Uploaded December 2010 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Leon Billings, a former legislative aide to Sen Edmund Muskie, D-ME, wrote many of the major provisions of the Clean Air Act of 1970. In this interview with correspondent Dan Goldstein, he talks about how the act is being used today to regulate greenhouse gas emissions and talks about the future of emissions legislation.
Billings says lobbyists for those who oppose the Clean Air Act are pervasive in Washington, but he does not believe they have as much influence as they want their clients to believe. He says industry money would be better spent on pollution controls than on lawyers who believe they can weaken the Clean Air Act.
The success of the Clean Air Act as opposed to the failure of cap-and-trade legislation in Congress is a matter, says Billings, of changing political times. He says the fact that most of the basic decisions were made behind closed doors is important because many of the lawmakers would not have been willing to take progressive positions in open meetings where their constituents might be watching.
Billings says one of the reasons the the cap-and-trade bill did not succeed in the U.S. Senate is because it was not jointly drafted by lawmakers with competing interests who could then sit down and compromise. He says that's another reason the Clean Air Act succeeded. Lawmakers came to a consensus because they had a stake in the outcome. He says the cap-and-trade bill started out that way in the House, but it did not come to fruition in the Senate because it was drafted by only one side, whose opponents sat out the whole process.
Billings believes the Clean Air Act is not the best vehicle to attack carbon dioxide emissions. He says it's better suited for methane, black carbon and fluorocarbons. But he says the technology to control carbon dioxide emissions is not available at the level of reductions needed. He says the Clean Air Cat could be used against itself in some respect, and the idea of tailoring it to large emissions of carbon dioxide may be "stretching it."
He predicts that ...
Leon Billings, a former legislative aide to Sen Edmund Muskie, D-ME, wrote many of the major provisions of the Clean Air Act of 1970. In this interview with correspondent Dan Goldstein, he talks about how the act is being used today to regulate greenhouse gas emissions and talks about the future of emissions legislation.
Billings says lobbyists for those who oppose the Clean Air Act are pervasive in Washington, but he does not believe they have as much influence as they want their clients to believe. He says industry money would be better spent on pollution controls than on lawyers who believe they can weaken the Clean Air Act.
The success of the Clean Air Act as opposed to the failure of cap-and-trade legislation in Congress is a matter, says Billings, of changing political times. He says the fact that most of the basic decisions were made behind closed doors is important because many of the lawmakers would not have been willing to take progressive positions in open meetings where their constituents might be watching.
Billings says one of the reasons the the cap-and-trade bill did not succeed in the U.S. Senate is because it was not jointly drafted by lawmakers with competing interests who could then sit down and compromise. He says that's another reason the Clean Air Act succeeded. Lawmakers came to a consensus because they had a stake in the outcome. He says the cap-and-trade bill started out that way in the House, but it did not come to fruition in the Senate because it was drafted by only one side, whose opponents sat out the whole process.
Billings believes the Clean Air Act is not the best vehicle to attack carbon dioxide emissions. He says it's better suited for methane, black carbon and fluorocarbons. But he says the technology to control carbon dioxide emissions is not available at the level of reductions needed. He says the Clean Air Cat could be used against itself in some respect, and the idea of tailoring it to large emissions of carbon dioxide may be "stretching it."
He predicts that ...










