Is Science Under Siege? @NAScholars
Is Science Under Siege?  @NAScholars
Uploaded March 2025 | Updated November 2026, 1 hour ago
Recent proposals by the National Institutes of Health to reduce overhead costs on grants to university scientists has generated a furious storm of controversy and overheated rhetoric. "Science is under siege!" is the claim. But is it true?
On 28 February 2025, Cornell University's Department of Science and Technology Studies hosted a round table discussion on the topic: Science Under Siege." Scott Turner, Director of Science Programs at the National Association of Scholars went there to document what the round table had to say. This video is the complete event.
What do you think? Does it make the case that science is, in fact, "under siege"? Please post your opinion in the comments section. Maybe we can get a good debate going!
Just to kick things off, here are some prompts, and my opinion.
1. Is it science that's under siege, or the science revenue stream? The two aren't equivalent. The participants in the round table were either high level administrators or "studies" scholars. When it's indirect costs that are being proposed for cuts, it's those livelihoods that are at stake. To what extent do they contribute to the enterprise of science? Funding for working scientists would actually increase under the proposed indirect costs cuts.
2. One speaker claimed that the NIH cannot unilaterally set limits on indirect costs. Why not? To what extent can Cornell claim to be a partner when the bulk of its science funding comes from government?
3. Should science serve political ends, or should it be an apolitical search for new knowledge about the natural world? If the bulk of your funding comes from an inherently political source (government), is it even possible to conduct discovery-based science?
4. Why didn't we hear from actual natural scientists? My conversations with fellow academic scientists paint a different picture than what was presented here.
5. Would you say that the speakers represented a balance of political perspectives to their remarks, or were they consistently biased to one? I could not escape the impression that the speakers were uniformly left-wing, and that none would have voted with the winning party in the last election. To what extent does this political bias color the claim that science is "under siege"?
Is Science Under Siege?Indigenization vs. Open InquiryWho Protects Our Kids?Episode 4. The fall of DarwinismThe Franklin Standards. A conversation highlight reelConfounded ErrorsAnti-Semitism, Inclusion, and Student Rights in Higher EdAfter Affirmative Action: Collapsing the InfrastructureAmerican Innovation: Talking from Afar—The TelephoneIntroducing Cafe Berlin (audio)Mark David Hall on Christian NationalismTeaching African American History
National Association of Scholars |

Is Science Under Siege?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER