Letter from Dr. J. Carter, Professor   Dont Settle for Pudding-Brained Rebuttals of Sal @EvidenceandReasons
Letter from Dr. J. Carter, Professor   Dont Settle for Pudding-Brained Rebuttals of Sal  @EvidenceandReasons
Uploaded July 2022 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
If you want quality critiques of Sal, go to Jordan K, Dr. Dan, Erika Gutsick Gibbon, Dapper Dino, and PhD Tony. Don't settle for Pudding-Brained rebuttals.

Speaking of which, TONIGHT, July 26, 2022 Jordan K will criticize some of Sal's views on Sal's Academic Channel, the ER Academy at 10PM:
youtube.com/watch?v=2FCcRkkYwY8

Sal will read and comment on his MDD debate and the role of debate in the Creation/Evolution Controversy. It will include input from a letter from Dr. James Carter, a professor of Organic and Biochemistry for 16 years, and student of science for 27 years.

==================================================
From: James Carter [REDACTED]
Sent: Monday, July 25, 2022 1:31 PM
To: Salvador Cordova [REDACTED]
Subject: MDD Debate

Greetings Sal!

I caught your recent debate against TJump and PhD Tony on MDD. Too bad James didn’t partner you up with a geologist to help address some of the questions that Tony brought up. Both of your opponents were obnoxiously condescending and I think you stood your ground well.

I saw your after show and liked your perspective about playing the long game by drawing out questions from new opponents so you can research their questions and come back with answers someday. I also don’t know much about geology or paleontology so I like learning more about the fields and finding fresh challenges to combat.

The argument about cosmogenic exposure (nuclide) dating (CED) was new to me but I think Paul Giem has presented on it in the past because I recall him discussing Beryllium-10. I asked him for a copy of the presentation or recording and will let you know what he says.

My geologist buddy Dr. [REDACTED], who is also an advisor on the Long Story Short abiogenesis critique team, is a sedimentologist so he isn’t very familiar with CED either. A quick search on ICR, Creation.com, and AIG didn’t turn out much, although CED was briefly mentioned at the end of Ch. 3 in John Baumgardner’s book "Thousands, Not Billions". I did find a few possible sources of anomalies in the method on this website: antarcticglaciers.org/glacial-geology/dating-glacial-sediments-2/cosmogenic_nuclide_datin

Let me know if you learn anything more about CED and I’ll do the same.

In the mean time, if you want some fresh arguments for the geologic record not being millions of years old, check out Dr. [REDACTED's work]...I can send you a copy.


During the MDD Q&A, StupidWh0reEnergy brought up a really old argument about the Yellowstone Petrified forest that "stumped" you (pun intended, haha). Not many people know about it but my church’s Geoscience Research Institute, which has a branch located on my University’s campus here at Loma Linda, publishes a free journal called "Origins". The entire 1997 issue (Vol. 24, No. 1) was dedicated to challenging the argument that StupidWh0reEnergy brought up. It is the culmination of years of research by Harold G. Coffin, Ph.D., who received assistance from other Creation researchers, including Dr. Steve Austin. They conclude that the layers of trees are not different years of growth, burial, new growth, etc., but rather vertical deposits of broken and transported logs from a catastrophic flood, much like the trees that settled at different rates and were buried in the silty waters of Spirit Lake soon after Mt. Saint Helens erupted.

grisda.org/origins-24005

I have seen counter-arguments to many of the other issues that PhD Tony brought up, including dendrochronology, ice-core dating, varves, etc. so I encourage you to research them as well.

Hope you are doing well Sal! I look forward to hearing how your recent presentation went.

Blessings,
James Carter
=======================================

Sal will additionally give thoughts on a cyberstalking troll who is a high school dropout and pathologically delusional bloviator. The troll's behavior is consistent with dementia and brain damage from a long history of alcoholism. Alcohol can turn a brain into pudding. Don't become a pudding brain.

Sal will also comment on SFT, Raw Matt and Kent Hovind, and Paul Price formerly of CMI.

Sal appeared on an Aritificial Intelligence Podcast for an entire month with Robert Marks:
mindmatters.ai/podcast/ep189

mindmatters.ai/podcast/ep190

mindmatters.ai/podcast/ep191

mindmatters.ai/podcast/ep192

Robert Marks prominently feature in Evolution News and Views:
evolutionnews.org/2022/07/robert-j-marks-could-artificial-intelligence-replace-tom-cruise

The non-Computable You:
amazon.com/dp/163712015X


If you feel this channel has blessed you and others, you're invited to donate gifts via PayPal:
paypal.com/donate/?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=7SXFF8FM2YBSE
Letter from Dr. J. Carter, Professor   Dont Settle for Pudding-Brained Rebuttals of SalChannel Announcement and Update, Personal Ramble 9/19/25Honoring Dr. Dan and Dr. Joel at the Creation Research SocietyDr. Royal Truman, Scientist and Christian,  Grayson the Epitome of Brandolinis Law and BS ArtistryMBC LAWSUIT:  Platt team facing jury trial,  breech of contract and fraud rulings in Fairfax CourtGod Bless America on Veterans Day 11/11/22The Casino of Life (from the movie Expelled)Machines in Biology and Humes statement of the Intelligent Design ArgumentRebekah and Sal talk about the failure of The Big Bang TheoryInvestigateMBC:  MBC at Risk of Another LawsuitAFTERSHOW:  Modern Day Debate: Christopher & Sal vs.  TJump & PhD TonyYEC Scientist Sal interviews OEC Scientist Hugh Ross
Evidence and Reasons |

Letter from Dr. J. Carter, Professor -- Don't Settle for Pudding-Brained Rebuttals of Sal

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER