Is the Old Mine Cushion the Hardest Diamond Cut to Work With? @ByBonnieJewelry
Is the Old Mine Cushion the Hardest Diamond Cut to Work With?  @ByBonnieJewelry
Uploaded October 2026 | Updated November 2026, 1 day ago
She wanted an elongated stone… but the journey led us to an old mine cushion. 💎

Old mine cushions have a character all their own, and choosing one takes more than looking at a certificate. The shape, facet pattern, proportions, and overall personality of the diamond matter. This is where your jeweler’s experience makes all the difference. If someone shows you only a certificate and nothing more, ask more questions. You deserve to understand exactly what makes your diamond special.

In this story time, I’m taking you through my client’s journey: the styles she considered, why she ultimately chose this old mine cushion, and how we approached pairing it with a wedding band.

Because finding the right diamond isn't just about checking boxes. It's about knowing what to look for and trusting the person guiding you through the process.
Now tell me: are you an old mine cushion lover, or is there another diamond cut that has your heart? 👇


Find the featured styles on our website:

Cushion Diamond Old Mine with Half Moon Diamond 3 Stone Platinum Engagement Ring-Style 115803 bybonniejewelry.com/products/cushion-diamond-old-mine-with-half-moon-diamond-3-stone-platinum-engagement-ring?_pos=1&_sid=1707f78d9&_ss=r
Round Diamond 3 Stone Basket Platinum Engagement Ring-Style 1579 bybonniejewelry.com/products/round-diamond-3-stone-basket-platinum-engagement-ring?_pos=2&_psq=round+3+stone+engageme&_psid=9ff2db095&_ss=e&variant=44107098128579
Cushion Diamond Old Mine Hidden Halo Tapered Cathedral Solitaire Yellow Gold Engagement Ring-Style 3292 bybonniejewelry.com/products/cushion-diamond-hidden-halo-tapered-cathedral-solitaire-yellow-gold-engagement-ring?_pos=2&_sid=ba413b188&_ss=r
4ct Pear Shape Diamond with Trapezoid Yellow Gold 3 Stone Ring-Style 3135 bybonniejewelry.com/products/4ct-pear-shape-diamond-with-trapezoid-yellow-gold-3-stone-ring?_pos=1&_psq=3135&_psid=26fd82b98&_ss=e
Emerald Diamond Tapered Cathedral Solitaire Yellow Gold Engagement Ring-Style 2719 bybonniejewelry.com/products/emerald-diamond-tapered-cathedral-solitaire-yellow-gold-engagement-ring?_pos=2&_sid=de0e1092a&_ss=r
1.25ct Emerald Cut Diamond Chloe Yellow Gold 3.50mm Wedding Band-Style 2030A bybonniejewelry.com/products/1-25ct-emerald-diamond-chloe-yellow-gold-eternity-band?_pos=1&_sid=ddd30c0f8&_ss=r
Oval Diamond Tulip French Pave Platinum Engagement Ring-Style 1757 bybonniejewelry.com/products/oval-diamond-tulip-french-pave-platinum-engagement-ring?_pos=1&_sid=03088194f&_ss=r
1.75ct Emerald Diamond East West Petite Platinum Eternity Band-Style 2247 bybonniejewelry.com/products/emerald-diamond-east-west-petite-platinum-eternity-band?_pos=1&_sid=6e6a21c99&_ss=r
Cushion Diamond Old Mine The Eloise Trellis with Hidden Halo Platinum Engagement Ring- Style 3049 bybonniejewelry.com/products/cushion-diamond-old-mine-the-eloise-trellis-with-hidden-halo-platinum-engagement-ring?_pos=1&_sid=d7727e309&_ss=r
Cushion Diamond Old Mine Knife Edge Hidden Halo Platinum Engagement Ring- Style 2694 bybonniejewelry.com/products/cushion-diamond-old-mine-knife-edge-hidden-halo-platinum-engagement-ring?_pos=1&_sid=af40cc84f&_ss=r


Timestamps
0:00 Old Mine Cut Cushion Engagement Ring: Why It’s So Hard to Make
0:20 By Bonnie Jewelry: Custom Diamond Jewelry & Craftsmanship
0:35 5 Things to Check Before Buying an Old Mine Cut Diamond
1:00 Biggest Mistake When Shopping for an Old Mine Cut Cushion
1:20 Custom Pear Shape vs. Old Mine Cut Engagement Ring
1:45 Ring Proportions: Wrong Stone Size & Too Much Metal
2:10 Low Profile Engagement Ring for Everyday Wear
2:25 Why You Can’t Order a Custom Engagement Ring Off the Shelf
2:45 Finished Old Mine Cut Ring: Soft Corners & Seamless Prongs
3:05 Old Mine Cut Settings: Hidden Halo, Gold Solitaire & Platinum Knife Edge
3:35 Face-Up Look vs. Certificate & Carat Weight
3:55 Old Mine Cut Eternity Band Idea

Linked Videos
0:53 youtu.be/Mi-Q549Wx-A?si=MYwrm6UMBLJdUdQT
1:12 youtu.be/zCqyoCpzkBU?si=FeQKOI0y6b_00OlH

Make sure to:
👍Like the video
🗨️Comment your proposal questions below
👥Share this with a friend currently stressing over his proposal
👆Subscribe for more jewelry, engagement ring, and proposal content

► OVERVIEW ❤ About my size for reference: I am 5'3, 110 Pounds, Finger size 5.5 ❖
San Francisco Bay Area, California
We have clients in many states across the country, as well as worldwide!

► Read All 5 Star Reviews ✮✮✮✮✮
https://www.yelp.com/biz/by-bonnie-je...

► OTHER VIDEOS TO WATCH
Finding the Right Wedding Band For Your 3 Stone Ring
youtu.be/zCqyoCpzkBU?si=R-e5Pa2ykJna2j3f


Round vs Cushion vs Emerald vs Oval: Which Three Stone Engagement Ring Is Right for You?
youtu.be/A2vsC_tYLb8?si=ioh6b6b-CqJ9b8Dt
Is the Old Mine Cushion the Hardest Diamond Cut to Work With?6.20ct Oval Diamond Hidden Halo SolitaireThe 2ct Round Engagement Ring Everyone WantsWe love having all of your beautiful faces in the showroomGuess the carat size of this Emerald cut SolitaireNot All Pink Diamonds Are The Same✨A beautiful engagement ring is about more than just the center diamond. 💍Can you mix lab diamonds with natural diamonds?Why Does Your Engagement Ring Keep Spinning?Should an Engagement Ring Be a Surprise?Yellow Gold Engagement Ring InspirationI Wanted a Pink Diamond Bracelet… So I Made One
By Bonnie Jewelry |

Is the Old Mine Cushion the Hardest Diamond Cut to Work With?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER