Uploaded February 2025 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Prof John O'Quigley looks at the statistics behind the Letby case and shows conclusively that there is no case to answer. The statistical chart used is mere smoke and mirrors and doesn't stand up to academic scrutiny. The full academic paper can be found here osf.io/hqzrw
John O’Quigley is a professor at University College London. He has worked in the University of Paris at the Sorbonne, University of California San Diego, University of Washington, Seattle, the University of Virginia Medical School and the Dept of Mathematics at Lancaster University.
Timestamp
00:00 Lucy Letby: Statistical Smoke and Mirrors with John O'Quigley
02:09 The statistical case against Letby
07:09 How the suspicious cases were chosen through selection bias
18:14 "The chart presented in court is absolutely bogus"
24:00 Reconstructing the missing data for a complete picture
31:44 Calculating the odds that Letby is guilty with the full data
37:32 Calculating the odds for anyone working more shifts than normal
40:48 Comparing Letby's odds with any nurse working over the average
43:10 Letby's odds are what they should be for ANYONE working 33% more
46:00 Conclusion This nurse is in prison without having done anything wrong
Prof John O'Quigley looks at the statistics behind the Letby case and shows conclusively that there is no case to answer. The statistical chart used is mere smoke and mirrors and doesn't stand up to academic scrutiny. The full academic paper can be found here osf.io/hqzrw
John O’Quigley is a professor at University College London. He has worked in the University of Paris at the Sorbonne, University of California San Diego, University of Washington, Seattle, the University of Virginia Medical School and the Dept of Mathematics at Lancaster University.
Timestamp
00:00 Lucy Letby: Statistical Smoke and Mirrors with John O'Quigley
02:09 The statistical case against Letby
07:09 How the suspicious cases were chosen through selection bias
18:14 "The chart presented in court is absolutely bogus"
24:00 Reconstructing the missing data for a complete picture
31:44 Calculating the odds that Letby is guilty with the full data
37:32 Calculating the odds for anyone working more shifts than normal
40:48 Comparing Letby's odds with any nurse working over the average
43:10 Letby's odds are what they should be for ANYONE working 33% more
46:00 Conclusion This nurse is in prison without having done anything wrong










