix Investigation & Timeline
10:45 — The Digital Trail: Doorbell Camera, Pacemaker Data, & Disconnections
22:30 — Examining the Crime Scene Evidence & Law Enforcement Missteps
35:10 — Expert Panel Analysis with Dr. Colleen Fitzpatrick & Matt Murphy
48:20 — Media Frenzy, Ransom Speculation, & Public Pressure
1:02:15 — Final Thoughts & What Lies Ahead in the Investigation
Hashtags
#NancyGuthrie #GoneInTheNight #Fox10Phoenix #BreakTheCase #JenCoffindaffer TrueCrime NewsNation CrimeForensics InvestigativeReport TucsonArizona
Video Tags
Gone in the night, Nancy Guthrie, FOX 10 Phoenix, FOX 10 Investigates, Jen Coffindaffer, Break the Case, NewsNation, GiGi McKelvey, pretty lies alibis, Matt Murphy, Dr Colleen Fitzpatrick, Ellen McNamara, Justin Lum, Tucson Arizona, Catalina Foothills, true crime analysis, missing person investigation, digital forensics, crime scene breakdown
Gone In The Night The Search For Nancy Guthrie Special Report| BreakTheCase
Join Jen Coffindaffer and an expert panel as we break down the shocking FOX 10 Phoenix special report, “Gone in the Night: The Search for Nancy Guthrie”. We analyze the chilling timeline, the digital forensic footprint, the doorbell camera footage, and the critical missteps in the high-profile investigation out of Tucson, Arizona.
Make sure to connect with our panel across their platforms:
Host: @breakthecase / @breakthecasepod / @CoffindafferFBI
Network / Coverage: @Newsnation
Guests & Experts: GiGi McKelvey (@prettyliesalibis), Matt Murphy, Dr. Colleen Fitzpatrick, Ellen McNamara, and Justin Lum. For the Full episode check our Nancy Guthrie playlist on YouTube ⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️
The Nancy Guthrie Abduction
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMIiEioLVrfUMiWWPhrtYX-wisAXy0NKd
Timestamps
0:00 — Introduction: Gone in the Night (The Search for Nancy Guthrie)
2:15 — Breaking Down the FOX 10 Phoenix Investigation & Timeline
10:45 — The Digital Trail: Doorbell Camera, Pacemaker Data, & Disconnections
22:30 — Examining the Crime Scene Evidence & Law Enforcement Missteps
35:10 — Expert Panel Analysis with Dr. Colleen Fitzpatrick & Matt Murphy
48:20 — Media Frenzy, Ransom Speculation, & Public Pressure
1:02:15 — Final Thoughts & What Lies Ahead in the Investigation
Hashtags
#NancyGuthrie #GoneInTheNight #Fox10Phoenix #BreakTheCase #JenCoffindaffer TrueCrime NewsNation CrimeForensics InvestigativeReport TucsonArizona
Video Tags
Gone in the night, Nancy Guthrie, FOX 10 Phoenix, FOX 10 Investigates, Jen Coffindaffer, Break the Case, NewsNation, GiGi McKelvey, pretty lies alibis, Matt Murphy, Dr Colleen Fitzpatrick, Ellen McNamara, Justin Lum, Tucson Arizona, Catalina Foothills, true crime analysis, missing person investigation, digital forensics, crime scene breakdown










