Uploaded May 2018 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
Urna Fatale was originally written one half step higher than it is performed today and since the end of the 19th century all baritones sang it a half step lower. Even Warren, Ruffo, Tibbett and McNeil sang it down a half step. To my knowledge, only Leo Nucci and myself have sung the aria and cabaletta in the original high key. It was simply too high for most baritones. The original key puts more intensity into the character. This is the original high key from one of my many performances of it. josephshore.com/where_have_all_the_great_singers1.htm
Urna Fatale was originally written one half step higher than it is performed today and since the end of the 19th century all baritones sang it a half step lower. Even Warren, Ruffo, Tibbett and McNeil sang it down a half step. To my knowledge, only Leo Nucci and myself have sung the aria and cabaletta in the original high key. It was simply too high for most baritones. The original key puts more intensity into the character. This is the original high key from one of my many performances of it. josephshore.com/where_have_all_the_great_singers1.htm










