Metatron and Shadiversity Responded to Me (it was bad) @FreddaYT
Metatron and Shadiversity Responded to Me (it was bad)  @FreddaYT
Uploaded August 2025 | Updated November 2026, 6 hours ago
Play War Thunder now with my links, and get a massive, free bonus pack including vehicles, boosters and more on PC and consoles: playwt.link/fredda25 | Mobile: https://wtm.game/fredda

I criticized these creators and they doubled down on their positions on history. Two of them tried to frame me as a liar, a propagandist and a slanderer. One of my chief criticisms of them was that they don't cite sources. In their defense, they chose not to cite sources.

I wish I had time to work more on this video, but at the same time I would much rather be more productive talking about other topics and aspects of history, so maybe it's for the best. The time limitation meant I could not address everything, even so, this video sprawled out of control into something that ended up being over an hour long.

If you enjoy the video, please leave a like, I'm told it helps. If you have questions or suggestions please leave a comment, I do my best to read them all!

Bibliography:

- C. Atkins & P. Smith, “Columbia student Mahmoud Khalil was detained without an arrest warrant, Trump administration says” nbcnews.com, Apr 25, 2025 (accessed 27.08.2025)
- E.H. Carr, “What is History? 2nd ed.” (1990)
- Cornell Law School, "LLI, Wex, Defamation" law.cornell.edu, (accessed 25.08.2025)
- R.J. Evans “The Two Faces of E.H. Carr” archives.history.ac.uk, (accessed 26.08.2025)
- FinalFantasy, “Final Fantasy Tactics the Ivalice Chronicles (attached image)” x.com, Jun 5, 2025. (accessed 14:45 GMT+0, Jun 6, 2025)
- Fredda, “Youtube "Medievalists" are Weird: Metatron, Lindybeige, Shadiversity” youtube.com, Jun 29th, 2025.
- Fredda, “The Norwegian Plagiarism Scandal” youtube.com, Apr 11th, 2024.
- M. Gauchet “Right and Left” in Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Vol: 1 (1997)
- J.M. Lewis & T.R Hensley, “The May 4 Shootings at Kent State University: The Search for Historical Accuracy” in The Ohio Council for the Social Studies Review, Vol 34, No. 1 (summer 1998), pp. 9-21
- larsandersen23, “Debunking Viking Age Myths: Spear bow Origins” youtube.com, Jul 10, 2025
- Lindybeige, “Comment on ‘Youtube ”Medievalists” are Weird: Metatron, Lindybeige, Shadiversity’
- Loremaster of Sotek, “I Cannot be Silent. We Need to Talk.” youtube.com, Jun 6, 2020.
on Fredda, youtube.com, July 7th, 2025, estimated 16:00-17:00 UTC+0 (accessed 30.08.2025)
- Majorkill, “Why do people HATE Arch Warhammer?” youtube.com, Sep 29, 2021.
- Metatron, “This YouTuber Slandered Me, Shad and Lindybeige so We are taking him DOWN” youtube.com, Jul 30, 2025.
- J. Offenhartz, “Immigration agents arrest Palestinian activist who helped lead Columbia University protests” apnews.com, Mar 10, 2025. (accessed 27.08.2025)
- PunishedFredda, “Lindybeige wrote an essay in my comments.” x.com. Jul 7, 2025
- T. Ryssdalsnes, “Gratis utdanning er en av juvelene i den norske velferdsstaten” 19.08.2024 (accessed 29.08.2025)
- Sellsword Arts, “‪@shadiversity‬ ATTACKED me over a Misunderstanding? A Response” youtube.com, Jan 21, 2024.
- Shadiversity, “He tried to destroy SHADIVERSITY, METATRON and LINDYBEIGE with lies- Fredda is an intellectual fraud” youtube.com, Jul 30, 2025.
- Shadiversity, “The SPEAR-BOW was REAL?!” youtube.com, Jul 5th, 2025
- Shadiversity, “They DID IT AGAIN and it's AWESOME!” youtube.com, Jul 18th, 2025
- Shadiversity, “How would a knight CHANGE a KATANA?” youtube.com, Jul 8th, 2025
- The Spokesman Review, “Roderick Stackelberg Obituary” legacy.com, May 13, 2018 (accessed 29.08.2025)
- R. Stackelberg, “Hitler’s Germany: Origins, Interpretations, Legacies” (1999)
- G.F Taylor, “The FBI COINTELPRO program and the Fred Hampton Assassination”, Huffpost.com, Dec 3, 2013. (Accessed 27.08.2025)
- E. Traverso, “Totalitarianism Between History and Theory” in History and Theory, December 2017, Vol. 56, No. 4, Theme Issue 55


#history #response
----------------------------------------------------------
Second Channel ► youtube.com/channel/UC_vmJ0eAvpVdPNgjZcFhemA
Twitter ► twitter.com/PunishedFredda
Patreon ► patreon.com/Fredda
Twitch ► twitch.tv/fredda_
Community Discord ► discord.gg/gRpyvYSwbs
----------------------------------------------------------
Metatron and Shadiversity Responded to Me (it was bad)Anglophobia Simulator | AC: Valhalla | LIVEKaiserreich Version 0.9 Aurora Borealis is out!Lets Play Cataclysm: Dark Days Ahead | Cletus | Ep. 6 | Bicycle ScoutingDwarf Fortress - New Players Welcome - LIVELets Play Kaiserreich Hoi4 [Finland] - Episode 11 - Winters Still Here, WrangelKaiserreich for Hearts of Iron 4 [German Empire] - Episode 21 - It Never EndsKaiserreich for Hearts of Iron 4 [German Empire] - Episode 31 - Musings on Military StrategyKaiserreich Hoi4 [Papal State] (VOD) - Part 1 - Resurrecting the Republican IdealsCataclysm: Dark Days Ahead | Cletus | Ep. 3 | BackstoryLets Play Kaiserreich Hoi4 [USA] - Episode 1 - Welcome to AmericaLets Play Kaiserreich Hoi4 [Finland] - Episode 16 - Preparing for the Last War
Fredda |

Metatron and Shadiversity Responded to Me (it was bad)

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER