Uploaded May 2018 | Updated November 2026, 10 hours ago
1. Gratias Agimus tibi (Puccini, Messa di Gloria) 2. Nessun Dorma 3.Pieta Signore (Fetis). 4. Ingemisco (Verdi, Requiem) All of these were recorded when I was 60 to 68 years old after four heart surgeries.
I present these tenor arias which are mostly on sacred subjects, in honor of Jerome Hines and Cesare Bardelli, my two great influences in my singing style and career. I was not a tenor but a Verdi Baritone with an extension of my full head voice ("la voce piena in testa") which allowed me to sing tenor arias. This is not a type of singing to be found many places today. Singers of today do not use the principles of historic singing for the most part. Jerome Hines told me: "Let me put it this way. We are facing a generation of young singers who are much more diminutive in their approach to singing. I will sing King Mark with a Tristan who I feel should be doing Almaviva!"
During my interview with him, he also commented:
"Shore: Jerry, a few years ago a major regional opera company did DON CARLO and hired you to do the Grand Inquisitor. A young international bass of the current generation, who I will simply call Mr. X, was the Philip. The Chorus Master is a friend of mine and he relayed this account of the show. He said, 'We all thought Mr. X was sounding just fine as Philip until out walked Jerome Hines as the Grand Inquisitor, and he made Mr. X sound like a teenager. WE HAD ALL FORGOTTEN WHAT A REAL BASS SOUNDS LIKE.'
Hines: I have a tape of that performance and Mr. X sounds like my little boy!
(Shore: While Jerry was alive I never revealed who "Mr. X" was but now that Jerry is gone I don't mind revealing that Mr. X was Sam Ramey and the opera company was Tulsa where Ramey was singing Philip and Hines was the Inquisitor.)
Shore: Can you describe the differences in the way singers sounded when you were coming into the business 50 years ago and how they sound now?
Hines: Yes, when I came to the Met, Robert Merrill and Leonard Warren sounded more like basses than most of the basses you hear today. Take Lawrence Tibbett. He had a big, world-class sound. It was a richer, heavier sound by far than what you hear from baritones today.
Shore: You know that some people want me to sing bass roles today, even though you and I both know I'm a baritone.
Hines: Of course. You're absolutely right. You sound the way a real baritone is supposed to sound."
This decline in vocal resonance and power in singers was known and analyzed by experts way back in 1980. Critic Peter Davis wrote a huge article in the New York Times describing the situation:
"Where are the new Carusos and Ponselles? Is it simply that extraordinary vocal power is a rarity of nature, and that a Caruso comes to us only once in a century? No, say numerous impresarios, managers, voice teachers, coaches and administrators of organizations that assist budding musical talent. Potentially great voices are reasonably common, they say, but conditions in the music world today are not conducive to their recognition and development. Indeed, in the view of one vocal authority, if a young Caruso suddenly appeared on the first rung of the professional ladder, unformed and unrefined, bursting with raw talent, he would not receive the sort of care or encouragement that would allow him to realize his full vocal or artistic capacities" ("Where Are the Great Opera Singers of Tomorrow," The New York Times, April 20, 1980)
1. Gratias Agimus tibi (Puccini, Messa di Gloria) 2. Nessun Dorma 3.Pieta Signore (Fetis). 4. Ingemisco (Verdi, Requiem) All of these were recorded when I was 60 to 68 years old after four heart surgeries.
I present these tenor arias which are mostly on sacred subjects, in honor of Jerome Hines and Cesare Bardelli, my two great influences in my singing style and career. I was not a tenor but a Verdi Baritone with an extension of my full head voice ("la voce piena in testa") which allowed me to sing tenor arias. This is not a type of singing to be found many places today. Singers of today do not use the principles of historic singing for the most part. Jerome Hines told me: "Let me put it this way. We are facing a generation of young singers who are much more diminutive in their approach to singing. I will sing King Mark with a Tristan who I feel should be doing Almaviva!"
During my interview with him, he also commented:
"Shore: Jerry, a few years ago a major regional opera company did DON CARLO and hired you to do the Grand Inquisitor. A young international bass of the current generation, who I will simply call Mr. X, was the Philip. The Chorus Master is a friend of mine and he relayed this account of the show. He said, 'We all thought Mr. X was sounding just fine as Philip until out walked Jerome Hines as the Grand Inquisitor, and he made Mr. X sound like a teenager. WE HAD ALL FORGOTTEN WHAT A REAL BASS SOUNDS LIKE.'
Hines: I have a tape of that performance and Mr. X sounds like my little boy!
(Shore: While Jerry was alive I never revealed who "Mr. X" was but now that Jerry is gone I don't mind revealing that Mr. X was Sam Ramey and the opera company was Tulsa where Ramey was singing Philip and Hines was the Inquisitor.)
Shore: Can you describe the differences in the way singers sounded when you were coming into the business 50 years ago and how they sound now?
Hines: Yes, when I came to the Met, Robert Merrill and Leonard Warren sounded more like basses than most of the basses you hear today. Take Lawrence Tibbett. He had a big, world-class sound. It was a richer, heavier sound by far than what you hear from baritones today.
Shore: You know that some people want me to sing bass roles today, even though you and I both know I'm a baritone.
Hines: Of course. You're absolutely right. You sound the way a real baritone is supposed to sound."
This decline in vocal resonance and power in singers was known and analyzed by experts way back in 1980. Critic Peter Davis wrote a huge article in the New York Times describing the situation:
"Where are the new Carusos and Ponselles? Is it simply that extraordinary vocal power is a rarity of nature, and that a Caruso comes to us only once in a century? No, say numerous impresarios, managers, voice teachers, coaches and administrators of organizations that assist budding musical talent. Potentially great voices are reasonably common, they say, but conditions in the music world today are not conducive to their recognition and development. Indeed, in the view of one vocal authority, if a young Caruso suddenly appeared on the first rung of the professional ladder, unformed and unrefined, bursting with raw talent, he would not receive the sort of care or encouragement that would allow him to realize his full vocal or artistic capacities" ("Where Are the Great Opera Singers of Tomorrow," The New York Times, April 20, 1980)



![Joseph Shore -La Forza del destino-Urna Fatale to end of scene
This was taped from the audience. Imagine what it would have sounded like recorded by RCA with a big Neumann microphone and professional editing. This is the original high key which only Leo Nucci and I sang it in, to my knowledge. The ending is a high G sharp. Warren changed the words at the end to Giuro dal ciel, making the [o] vowel the vowel for the high G sharp. Sometimes I did that but not on this time. The sweeping phrases used here, plus the dynamic contrast within each phrase show pp to FF without effort of force. I feel that my interpretation here can stand up against any of my Verdi baritone colleagues singing during my generation. Of course we all know that Warren was the best!! For this concert which I gave in 1990 at The University of North Carolina, a man came backstage at the end to congratulate me on my singing. I recognized him as a powerful man in opera who I had sung for early in my career. He made a snap judgment against me and let me go without hiring or encouragement. He said to me, You really sing Verdi like nobody else today. Why dont you come back to New York with me and take another shot at being accepted by the system. Thats a nice idea but a little late. I already have a multiple year contract to teach at this university. He hung his head a little sheepishly and said, Im sorry...great singing.
This was taped from the audience. Imagine what it would have sounded like recorded by RCA with a big Neumann microphone and professional editing.
This is the original high key which only Leo Nucci and I sang it in, to my knowledge. The ending is a high G sharp. Warren changed the words at the end to Giuro dal ciel, making the [o] vowel the vowel for the high G sharp. Sometimes I did that but not on this time. I feel that my interpretation here can stand up against any of my Verdi baritone colleagues singing during my generation. Of course we all know that Warren was the best!!
For this concert which I gave in 1990 at The University of North Carolina, a man came backstage at the end to congratulate me on my singing. I recognized him as a powerful man in opera whi I had sung for early in my career. He made a snap judgment against me and let me go without hiring or encouragement. He said to me, You really sing Verdi like nobody else today. Why dont you come back to New York with me and take another shot at being accepted by the system.
Thats a nice idea but a little late. I already have a multiple year contract to teach at this university. He hung his head a little sheepishly and said, Im sorry...great singing. Joseph Shore -La Forza del destino-Urna Fatale to end of scene](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/zF81t5A3O9M/mqdefault.jpg)

