LAWSUIT DRAFTED: HeeHaw’s mom’s attorney says they are prepared to take the case to federal court @TheRealPaulMueller
LAWSUIT DRAFTED: HeeHaw’s mom’s attorney says they are prepared to take the case to federal court  @TheRealPaulMueller
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
Cedartown, Georgia - The attorney representing Hannah Israel says a lawsuit over the shooting death of her beloved miniature donkey, HeeHaw, has already been drafted and could soon be filed if answers and evidence are not produced.

During my exclusive interview, attorney Chris McCormick said the case raises serious Fourth Amendment questions involving Hannah’s property rights and whether the use of lethal force against HeeHaw was reasonable.

“We’re not just going to sit on the sidelines,” McCormick said. “If we’re not going to have movement sooner rather than later, a lawsuit which has already been drafted is going to be filed.”

McCormick said the most important evidence will be the body-camera footage and the Rockmart Fire Department’s drone recording. Neither recording has been publicly released.

“The proof is in the pudding,” McCormick said. “The drone and the body cam. That’s, in my view, step one.”

The recordings could help answer the question at the center of this case: What did HeeHaw do in the moments before Cedartown Police Officer Trenton Garner fired the shot?

Garner wrote in his incident report that HeeHaw began to charge and that he fired to prevent injury to a K-9 handler and K-9 team. However, when a reporter asked Cedartown Police Chief Jamie Newsome whether Garner said he feared for his life, Newsome answered, “No.”

McCormick said the case could ultimately hinge on whether Garner’s actions were those of a reasonable officer facing the same circumstances.

Hannah described HeeHaw as a bottle-raised, approximately 100-pound miniature donkey who stood less than 30 inches tall. She said he regularly interacted with children, attended petting zoos and even visited nursing-home residents in a memory-care unit.

She said she had never seen him behave aggressively.

“He met so many people in so many different situations,” Hannah said. “The only thing that could have been in his brain was, ‘Hey, who’s come to see me, or who am I about to meet right now?’”

Hannah also described searching the 20-acre pasture for more than an hour before finding HeeHaw’s body.

“It was very traumatizing,” she said. “The farm is not the same. My home is not the same anymore.”

McCormick also raised another significant question: Why was Hannah reportedly not contacted before officers entered the pasture, even though law enforcement allegedly had her telephone number?

“What blows my mind is there was never an attempt, as I understand it, to contact my client,” McCormick said.

He also questioned why the officers themselves did not immediately notify Hannah afterward or help her locate HeeHaw.

HeeHaw’s remains were taken as part of the Georgia Department of Agriculture’s investigation. McCormick said he understands they were sent to the University of Georgia for a necropsy and that he was assured they would eventually be returned to Hannah.

McCormick said extensive requests have been made for evidence and records, including video and audio recordings, police reports, communications, training materials, employment files and information concerning the firearm, Taser and drone involved.

He acknowledged that agencies may have discretion to withhold certain records during an active investigation and cautioned against assuming that the delay means evidence is being concealed.

McCormick also confirmed that he has sent five cease-and-desist notices concerning online statements about Hannah. He said she has never been arrested, charged or cited for animal cruelty and warned against presenting unverified allegations as established facts.

Hannah said she has not received physical threats, but she has faced intense online hostility and misrepresentation while trying to grieve and continue operating her farm.

McCormick also clarified that neither he nor Hannah organized or helped plan the announced protest. He said they learned about it online and do not want their effort for transparency portrayed as an attempt to create chaos or strong-arm authorities.

His message throughout the interview was simple: This case is not about turning tragedy into a financial reward.

If Hannah eventually receives monetary compensation, McCormick said, “It’s an award, not a reward.”

“We’re not asking to be rewarded with anything,” he said. “There’s a deterrent mechanism here too. We want to make sure that other animals are not slaughtered in this manner.”

McCormick says he is prepared to take the case the distance.

“I was born for a storm,” he said. “Calmness doesn’t suit me.”

Hannah wants answers. Her attorney wants the evidence. The public deserves transparency.

Release the body-camera footage. Release the drone recording. Let the evidence show exactly what happened to HeeHaw.

RESOURCES and continuing coverage are in my pinned comment below ↓

Please keep all communication peaceful, lawful and respectful. No threats, harassment or interference with the active investigation.

#JusticeForHeeHaw #TheRealPaulMueller #AnimalWarriors
LAWSUIT DRAFTED: HeeHaw’s mom’s attorney says they are prepared to take the case to federal courtBREAKING: HeeHaw Bodycam Released | Officer Moves to Dismiss Federal LawsuitIn Danger: A NYC firehouse dog is in urgent need of a homeThe dispatch communication:  K9 Ace comes face to face with dangerOnly a Slap. Man Arrested After Allegedly Beating Dog to Death and Burying Him in the Backyard
TheRealPaulMueller |

LAWSUIT DRAFTED: HeeHaw’s mom’s attorney says they are prepared to take the case to federal court

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER