Uploaded December 2012 | Updated November 2026, 2 hours ago
(Part 1 of 3) Los Angeles City Council deliberation on the Koretz/Rosendahl Resolution on Southern California Edison's damaged San Onofre nuclear power plant. Paul Koretz; Jose Huizar; Bill Rosendahl; Ed Reyes; Dennis Zine
R E S O L U T I O N
WHEREAS, any official position of the City of Los Angeles with respect to legislation, rules, regulations or policies proposed to or pending before a local, state or federal governmental body or agency must have first been adopted in the form of a Resolution by the City Council with the concurrence of the Mayor; and
WHEREAS, Southern California Edison's (Edison) four replacement steam generators manufactured by Mitsubishi for the two nuclear reactors at San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant (San Onofre) were shut down after one of the tubes released radiation in January 2012; and
WHEREAS, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) determined that the crippled steam generators present a serious safety risk; and
WHEREAS, Edison recently submitted a plan to the NRC to restart San Onofre Unit 2 at 70% power for 150 days as an interim compensatory action while the utility considers a long-term plan for repairing the steam generators; and
WHEREAS, in 2011, the NRC recommended a fifty mile evacuation zone
WHEREAS, portions of Los Angeles are within fifty miles of San Onofre and therefore within the danger zone of any radiation leak or worse disaster; and
WHEREAS, it is vitally important to ensure the health and well-being of the general public, the power plant workers, the potentially-affected residents of Los Angeles, and the environment; and
WHEREAS, federal regulations provide that a formal license amendment with an adjudicatory hearing is the appropriate and transparent process by which the NRC can evaluate the safety of the major design changes made at San Onofre, as this process ensures public participation in a formal evidentiary, regulatory process; and
WHEREAS, any other process than a license amendment with an evidentiary hearing is insufficient for public safety; in fact, NRC allowed an alternative, less transparent, more perfunctory review process during the application of the very steam generators which FAILED at San Onofre, and the problems with these generators may well have been discovered through the more appropriate, thorough license amendment process; and
WHEREAS, environmental and community groups, as well as other cities in the region, including Santa Monica, Del Mar and Laguna Beach, are concerned that Edison appears to be trying to circumvent the formal amendment license process and are calling on the NRC to require that Edison seek San Onofre restart approval ONLY through that formal license amendment process;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, with the concurrence of the Mayor, that by the adoption of this Resolution, the City of Los Angeles hereby includes in its 2011-2012 Federal Legislative Program SUPPORT for action by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to make no decision about restarting either San Onofre Unit until Edison has completed a thorough, public, transparent license amendment with an adjudicatory hearing on whether it is safe to restart either reactor and a determination of what repairs, replacements, or other actions by Edison are necessary to guarantee both short- and long-term public safety.
video-2012-12-16-14-52-05.mp4
(Part 1 of 3) Los Angeles City Council deliberation on the Koretz/Rosendahl Resolution on Southern California Edison's damaged San Onofre nuclear power plant. Paul Koretz; Jose Huizar; Bill Rosendahl; Ed Reyes; Dennis Zine
R E S O L U T I O N
WHEREAS, any official position of the City of Los Angeles with respect to legislation, rules, regulations or policies proposed to or pending before a local, state or federal governmental body or agency must have first been adopted in the form of a Resolution by the City Council with the concurrence of the Mayor; and
WHEREAS, Southern California Edison's (Edison) four replacement steam generators manufactured by Mitsubishi for the two nuclear reactors at San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant (San Onofre) were shut down after one of the tubes released radiation in January 2012; and
WHEREAS, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) determined that the crippled steam generators present a serious safety risk; and
WHEREAS, Edison recently submitted a plan to the NRC to restart San Onofre Unit 2 at 70% power for 150 days as an interim compensatory action while the utility considers a long-term plan for repairing the steam generators; and
WHEREAS, in 2011, the NRC recommended a fifty mile evacuation zone
WHEREAS, portions of Los Angeles are within fifty miles of San Onofre and therefore within the danger zone of any radiation leak or worse disaster; and
WHEREAS, it is vitally important to ensure the health and well-being of the general public, the power plant workers, the potentially-affected residents of Los Angeles, and the environment; and
WHEREAS, federal regulations provide that a formal license amendment with an adjudicatory hearing is the appropriate and transparent process by which the NRC can evaluate the safety of the major design changes made at San Onofre, as this process ensures public participation in a formal evidentiary, regulatory process; and
WHEREAS, any other process than a license amendment with an evidentiary hearing is insufficient for public safety; in fact, NRC allowed an alternative, less transparent, more perfunctory review process during the application of the very steam generators which FAILED at San Onofre, and the problems with these generators may well have been discovered through the more appropriate, thorough license amendment process; and
WHEREAS, environmental and community groups, as well as other cities in the region, including Santa Monica, Del Mar and Laguna Beach, are concerned that Edison appears to be trying to circumvent the formal amendment license process and are calling on the NRC to require that Edison seek San Onofre restart approval ONLY through that formal license amendment process;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, with the concurrence of the Mayor, that by the adoption of this Resolution, the City of Los Angeles hereby includes in its 2011-2012 Federal Legislative Program SUPPORT for action by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to make no decision about restarting either San Onofre Unit until Edison has completed a thorough, public, transparent license amendment with an adjudicatory hearing on whether it is safe to restart either reactor and a determination of what repairs, replacements, or other actions by Edison are necessary to guarantee both short- and long-term public safety.
video-2012-12-16-14-52-05.mp4





![Utility Companies Must Pay For Nuke Plant Mistakes
San Diego Sierra Club *Run With the Sun* organizer Pete Hasapopoulos warns the California Public Utilities Commission that San Diego Gas and Electric is viewing the closure of the San Onofre nuclear plant as an invitation to an All You Can Eat Fossil Fuels Buffet.
October 1, 2013
California Public Utilities Commission Hearing
San Diego, California
Much of the testimony in the video is based on the following talking points provided by the Angeles Chapter of the Sierra Club [www.angeles2.sierraclub.org]:
In November 2012 the PUC approved a 5.04 percent rate increase by Southern California Edison on its customers. Yet the PUC was silent on the ratepayer surcharge of more than $50 million per month to keep San Onofre in standby condition. The surcharge is now in its 20th month.
Questions:
Do you intend to allow the subsidy to continue indefinitely even though the plant is now closed?
We ask for an immediate end to the subsidy.
When do you intend to make public your analysis regarding the level of subsidy that has been fair and reasonable since January 31, 2012, and to consider rebates if appropriate?
Ratepayers deserve a full accounting of the subsidy paid to Edison.
Large as these issues are, they are dwarfed by the need for responsible management of the decommissioning fund. Edison has pegged the total cost of decommissioning in the $4 billion-plus range while fund collections to-date, including those by Edison, SDG&E and the City of Riverside, total $3.6 billion.
There are two grave risks. First, the moneys currently on hand could be spent ineffectively and fail to achieve crucial cleanup objectives. Next, Edison may view the decommissioning fund as a potential revenue stream. Some of this funding might be used to grow the company rather than address waste management and site remediation needs.
Question:
What monitoring and accountability mechanisms does the PUC intend to create to assure the prudent and effective use of money in the decommissioning fund, in order to prevent unjustified surcharges on ratepayers and/or shortfalls in meeting cleanup objectives?
We call for effective oversight by the PUC to assure the appropriate use of money in the decommissioning fund.
The time has come for a full understanding of the intentions and approaches that will be used by the California Public Utilities Commission in handling these large public interest concerns.
[end talking points]
Further verbal testimony:
We would echo our friends at The Utility Reform Network [www.turn.org] as far as SDG&E is concerned:
Utility Companies Must Pay for their Mistakes out of Profits Not Rates.
Customers should not pay a single penny for costs incurred by SDG&E to own an expensive, inoperable nuclear plant.
And what SDG&E customers should understand is that since the announcement on the permanent closure of the San Onofre nuclear plant SDG&E has decided that thats served up an all the fossil fuels you can eat buffet.
They have come back to the PUC asking for the Pio Pico natural gas plant - 1.6 Billion Dollars for ratepayers - they want to build gas plants on Camp Pendleton now - So they add insult to injury - but what they want to extract from us in rates from the San Onofre nuclear plant they want to use it to come at us natural gas power plants that we do not need and throw it on our backs.
Pete Hasapopoulos
Organizer
Run with the Sun Program
Sierra Club San Diego Chapter
12,000 Members in San Diego & Imperial Counties
www.runwithsun.org
www.facebook.com/RunWithTheSun
www.sandiego.sierraclub.org
I created this video with the YouTube Video Editor (http://www.youtube.com/editor) Utility Companies Must Pay For Nuke Plant Mistakes](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/au6QQJgt75Q/mqdefault.jpg)




