Uploaded August 2025 | Updated November 2026, 6 hours ago
Play War Thunder now with my links, and get a massive, free bonus pack including vehicles, boosters and more on PC and consoles: playwt.link/fredda25 | Mobile: https://wtm.game/fredda
I criticized these creators and they doubled down on their positions on history. Two of them tried to frame me as a liar, a propagandist and a slanderer. One of my chief criticisms of them was that they don't cite sources. In their defense, they chose not to cite sources.
I wish I had time to work more on this video, but at the same time I would much rather be more productive talking about other topics and aspects of history, so maybe it's for the best. The time limitation meant I could not address everything, even so, this video sprawled out of control into something that ended up being over an hour long.
If you enjoy the video, please leave a like, I'm told it helps. If you have questions or suggestions please leave a comment, I do my best to read them all!
Bibliography:
- C. Atkins & P. Smith, “Columbia student Mahmoud Khalil was detained without an arrest warrant, Trump administration says” nbcnews.com, Apr 25, 2025 (accessed 27.08.2025)
- E.H. Carr, “What is History? 2nd ed.” (1990)
- Cornell Law School, "LLI, Wex, Defamation" law.cornell.edu, (accessed 25.08.2025)
- R.J. Evans “The Two Faces of E.H. Carr” archives.history.ac.uk, (accessed 26.08.2025)
- FinalFantasy, “Final Fantasy Tactics the Ivalice Chronicles (attached image)” x.com, Jun 5, 2025. (accessed 14:45 GMT+0, Jun 6, 2025)
- Fredda, “Youtube "Medievalists" are Weird: Metatron, Lindybeige, Shadiversity” youtube.com, Jun 29th, 2025.
- Fredda, “The Norwegian Plagiarism Scandal” youtube.com, Apr 11th, 2024.
- M. Gauchet “Right and Left” in Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Vol: 1 (1997)
- J.M. Lewis & T.R Hensley, “The May 4 Shootings at Kent State University: The Search for Historical Accuracy” in The Ohio Council for the Social Studies Review, Vol 34, No. 1 (summer 1998), pp. 9-21
- larsandersen23, “Debunking Viking Age Myths: Spear bow Origins” youtube.com, Jul 10, 2025
- Lindybeige, “Comment on ‘Youtube ”Medievalists” are Weird: Metatron, Lindybeige, Shadiversity’
- Loremaster of Sotek, “I Cannot be Silent. We Need to Talk.” youtube.com, Jun 6, 2020.
on Fredda, youtube.com, July 7th, 2025, estimated 16:00-17:00 UTC+0 (accessed 30.08.2025)
- Majorkill, “Why do people HATE Arch Warhammer?” youtube.com, Sep 29, 2021.
- Metatron, “This YouTuber Slandered Me, Shad and Lindybeige so We are taking him DOWN” youtube.com, Jul 30, 2025.
- J. Offenhartz, “Immigration agents arrest Palestinian activist who helped lead Columbia University protests” apnews.com, Mar 10, 2025. (accessed 27.08.2025)
- PunishedFredda, “Lindybeige wrote an essay in my comments.” x.com. Jul 7, 2025
- T. Ryssdalsnes, “Gratis utdanning er en av juvelene i den norske velferdsstaten” 19.08.2024 (accessed 29.08.2025)
- Sellsword Arts, “@shadiversity ATTACKED me over a Misunderstanding? A Response” youtube.com, Jan 21, 2024.
- Shadiversity, “He tried to destroy SHADIVERSITY, METATRON and LINDYBEIGE with lies- Fredda is an intellectual fraud” youtube.com, Jul 30, 2025.
- Shadiversity, “The SPEAR-BOW was REAL?!” youtube.com, Jul 5th, 2025
- Shadiversity, “They DID IT AGAIN and it's AWESOME!” youtube.com, Jul 18th, 2025
- Shadiversity, “How would a knight CHANGE a KATANA?” youtube.com, Jul 8th, 2025
- The Spokesman Review, “Roderick Stackelberg Obituary” legacy.com, May 13, 2018 (accessed 29.08.2025)
- R. Stackelberg, “Hitler’s Germany: Origins, Interpretations, Legacies” (1999)
- G.F Taylor, “The FBI COINTELPRO program and the Fred Hampton Assassination”, Huffpost.com, Dec 3, 2013. (Accessed 27.08.2025)
- E. Traverso, “Totalitarianism Between History and Theory” in History and Theory, December 2017, Vol. 56, No. 4, Theme Issue 55
#history #response
----------------------------------------------------------
Second Channel ► youtube.com/channel/UC_vmJ0eAvpVdPNgjZcFhemA
Twitter ► twitter.com/PunishedFredda
Patreon ► patreon.com/Fredda
Twitch ► twitch.tv/fredda_
Community Discord ► discord.gg/gRpyvYSwbs
----------------------------------------------------------
Play War Thunder now with my links, and get a massive, free bonus pack including vehicles, boosters and more on PC and consoles: playwt.link/fredda25 | Mobile: https://wtm.game/fredda
I criticized these creators and they doubled down on their positions on history. Two of them tried to frame me as a liar, a propagandist and a slanderer. One of my chief criticisms of them was that they don't cite sources. In their defense, they chose not to cite sources.
I wish I had time to work more on this video, but at the same time I would much rather be more productive talking about other topics and aspects of history, so maybe it's for the best. The time limitation meant I could not address everything, even so, this video sprawled out of control into something that ended up being over an hour long.
If you enjoy the video, please leave a like, I'm told it helps. If you have questions or suggestions please leave a comment, I do my best to read them all!
Bibliography:
- C. Atkins & P. Smith, “Columbia student Mahmoud Khalil was detained without an arrest warrant, Trump administration says” nbcnews.com, Apr 25, 2025 (accessed 27.08.2025)
- E.H. Carr, “What is History? 2nd ed.” (1990)
- Cornell Law School, "LLI, Wex, Defamation" law.cornell.edu, (accessed 25.08.2025)
- R.J. Evans “The Two Faces of E.H. Carr” archives.history.ac.uk, (accessed 26.08.2025)
- FinalFantasy, “Final Fantasy Tactics the Ivalice Chronicles (attached image)” x.com, Jun 5, 2025. (accessed 14:45 GMT+0, Jun 6, 2025)
- Fredda, “Youtube "Medievalists" are Weird: Metatron, Lindybeige, Shadiversity” youtube.com, Jun 29th, 2025.
- Fredda, “The Norwegian Plagiarism Scandal” youtube.com, Apr 11th, 2024.
- M. Gauchet “Right and Left” in Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Vol: 1 (1997)
- J.M. Lewis & T.R Hensley, “The May 4 Shootings at Kent State University: The Search for Historical Accuracy” in The Ohio Council for the Social Studies Review, Vol 34, No. 1 (summer 1998), pp. 9-21
- larsandersen23, “Debunking Viking Age Myths: Spear bow Origins” youtube.com, Jul 10, 2025
- Lindybeige, “Comment on ‘Youtube ”Medievalists” are Weird: Metatron, Lindybeige, Shadiversity’
- Loremaster of Sotek, “I Cannot be Silent. We Need to Talk.” youtube.com, Jun 6, 2020.
on Fredda, youtube.com, July 7th, 2025, estimated 16:00-17:00 UTC+0 (accessed 30.08.2025)
- Majorkill, “Why do people HATE Arch Warhammer?” youtube.com, Sep 29, 2021.
- Metatron, “This YouTuber Slandered Me, Shad and Lindybeige so We are taking him DOWN” youtube.com, Jul 30, 2025.
- J. Offenhartz, “Immigration agents arrest Palestinian activist who helped lead Columbia University protests” apnews.com, Mar 10, 2025. (accessed 27.08.2025)
- PunishedFredda, “Lindybeige wrote an essay in my comments.” x.com. Jul 7, 2025
- T. Ryssdalsnes, “Gratis utdanning er en av juvelene i den norske velferdsstaten” 19.08.2024 (accessed 29.08.2025)
- Sellsword Arts, “@shadiversity ATTACKED me over a Misunderstanding? A Response” youtube.com, Jan 21, 2024.
- Shadiversity, “He tried to destroy SHADIVERSITY, METATRON and LINDYBEIGE with lies- Fredda is an intellectual fraud” youtube.com, Jul 30, 2025.
- Shadiversity, “The SPEAR-BOW was REAL?!” youtube.com, Jul 5th, 2025
- Shadiversity, “They DID IT AGAIN and it's AWESOME!” youtube.com, Jul 18th, 2025
- Shadiversity, “How would a knight CHANGE a KATANA?” youtube.com, Jul 8th, 2025
- The Spokesman Review, “Roderick Stackelberg Obituary” legacy.com, May 13, 2018 (accessed 29.08.2025)
- R. Stackelberg, “Hitler’s Germany: Origins, Interpretations, Legacies” (1999)
- G.F Taylor, “The FBI COINTELPRO program and the Fred Hampton Assassination”, Huffpost.com, Dec 3, 2013. (Accessed 27.08.2025)
- E. Traverso, “Totalitarianism Between History and Theory” in History and Theory, December 2017, Vol. 56, No. 4, Theme Issue 55
#history #response
----------------------------------------------------------
Second Channel ► youtube.com/channel/UC_vmJ0eAvpVdPNgjZcFhemA
Twitter ► twitter.com/PunishedFredda
Patreon ► patreon.com/Fredda
Twitch ► twitch.tv/fredda_
Community Discord ► discord.gg/gRpyvYSwbs
----------------------------------------------------------




![Lets Play Kaiserreich Hoi4 [Finland] - Episode 11 - Winters Still Here, Wrangel
#kaiserreich #history #hoi4 #finland
Hearts of Iron 4 is a paradox grand strategy game of logistics, warfare and planning. Im playing the Kaiserreich mod which envisions an alternate-history scenario where Germany won the Great War among other things, and draws conclusions from it leading all the way up to the second world war.
Game Version: Hoi4 (1.6.2) with all expansions
Kaiserreich Version: (0.9)
Hearts of Iron 4 (Humble Store) ►https://www.humblebundle.com/store/hearts-of-iron-iv-cadet-edition?partner=fredda&charity=25618
Twitter ► https://twitter.com/IneptFredda
Discord ► https://discord.gg/bfMhgyx
Patreon ► https://www.patreon.com/Fredda
Kaiserreich ► https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1521695605&searchtext=Kaiserreich
Modlist ► https://pastebin.com/7wjmnQs9
If you enjoy the video please leave a like, Im told it helps.
If you have questions or anything to that effect, please leave a comment. I will do my best to read and respond. Lets Play Kaiserreich Hoi4 [Finland] - Episode 11 - Winters Still Here, Wrangel](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/kcCU7BqD3ls/mqdefault.jpg)
![Kaiserreich for Hearts of Iron 4 [German Empire] - Episode 21 - It Never Ends
#kaiserreich #history #hoi4
Hearts of Iron 4 is a paradox grand strategy game in which you stare at a ton of menus, fight nazis and sometimes you are the nazis. Im playing the Kaiserreich mod which envisions an alternate-history scenario where Germany won the Great War among other things, and draws conclusions from it leading all the way up to the second world war.
The game is being played on the most recent version of Hoi4 (1.6.2) with all expansions, and the most recent version of Kaiserreich (0.8.6)
You can get Hearts of Iron 4 on steam here: https://store.steampowered.com/app/394360/Hearts_of_Iron_IV/
You can get Kaiserreich here: https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1521695605&searchtext=Kaiserreich
You can find my modlist here: https://pastebin.com/7wjmnQs9
If you enjoy the video please leave a like, Im told it helps.
If you have questions or anything to that effect, please leave a comment. I will do my best to read and respond.
If you want to reach me or stay up to date with whats going on with the channel: https://twitter.com/IneptFredda
I do this for fun, but if youd like to give me a $ or something: https://www.patreon.com/Fredda Kaiserreich for Hearts of Iron 4 [German Empire] - Episode 21 - It Never Ends](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/l8zPndO5xew/mqdefault.jpg)
![Kaiserreich for Hearts of Iron 4 [German Empire] - Episode 31 - Musings on Military Strategy
#kaiserreich #history #hoi4
Hearts of Iron 4 is a paradox grand strategy game in which you stare at a ton of menus, fight nazis and sometimes you are the nazis. Im playing the Kaiserreich mod which envisions an alternate-history scenario where Germany won the Great War among other things, and draws conclusions from it leading all the way up to the second world war.
The game is being played on the most recent version of Hoi4 (1.6.2) with all expansions, and the most recent version of Kaiserreich (0.8.6)
Get Hearts of Iron 4 with my affiliate link which supports the channel at no extra cost!
Hearts of Iron IV: https://www.humblebundle.com/store/hearts-of-iron-iv-cadet-edition?partner=fredda&charity=25618
Man the Guns: https://www.humblebundle.com/store/hearts-of-iron-iv-cadet-edition?partner=fredda&charity=25618
You can get Kaiserreich here: https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1521695605&searchtext=Kaiserreich
You can find my modlist here: https://pastebin.com/7wjmnQs9
If you enjoy the video please leave a like, Im told it helps.
If you have questions or anything to that effect, please leave a comment. I will do my best to read and respond.
If you want to reach me or stay up to date with whats going on with the channel: https://twitter.com/IneptFredda
I do this for fun, but if youd like to give me a $ or something: https://www.patreon.com/Fredda Kaiserreich for Hearts of Iron 4 [German Empire] - Episode 31 - Musings on Military Strategy](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/lUCd2Dlq9LY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Kaiserreich Hoi4 [Papal State] (VOD) - Part 1 - Resurrecting the Republican Ideals
This was streamed live at Twitch.tv/Fredda_ on July 7th 2019.
Were playing as the Papal State in the Kaiserreich mod for Hearts of Iron 4. The goal is to create a constitutional monarchy, that restores the borders of the Roman Republic.
With this being a livestream VOD, expect interruptions, technical issues, expect me to stray from my usual commentary style and so on and so forth. If youd like to join the conversation, click the Twitch link below and give me a follow!
Twitch ► https://www.twitch.tv/fredda_
Twitter ► https://twitter.com/IneptFredda
Patreon ► https://www.patreon.com/Fredda
Discord ► https://discord.gg/bfMhgyx
Kaiserreich ► https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1521695605&searchtext=Kaiserreich
Modlist ► https://pastebin.com/7wjmnQs9
If you enjoy the video please leave a like, Im told it helps.
If you have questions or anything to that effect, please leave a comment. I will do my best to read and respond. Kaiserreich Hoi4 [Papal State] (VOD) - Part 1 - Resurrecting the Republican Ideals](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/lViOzHNr_A4/mqdefault.jpg)

![Lets Play Kaiserreich Hoi4 [USA] - Episode 1 - Welcome to America
Hearts of Iron 4 is a paradox grand strategy game of logistics, warfare and planning. Im playing the Kaiserreich mod which envisions an alternate-history scenario where Germany won the Great War among other things, and draws conclusions from it leading all the way up to the second world war.
Game Version: Hydra (1.7) with all expansions
Kaiserreich Version: (0.9.2)
#kaiserreich #history #hoi4 #usa #letsplay
Hearts of Iron 4 (Humble Store) ►https://www.humblebundle.com/store/hearts-of-iron-iv-cadet-edition?partner=fredda&charity=25618
Twitter ► https://twitter.com/IneptFredda
Twitch ► https://www.twitch.tv/fredda_
Patreon ► https://www.patreon.com/Fredda
Discord ► https://discord.gg/bfMhgyx
Kaiserreich ► https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1521695605&searchtext=Kaiserreich
Modlist ► https://pastebin.com/7wjmnQs9
If you enjoy the video please leave a like, Im told it helps.
If you have questions or anything to that effect, please leave a comment. I will do my best to read and respond. Lets Play Kaiserreich Hoi4 [USA] - Episode 1 - Welcome to America](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/mAbbe90LvYU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Lets Play Kaiserreich Hoi4 [Finland] - Episode 16 - Preparing for the Last War
Hearts of Iron 4 is a paradox grand strategy game of logistics, warfare and planning. Im playing the Kaiserreich mod which envisions an alternate-history scenario where Germany won the Great War among other things, and draws conclusions from it leading all the way up to the second world war.
Game Version: Hoi4 (1.6.2) with all expansions
Kaiserreich Version: (0.9)
#kaiserreich #history #hoi4 #finland #letsplay
Hearts of Iron 4 (Humble Store) ►https://www.humblebundle.com/store/hearts-of-iron-iv-cadet-edition?partner=fredda&charity=25618
Twitter ► https://twitter.com/IneptFredda
Twitch ► https://www.twitch.tv/fredda_
Discord ► https://discord.gg/bfMhgyx
Patreon ► https://www.patreon.com/Fredda
Kaiserreich ► https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1521695605&searchtext=Kaiserreich
Modlist ► https://pastebin.com/7wjmnQs9
If you enjoy the video please leave a like, Im told it helps.
If you have questions or anything to that effect, please leave a comment. I will do my best to read and respond. Lets Play Kaiserreich Hoi4 [Finland] - Episode 16 - Preparing for the Last War](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/mHFXIsCa4OA/mqdefault.jpg)