LIVE! with Q&A:  A pre-Christian Dying Messiah? Responding to Richard C. Carriers Incompetence @DrKippDavis
LIVE! with Q&A:  A pre-Christian Dying Messiah? Responding to Richard C. Carriers Incompetence  @DrKippDavis
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Last month, Dr. Richard C. Carrier—author of "On the History of Jesus," and the more recent book, "The Obsolete Paradigm of A Historical Jesus" (which failed peer review)—announced the publication of a "major" article in which he asserts that "the vast majority of the dozens of experts ... agree" that there was a prominent expectation for a dying messiah "at least a century prior to Christianity." As we have come to expect from Dr. Carrier, the paper is neither "major," nor does it manage to do what he claims. The article is terrible, which is probably why it was not published in a top-tier journal.

The @godlessengineer hosted Carrier on a livestream last month to discuss the findings of his article.

Join me and @Vishanti today, as we review Carrier's presentation and take a closer look at the contents of his article, and the question: "Did Any Pre-Christian Jews Expect a Dying-and-Rising Messiah?" I expect to produce a more formal response to the article itself in the near future, but in the meantime, we shall see how Carrier somehow arrived at his conclusions from the sources he is attempting—poorly—to read and engage with.

Carrier's announcement: richardcarrier.info/archives/43806
Carrier's presentation on The @godlessengineer: youtube.com/watch?v=v1H81Hc1IkM

As always, Q&A will follow. Superchat for priority.

CLICK HERE to watch this stream in the alternative format: youtube.com/live/3oHclezd-tA
BUY THE BOOK HERE: https://a.co/d/4QBMXLr

Please, also subscribe to @Vishanti

I have Channel Memberships! Join today to unlock emojis, special live chat options and early access to my videos.

Interested in learning biblical Hebrew? Check out the course offerings at Digital Hammurabi, where you can choose from a growing selection of ancient languages: digitalhammurabi.com/language-classes

Patrons get early access to all my material for as little as $4 a month: patreon.com/kippdavis

Buy my 14-hour, 18-lecture course, "Real Israelite Religions: Facts on the Ground and Propaganda in the Bible," and own it for life:
sales.mvp-courses.com/israelite-religions/?affiliate=mythvision

Follow me on Twitter: twitter.com/DrKippDavis
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/drkippd.bsky.social

🎙️ New to streaming or looking to level up? Check out StreamYard and get $10 discount! 😍 streamyard.com/pal/d/6570013047914496
LIVE! with Q&A:  A pre-Christian Dying Messiah? Responding to Richard C. Carriers IncompetenceLIVE! with Q&A: Joe Schmid, @MajestyofReason, and why philosophers suck at the BibleLIVE! with Q&A:  Correcting @TruthUnites about slavery in the Bible ... againLIVE! with Q&A: Canadian Thanksgiving and New Testament manuscripts with @cjcornthwaiteLIVE! with Q&A: @InspiringPhilosophy debates Muslims because he cant read the BibleLIVE! with Q&A: The Bible is Mythology—responding to William Lane Craig & @SeanMcDowellLIVE! with Q&A: @InspiringPhilosophy sucks at history, with @Paulogia and @cjcornthwaiteLIVE! with Q&A: When gods walked among men—Responding to @TruthUnites  on Genesis 6 📱LIVE! with Q&A: Inspiring Philosophy—same mistakes, different day (with Lorence@TheBeholdNetwork)Budget Scripture Saturday with @TheHumanityLive & @tapiocaweasel — The Turtledove is your godReading Hebrew with Dr. Kipp & friends: Qryat Ibrit 75—Zech. 11:4 ff. with @maklelanLIVE! with Q&A: Michael Jones is totally wrong about Israelites — @InspiringPhilosophy response 📱
Kipp Davis |

LIVE! with Q&A: A pre-Christian "Dying Messiah"? Responding to Richard C. Carrier's Incompetence

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER