Uploaded February 2021 | Updated September 2026, 2 hours ago
Which Valentine's Day slasher is better, MY BLOODY VALENTINE (1981) ⛏ or VALENTINE (2001) 🏹 You guys voted, and the results are in!
Vote for next week's match ✅
YOU'RE NEXT 𝘷𝘴. READY OR NOT:
youtube.com/post/Ugw8k-ryYXNpdWTD2uV4AaABCQ
Previous Episode
GET OUT 𝘷𝘴. US: youtu.be/rFHyuNAKYTU
Welcome to FRIGHT CLUB, the horror movie battle ring where YOU vote for the winner. Make sure to check my channel's community tab every THURSDAY to vote for the latest match up.
Which film is better, My Bloody Valentine or Valentine?
In this episode we will be comparing Valentine's Day horror movies MY BLOODY VALENTINE (1981) with VALENTINE (2001).
Both of these holiday horror flicks are noteworthy for following the trends of 80s and 90s horror and more or less being a HALLOWEEN ripoff and a SCREAM ripoff set on Valentine's Day. Valentine even stars Marley Shelton, who would go on to appear in Scream 4.
Despite both films being derivative, they offer top notch kills, even in the face of severe MPAA censorship. They also both feature iconic an iconic Valentine's Day killer, with The Mine (aka Harry Warden) and The Cupid Killer (Jeremy Melton).
As these are the most notable Valentine's Day slashers out there, not including the 2009 remake MY BLOODY VALENTINE 3D, they're prime contenders for this fright. So place your bets. Which is better MY BLOODY VALENTINE or VALENTINE? The Miner vs. Cupid Killer.
With both films having amassed their own separate cult following, which one did you vote for as the best?
We will be comparing the movies in 5 rounds, followed by the results from the poll in which you voted on last week (found in the community section of this channel).
INTRO 0:00
Meet the contenders.
STORY 1:18
How compelling is the narrative?
CHARACTER 3:53
How well do they fit into the narrative (and are portrayed)?
PRODUCTION 5:41
The quality of the film's look and sound.
EXECUTION 7:37
How well does the film succeed at what it's attempting?
KILLS 9:30
Blood n' guts, baby!
THE VOTE 11:33
How many people voted, and which movie they voted for?
Toss this video a thumbs up if you enjoyed it, and let me know in the comments which one is your favorite.
If you would like to vote in future episodes, make sure you are subscribed and have the bell notifications set to ALL (you may need to have your phone settings turned on for YouTube alerts as well). Otherwise, you can visit my channel's community section every Thursday, where the poll will run until Sunday. NEW EPISODES every Friday!
FRIGHT CLUB
Hosted by:
Zack Cherry
Written by:
Edward Alvarado
Zack Cherry
Edited by:
Zack Cherry
Music used in this video:
Impending Boom by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution licence (creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-free/index.html?isrc=USUAN1100198
Artist: incompetech.com
Searching For You by White Hex
If you enjoyed this video and would like to support this channel and FRIGHT CLUB, please check out my Patreon account for excluding bonus content, and gain early access to future episodes.
Patreon:
patreon.com/zackcherry
Instagram:
Zack @retrobitchface
Edward @edwardistruth
#MyBloodyValentine #Valentine2001 #FrightClub
Which Valentine's Day slasher is better, MY BLOODY VALENTINE (1981) ⛏ or VALENTINE (2001) 🏹 You guys voted, and the results are in!
Vote for next week's match ✅
YOU'RE NEXT 𝘷𝘴. READY OR NOT:
youtube.com/post/Ugw8k-ryYXNpdWTD2uV4AaABCQ
Previous Episode
GET OUT 𝘷𝘴. US: youtu.be/rFHyuNAKYTU
Welcome to FRIGHT CLUB, the horror movie battle ring where YOU vote for the winner. Make sure to check my channel's community tab every THURSDAY to vote for the latest match up.
Which film is better, My Bloody Valentine or Valentine?
In this episode we will be comparing Valentine's Day horror movies MY BLOODY VALENTINE (1981) with VALENTINE (2001).
Both of these holiday horror flicks are noteworthy for following the trends of 80s and 90s horror and more or less being a HALLOWEEN ripoff and a SCREAM ripoff set on Valentine's Day. Valentine even stars Marley Shelton, who would go on to appear in Scream 4.
Despite both films being derivative, they offer top notch kills, even in the face of severe MPAA censorship. They also both feature iconic an iconic Valentine's Day killer, with The Mine (aka Harry Warden) and The Cupid Killer (Jeremy Melton).
As these are the most notable Valentine's Day slashers out there, not including the 2009 remake MY BLOODY VALENTINE 3D, they're prime contenders for this fright. So place your bets. Which is better MY BLOODY VALENTINE or VALENTINE? The Miner vs. Cupid Killer.
With both films having amassed their own separate cult following, which one did you vote for as the best?
We will be comparing the movies in 5 rounds, followed by the results from the poll in which you voted on last week (found in the community section of this channel).
INTRO 0:00
Meet the contenders.
STORY 1:18
How compelling is the narrative?
CHARACTER 3:53
How well do they fit into the narrative (and are portrayed)?
PRODUCTION 5:41
The quality of the film's look and sound.
EXECUTION 7:37
How well does the film succeed at what it's attempting?
KILLS 9:30
Blood n' guts, baby!
THE VOTE 11:33
How many people voted, and which movie they voted for?
Toss this video a thumbs up if you enjoyed it, and let me know in the comments which one is your favorite.
If you would like to vote in future episodes, make sure you are subscribed and have the bell notifications set to ALL (you may need to have your phone settings turned on for YouTube alerts as well). Otherwise, you can visit my channel's community section every Thursday, where the poll will run until Sunday. NEW EPISODES every Friday!
FRIGHT CLUB
Hosted by:
Zack Cherry
Written by:
Edward Alvarado
Zack Cherry
Edited by:
Zack Cherry
Music used in this video:
Impending Boom by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution licence (creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-free/index.html?isrc=USUAN1100198
Artist: incompetech.com
Searching For You by White Hex
If you enjoyed this video and would like to support this channel and FRIGHT CLUB, please check out my Patreon account for excluding bonus content, and gain early access to future episodes.
Patreon:
patreon.com/zackcherry
Instagram:
Zack @retrobitchface
Edward @edwardistruth
#MyBloodyValentine #Valentine2001 #FrightClub
