Mandatory ID collection into a police database violates the Charter: R v Khairullah @privacylawyer
Mandatory ID collection into a police database violates the Charter: R v Khairullah  @privacylawyer
Uploaded March 2025 | Updated September 2026, 1 hour ago
The recent case of R v Khairullah, 2025 ABCJ 14, found that the "know your customer" requirements for scrap metal dealers in Alberta violates Section 8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Court determined that requiring scrap metal dealers to collect and record personal information of sellers, and then provide it to a police-accessible database, makes the dealers agents of the state conducting unreasonable searches. You can read the case here: canlii.ca/t/k91m4

Where you can find me
► Privacylawyer blog: blog.privacylawyer.ca
► My law firm: mcinnescooper.com
► Twitter: twitter.com/privacylawyer
► LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/davidtsfraser

Disclaimer: This is intended for education and information only and should not be taken as legal advice. If you need advice for your particular situation, you should seek out qualified counsel.

All views expressed are solely those of the creator and should not be attributed to his firm or any of its clients.
Mandatory ID collection into a police database violates the Charter: R v KhairullahCanadas new proposed law to outlaw explicit deepfakes: Bill C-16The Canadian Social Media Ban for Kids in Bill C-34 is UnconstitutionalAppeal court reverses Facebook’s Canadian privacy winA Christmas [Privacy] Carol - 2024 Holiday SpecialConsequences of passing Bill C22 Lawful Access Act Supporting Authorized Access to Information ActCanadas Privacy Regulators vs. TikTok: A critical overviewNew “real world” guidance on data breach notification and reporting - real risk of significant harmWhat privacy law applies to contractors? Privacy regulators need to clean up the mess they created.Takedowns of content based on mere suspicion under Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActThe really bad age verification bill is back in Canadas ParliamentBill C-34s social media ban for young people
PrivacyLawyer - David Fraser |

Mandatory ID collection into a police database violates the Charter: R v Khairullah

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER