Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
What would it take to pry Kyle Shanahan out of San Francisco? Troy Aikman says his first call as a front-office exec would be to the 49ers asking exactly that. So we took the bait. Using the 2002 Jon Gruden trade as the model (two firsts, two seconds, and cash), we asked a simple question: if the Niners got that offer for Shanahan today, would they take it?
Willard and Dibs don’t agree at all. One side says the phone gets hung up before the offer is even finished. You don’t trade the best coach in football for draft picks, which are a gamble anyway, and nobody would take 100 first-rounders. The other side says you at least listen: Shanahan’s coaching tree is everywhere, there are young offensive minds copying his system, and a pile of picks can turn into a whole roster.
From there it turns into a bigger debate. Are coaches like Ben Johnson and Liam Coen proof that Shanahan’s offense can be copied? Why do Troy Aikman and Joe Thomas rate him so highly? And should Super Bowl rings really be how we judge a head coach, especially when Sean McVay has one and has had a rough year?
Topics discussed include:
Troy Aikman saying he’d go after Kyle Shanahan first
The Jon Gruden trade as a blueprint for a Shanahan deal
Hanging up the phone or listening to the offer
The Shanahan coaching tree: Kubiak, Seattle, Las Vegas
Draft picks vs. an elite head coach (and the Herschel Walker trade)
Christian McCaffrey and whether running backs are replaceable
Ben Johnson, Liam Coen and the young offensive “copycats”
Whether a Super Bowl ring should define a coach’s career
Would you trade Kyle Shanahan for two firsts, two seconds and $15 million, or would you hang up the phone? Let us know in the comments.
0:00 – Would You Trade Kyle Shanahan?
0:59 – Troy Aikman’s First Call Would Be for Shanahan
2:58 – The Jon Gruden Trade Blueprint
4:17 – Hang Up the Phone or Take the Call?
10:52 – Super Bowl Rings, McVay and Judging Coaches
Download the Audacy app to never miss any of your favorite 957 The Game content:
go.audacy.com/y-listen-live-957thegame
Listen live: audacy.com/957thegame/listen
Visit our website: 957thegame.com
Subscribe on Twitch: twitch.tv/957thegame
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/957thegame
Like us on Facebook: facebook.com/957thegame
Follow us on Instagram: instagram.com/957thegame
Join our Newsletter: audacy.com/957thegame/join-our-clubs/mvp-club
What would it take to pry Kyle Shanahan out of San Francisco? Troy Aikman says his first call as a front-office exec would be to the 49ers asking exactly that. So we took the bait. Using the 2002 Jon Gruden trade as the model (two firsts, two seconds, and cash), we asked a simple question: if the Niners got that offer for Shanahan today, would they take it?
Willard and Dibs don’t agree at all. One side says the phone gets hung up before the offer is even finished. You don’t trade the best coach in football for draft picks, which are a gamble anyway, and nobody would take 100 first-rounders. The other side says you at least listen: Shanahan’s coaching tree is everywhere, there are young offensive minds copying his system, and a pile of picks can turn into a whole roster.
From there it turns into a bigger debate. Are coaches like Ben Johnson and Liam Coen proof that Shanahan’s offense can be copied? Why do Troy Aikman and Joe Thomas rate him so highly? And should Super Bowl rings really be how we judge a head coach, especially when Sean McVay has one and has had a rough year?
Topics discussed include:
Troy Aikman saying he’d go after Kyle Shanahan first
The Jon Gruden trade as a blueprint for a Shanahan deal
Hanging up the phone or listening to the offer
The Shanahan coaching tree: Kubiak, Seattle, Las Vegas
Draft picks vs. an elite head coach (and the Herschel Walker trade)
Christian McCaffrey and whether running backs are replaceable
Ben Johnson, Liam Coen and the young offensive “copycats”
Whether a Super Bowl ring should define a coach’s career
Would you trade Kyle Shanahan for two firsts, two seconds and $15 million, or would you hang up the phone? Let us know in the comments.
0:00 – Would You Trade Kyle Shanahan?
0:59 – Troy Aikman’s First Call Would Be for Shanahan
2:58 – The Jon Gruden Trade Blueprint
4:17 – Hang Up the Phone or Take the Call?
10:52 – Super Bowl Rings, McVay and Judging Coaches
Download the Audacy app to never miss any of your favorite 957 The Game content:
go.audacy.com/y-listen-live-957thegame
Listen live: audacy.com/957thegame/listen
Visit our website: 957thegame.com
Subscribe on Twitch: twitch.tv/957thegame
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/957thegame
Like us on Facebook: facebook.com/957thegame
Follow us on Instagram: instagram.com/957thegame
Join our Newsletter: audacy.com/957thegame/join-our-clubs/mvp-club










