Mormon Accidentally Proves Catholicism @BrianHoldsworth
Mormon Accidentally Proves Catholicism  @BrianHoldsworth
Uploaded January 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
Reducing the argument to ‘if not Catholicism, therefore the Great Apostasy’ is a textbook non-sequitur.

Sponsor: exodus90.com/brian
Support the channel by visiting: brianholdsworth.ca/help

In this video I analyze the recent debate between Catholic apologist Joe Heschmeyer and Mormon apologist Jacob Hansen, and show how his central LDS argument for a “Great Apostasy” commits a fatal logical fallacy: if not Catholicism, therefore Mormonism. I explain why this reasoning collapses, why the burden of proof is on the one claiming the Church disappeared, and how the historical record actually ends up pointing straight back to Catholicism.

Timestamps

00:00 – Why I watched the Heschmeyer vs. Hansen debate
02:17 – Shifting the burden of proof: Great Apostasy
03:11 – The “new revelation” argument and why it backfires
04:00 – Jesus as the fullness of revelation in Scripture
05:51 – The bank-teller analogy: proving something stopped existing
07:19 – Why Jacob’s argument is a textbook non-sequitur
08:29 – Accidentally providing evidence for Catholicism
09:24 – What evidence a real Great Apostasy would require
10:34 – Why the historical record looks overwhelmingly Catholic
11:39 – Presupposing Mormonism
12:49 – The dilemma that accidentally proves Catholicism

Music written and generously provided by Paul Jernberg. Find out more about his work as a composer here: pauljernberg.com

Podcast Version: brianholdsworth.libsyn.com
Mormon Accidentally Proves CatholicismThis is About Way More Than LiturgyObvious Proof of the SoulDid Donald Trump Really Do This?Why are Raves in Cathedrals a Bad Idea?The Only Reply You Need to these Muslim ArgumentsThe Sydney Sweeney Controversy Exposes EveryoneThis Prophesy Came TrueThe Clearest Sign of a Bad BishopFeminism: The Shadow Church w/ Dr. Carrie GressPope Francis Changed Me - RIPThe Malice of Liberal Christianity
Brian Holdsworth |

Mormon Accidentally Proves Catholicism

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER