Uploaded December 2025 | Updated September 2026, 9 hours ago
What makes the holidays in New York feel bigger than the season itself? In this special holiday special of the City Journal podcast, Daniel Di Martino, Josh Appel, and Rafael Mangual reflect on the magic, meaning, and contradictions of the holiday season in the city—sharing personal traditions, favorite seasonal rituals, and the foods, films, and memories that define the holidays. From classic New York culinary staples to the enduring lessons of It’s a Wonderful Life, the conversation explores how stories and traditions shape our understanding of generosity, family, and community. Along the way, the hosts grapple with deeper questions about individualism versus social obligation, the responsibilities of wealth, and even the perennial debate over believing in Santa Claus. Warm, thoughtful, and unmistakably New York, this episode captures why the holidays continue to matter—both personally and culturally.
Get the best of City Journal, delivered weekly:
city-journal.org/email-alerts
Daniel Di Martino: https://x.com/DanielDiMartino
Josh Appel: https://x.com/joshjappel
Rafael Mangual: https://x.com/Rafa_Mangual
00:00 Holiday Shopping and Store Experiences
02:28 Christmas in New York: A Magical Experience
04:10 Personal Holiday Traditions and Memories
07:08 Culinary Traditions: Food and Family
09:30 Celebrating Hanukkah
11:18 Family Gatherings and Holiday Entertainment
14:26 Classic Christmas Movies and Their Messages
19:39 The Balance of Individualism and Community
22:25 The Burden of Responsibility
24:14 Capitalism and Generosity
26:01 Wealth and Philanthropy
28:07 Christmas Movies and Nostalgia
30:43 The Evolution of New York City
34:24 The Santa Claus Debate
39:03 Rediscovering Childhood Wonder
What makes the holidays in New York feel bigger than the season itself? In this special holiday special of the City Journal podcast, Daniel Di Martino, Josh Appel, and Rafael Mangual reflect on the magic, meaning, and contradictions of the holiday season in the city—sharing personal traditions, favorite seasonal rituals, and the foods, films, and memories that define the holidays. From classic New York culinary staples to the enduring lessons of It’s a Wonderful Life, the conversation explores how stories and traditions shape our understanding of generosity, family, and community. Along the way, the hosts grapple with deeper questions about individualism versus social obligation, the responsibilities of wealth, and even the perennial debate over believing in Santa Claus. Warm, thoughtful, and unmistakably New York, this episode captures why the holidays continue to matter—both personally and culturally.
Get the best of City Journal, delivered weekly:
city-journal.org/email-alerts
Daniel Di Martino: https://x.com/DanielDiMartino
Josh Appel: https://x.com/joshjappel
Rafael Mangual: https://x.com/Rafa_Mangual
00:00 Holiday Shopping and Store Experiences
02:28 Christmas in New York: A Magical Experience
04:10 Personal Holiday Traditions and Memories
07:08 Culinary Traditions: Food and Family
09:30 Celebrating Hanukkah
11:18 Family Gatherings and Holiday Entertainment
14:26 Classic Christmas Movies and Their Messages
19:39 The Balance of Individualism and Community
22:25 The Burden of Responsibility
24:14 Capitalism and Generosity
26:01 Wealth and Philanthropy
28:07 Christmas Movies and Nostalgia
30:43 The Evolution of New York City
34:24 The Santa Claus Debate
39:03 Rediscovering Childhood Wonder
