Uploaded March 2026 | Updated September 2026, 1 week ago
I'm joined by Dr. Justin Mooney to discuss the metaphysics reincarnation without a soul. For more info, check out his paper, "Reincarnation for Everyone" forthcoming in the journal Mind. The paper is linked below.
philarchive.org/rec/MOORFE
00:00 Intro
00:35 Rebirth
02:22 Reincarnation Versus Karma
03:38 Why Christians Should Think About Reincarnation
08:07 Evidence And Skepticism
10:50 Resurrection Or Reincarnation
12:40 Paper Aim Metaphysical Possibility
16:01 Buddhist Karmic Causation
21:59 Causal Link Objection
23:59 Constitutionalism Model
28:06 First Person Perspective Transfer
31:24 Objections Spacetime Gaps
32:35 Resurrection Without Continuity
33:35 Lewis Spacetime Worms
36:00 Reincarnation Via Memory Links
38:28 Subconscious And Multiverse Fixes
40:38 Karmic Causation Requirement
42:10 Objections To Lewis View
44:58 Animalism And Olson
47:48 Brain Transplant Challenge
49:43 Practical Identity Explained
53:11 Practical Reincarnation Model
54:49 Late Developing Memories Objection
57:12 Conceivability And Wrap Up
Recently, my wife unexpectedly lost her job, putting us in a difficult place financially. Please prayerfully consider supporting me on Patreon. Go to patreon.com/theanalyticchristian
If you have questions or suggestions for future videos, please email at theanalyticchristian[at]gmail[dot]com
I'm joined by Dr. Justin Mooney to discuss the metaphysics reincarnation without a soul. For more info, check out his paper, "Reincarnation for Everyone" forthcoming in the journal Mind. The paper is linked below.
philarchive.org/rec/MOORFE
00:00 Intro
00:35 Rebirth
02:22 Reincarnation Versus Karma
03:38 Why Christians Should Think About Reincarnation
08:07 Evidence And Skepticism
10:50 Resurrection Or Reincarnation
12:40 Paper Aim Metaphysical Possibility
16:01 Buddhist Karmic Causation
21:59 Causal Link Objection
23:59 Constitutionalism Model
28:06 First Person Perspective Transfer
31:24 Objections Spacetime Gaps
32:35 Resurrection Without Continuity
33:35 Lewis Spacetime Worms
36:00 Reincarnation Via Memory Links
38:28 Subconscious And Multiverse Fixes
40:38 Karmic Causation Requirement
42:10 Objections To Lewis View
44:58 Animalism And Olson
47:48 Brain Transplant Challenge
49:43 Practical Identity Explained
53:11 Practical Reincarnation Model
54:49 Late Developing Memories Objection
57:12 Conceivability And Wrap Up
Recently, my wife unexpectedly lost her job, putting us in a difficult place financially. Please prayerfully consider supporting me on Patreon. Go to patreon.com/theanalyticchristian
If you have questions or suggestions for future videos, please email at theanalyticchristian[at]gmail[dot]com
