Lessons From America: Canada Needs Industrial Policy That Takes Risks @EnergiMedia
Lessons From America: Canada Needs Industrial Policy That Takes Risks  @EnergiMedia
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Canada cannot lead in every technology. It can choose where to compete, fund those bets properly, and stop backing projects that fail to deliver.

David Victor joins Markham Hislop to explain what American energy innovation can teach Canada about industrial policy. Victor served on the National Academies committee that evaluated ARPA-E, the energy innovation agency modelled on DARPA.

We discuss how expert program managers select and oversee portfolios of risky technologies, why spreading money too thin undermines innovation, and how government helps promising ideas move from research to commercial projects.

Victor also explains why loan guarantees serve a different purpose from early research funding, why a failed investment does not automatically mean failed policy, and why access to global markets matters especially for Canada.

The bigger question: can Canada build globally competitive industries without institutions prepared to take technological risks?

Chapters
00:00 What Industrial Policy Actually Means
01:03 DARPA and the Origins of the American Model
02:03 ARPA-E and Energy Innovation
03:11 Lessons for Canada
04:33 Concentrated Investment and Expert Management
05:37 Risk and the Meaning of Failure
06:12 Competing at the Technological Frontier
08:17 ARPA-E Under Trump
10:11 Research Funding and Loan Guarantees
13:06 Why the Whole Innovation System Must Work
14:35 Where to Compete With China
16:24 Political Risk and the Solyndra Lesson
19:42 Technologies to Watch
21:36 Can Economies Compete Without Industrial Policy?
23:11 Global Markets and the Cost of Capital
#IndustrialPolicy #ARPAE #EnergyInnovation #Canada #CleanTechnology #EnergiTalks
Lessons From America: Canada Needs Industrial Policy That Takes RisksMark Campanale, CEO of Carbon Tracker on the Rapidly Accelerating Energy TransitionCanadian Consumers Should Expect Middle East War to Keep Gas Prrces HighDanielle Smiths Survival Strategy.  Duane Bratt on how Danielle Smith could remain premier.Majority of Albertans Blame Danielle Smith for Unleashing SeparatismTrump 3.0: Why a Weakened Trump Will Be Worse for EveryoneUS Energy Is Changing Faster Than Trump Can ControlCharlie Angus: Trump, Smith and the Cost of Canada’s Oil GambleWhy the Strait of Hormuz Crisis Won’t Be Fixed QuicklyAre BC Conservatives Following Trump - Steven WeldonAbishur Prakash: Canada Should Prepare for More Trump PressureTrump Is a Lame Duck President But Still Dangerous to Canada
Energi Media |

Lessons From America: Canada Needs Industrial Policy That Takes Risks

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER