Uploaded March 2021 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Experimental Linguopoetics Arises: Phonaesthetics vs. Phonaesthemics — Could have been Tolkien wrong?
Linguopoetics, or a branch of linguistics dealing with creating languages (linguopoiesis), is a potentially rich field for experimental linguistic research. In our work, we have chosen and tested a hypothetical concept of phonaesthetics, originated outside of linguopoiesis, but introduced to it by John R. R. Tolkien, linguist and linguopoet himself. Phonaesthetics hypothesises that there is a universal causal relationship between the sound and meaning, i.e., the meaning of a word is determined by its sound, and vice versa. This represents so called strong formulation. Later, the weak formulation was introduced that it applies only to pairs of opposite / mutually extreme meanings. Another hypothesis to the relation between sound and meaning, the phonaesthemic hypothesis by John R. Firth, postulates ex-post mental association of a certain sound or group of sounds (a phonaestheme) with a certain meaning.
We have undertaken a study probing both these hypotheses by means of asking respondents to assign different meanings to one of the pair of phonetic sequences (and other way around) in different arrangements to test as many potential consequences of these hypotheses as possible. We have applied phonetic sequence & meaning pairs from natural languages, created languages and randomly generated and attributed sequences.
Our results suggest that although in the limited number of cases the respondents’ preference of a certain phonetic sequence to meaning is non-random (potentially a phonaesthemic phenomenon), in most cases, regardless of the origin, no causal relation between the two could be found, ruling thus the phonaesthetic hypothesis out.
Jan Havliš was born 1970 in Brno, Czechoslovakia, and nowadays lives with his wife, two cats, and more than 3500 books in a small house in Nebovidy, Czech Republic. He is a reader (senior lecturer) in bioanalytics and proteomics at Masaryk University in Brno. He was unknowingly conlanging since 7, and seriously conlanging from 1995, when he joined his friend Radek Zahradnik and they co-operated on development of Arkian, their first collaborating conlang. In 2010 – 2013 he made his BSc in general linguistics, since 2014 he teaches language construction & interlinguistics for Faculty of Art at Masaryk University. Since 2017 he started his PhD in general linguistics at Faculty of Art of the same uni with topic language creativity.
Experimental Linguopoetics Arises: Phonaesthetics vs. Phonaesthemics — Could have been Tolkien wrong?
Linguopoetics, or a branch of linguistics dealing with creating languages (linguopoiesis), is a potentially rich field for experimental linguistic research. In our work, we have chosen and tested a hypothetical concept of phonaesthetics, originated outside of linguopoiesis, but introduced to it by John R. R. Tolkien, linguist and linguopoet himself. Phonaesthetics hypothesises that there is a universal causal relationship between the sound and meaning, i.e., the meaning of a word is determined by its sound, and vice versa. This represents so called strong formulation. Later, the weak formulation was introduced that it applies only to pairs of opposite / mutually extreme meanings. Another hypothesis to the relation between sound and meaning, the phonaesthemic hypothesis by John R. Firth, postulates ex-post mental association of a certain sound or group of sounds (a phonaestheme) with a certain meaning.
We have undertaken a study probing both these hypotheses by means of asking respondents to assign different meanings to one of the pair of phonetic sequences (and other way around) in different arrangements to test as many potential consequences of these hypotheses as possible. We have applied phonetic sequence & meaning pairs from natural languages, created languages and randomly generated and attributed sequences.
Our results suggest that although in the limited number of cases the respondents’ preference of a certain phonetic sequence to meaning is non-random (potentially a phonaesthemic phenomenon), in most cases, regardless of the origin, no causal relation between the two could be found, ruling thus the phonaesthetic hypothesis out.
Jan Havliš was born 1970 in Brno, Czechoslovakia, and nowadays lives with his wife, two cats, and more than 3500 books in a small house in Nebovidy, Czech Republic. He is a reader (senior lecturer) in bioanalytics and proteomics at Masaryk University in Brno. He was unknowingly conlanging since 7, and seriously conlanging from 1995, when he joined his friend Radek Zahradnik and they co-operated on development of Arkian, their first collaborating conlang. In 2010 – 2013 he made his BSc in general linguistics, since 2014 he teaches language construction & interlinguistics for Faculty of Art at Masaryk University. Since 2017 he started his PhD in general linguistics at Faculty of Art of the same uni with topic language creativity.






![#lcc10 Douglas (Doug) L. Ball - The story of /ts/ and its relation to Skerre
#lcc10 Douglas (Doug) L. Ball - The story of /ts/ and its relation to Skerre
details & slides: https://conlang.org/lcc10/#ball
speaker: Twitter @tsketar, http://skerre.conlang.org, Fiat Lingua papers https://fiatlingua.org/tag/doug-ball/
In May of 2020, after the end of the most pandemic-affected semester (Spring 2020), I did not have anywhere to go or much to do. So I did what any quarantining conlanger-linguist would do: began a project, just using internet resources, to look at the phonological behavior of the affricate [ts].
This was a sound I had, at one time reluctantly, adopted into my principle conlang, Skerre. In the years since, I had never investigated how it might behave.
(Plus, its behavior did not seem to have ever been explicitly addressed head-on before; though, once I got digging, I found more than I thought I would. I ended up being influenced by studies of sibilant fricatives by Padgett & Żygis (2003) and Boersma & Hamann (2006) as well as the typologically-oriented study by Nikolaev & Grossman (2018).)
This talk reports some of the results from that investigation. I will focus mainly on the apparent 4 kinds of sibilant affricate inventories one finds in natural languages (partially disregarding laryngeal properties like voicing and aspiration), 3 of which include /ts/.
I’ll focus on patterns of contrasts, worldwide distribution (to the extent I could determine), and (apparent) implicational relationships between /ts/ and other stops, affricates, and fricatives. I will also discuss how my findings contributed to how I viewed /ts/ within the phonemic inventory of Skerre.
References
Bauer, Robert S. & Paul K. Benedict. 1997. Modern Cantonese phonology. Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter. ISBN 9783110823707, OCLC 979603712. Available at WorldCat.
Berns, Janine K.M. 2013. Friction between phonetics and phonology: The status of affricates. Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen dissertation. https://repository.ubn.ru.nl/bitstream/handle/2066/119022/119022.pdf
Boersma, Paul & Silke Hamann. 2006. Sibilant inventories in bidirectional phonology and phonetics. Handout from presentation at OCP (Old World Conference in Phonology) 3, January 17 2006. https://www.fon.hum.uva.nl/paul/presentations/BoersmaHamannHandout.pdf
Boersma, Paul & Silke Hamann. 2008. The evolution of auditory dispersion in bidirectional constraint grammars. Phonology 25(2). 217–270. https://www.fon.hum.uva.nl/paul/papers/BoersmaHamannPhonology2008.pdf
Kokkelmans, Joachim. 2021. The phonetics and phonology of sibilants: University of Verona dissertation. http://roa.rutgers.edu/content/article/files/1864_kokkelmans_1.pdf
Maddieson, Ian. 1984. Patterns of sounds. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-11326-7, OCLC 10724704. Available at WorldCat.
Maddieson, Ian, Sébastien Flavier, Egidio Marsico & François Pellegrino. 2014-2023. LAPSyD: Lyon-Albuquerque Phonological Systems Databases. https://lapsyd.huma-num.fr/lapsyd/
Michael, Lev, Tammy Stark, Emily Clem & Will Chang. 2015. South American Phonological Inventory Database v2.1.0. Berkeley: University of California. Survey of California and Other Indian Languages Digital Resource. https://linguistics.berkeley.edu/saphon/
Moran, Steven & Daniel McCloy (eds.). 2019. PHOIBLE 2.0. Jena: Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History. doi:10.5281/zenodo.2677911. https://phoible.org
Nikolaev, Dmitry & Eitan Grossman. 2018. Areal sound change and the distributional typology of affricate richness in Eurasia. Studies in Language 42(3). 562–599. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328383833_Areal_sound_change_and_the_distributional_typology_of_affricate_richness_in_Eurasia
Padgett, Jaye & Marzena Zygis. 2003. The evolution of sibilants in Polish and Russian. ZAS Papers in Linguistics 32, 155–174. https://zaspil.leibniz-zas.de/article/view/190
Padgett, Jaye & Marzena Żygis. 2007. The evolution of sibilants in Polish and Russian. Journal of Slavic Linguistics 15(2). 291–324. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Marzena-Zygis/publication/259814012_The_evolution_of_sibilants_in_Polish_and_Russian/links/0c96053811e0aee1b8000000/The-evolution-of-sibilants-in-Polish-and-Russian.pdf
Polian, Gilles. 2017. Tseltal and Tsotsil. In Judith Aissen, Nora C. England & Roberto Zavala Maldonado (eds.), The Mayan languages, 610–647. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-367-86913-7, OCLC 1348520591. Available at WorldCat.
Stone, Gerald. 2009. Polish. In Bernard Comrie (ed.), The World’s major languages, 289–304. Routledge 2nd edn. ISBN 978-0-415-60902-9, OCLC 1001961525. Available at WorldCat.
—
Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLOSXnL88bvWv5AAOWy43J7Jy-Sh7gSF5B
Join the LCS: https://conlang.org/become-a-member/
Captions by @stenoknight. #lcc10 Douglas (Doug) L. Ball - The story of /ts/ and its relation to Skerre](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/GjsudatqHH4/mqdefault.jpg)



