Is Jack actually Bon? Walten Files 5 Theory @ayylmaotv
Is Jack actually Bon? Walten Files 5 Theory  @ayylmaotv
Uploaded August 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Did you know this in the walten files?

Since the release of episode 5 fans have been discussing how Bon could be Jack. So is it true? Let me explain.

So throughout the episode we get evidence that Jack Walten is actually Bon the hare.

During rosemary’s nightmare jack disappears leaving a hare behind. This hare then leads rose to bon’s burgers where she dies.

Jack puts his hand on rose’s face to comfort her. Bon does it as well later in the same position.

The frame of Jack and Rose on their wedding is similar to when Bon meets rose in the jail cell.

She visits bon to dance with him, like she did with jack on their wedding.

Bon’s suit is also the same suit jack wore on his wedding.

If you lineup jack in the nightmare to bon in that scene they have similar injuries and teeth.

Bon refers to rose as rosie which jack did. He later says he loves her

So combined together jack could be bon. He’s stripped away his previous identity and is now trying to rebuild his family in wonderland.

There are some arguments against this theory however.

Firstly Jack is broadly shown as a loving father, it wouldn’t make sense for him to lose his identity and murder his family and co workers.

In a teaser from the walten files account we can see the souls inside each character, there’s one inside bon. So it’s either jack or it’s not, it can’t be 2 people inside the suit.

And lastly Bon is an unreliable narrator and a manipulator. We see his head hidden in a few scenes, like when Sophie and Rose watch the wedding video. So he uses this information to manipulate rose. He does things jack would do and says he knows where he is, all in the goal of leading her to bon’s burgers.

Personally I like the theory that Jack is Bon. Though i can see why people argue otherwise.

So what do you think? Are you a fan of this theory? Let me know down below.

Credit: The Walten Files 5 - Faces of Grief

#waltenfiles #thewaltenfiles #analoghorror

Please consider subscribing if you enjoyed the video :)
▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔
Discord ▸ discord.com/invite/xGPmb9T
Instagram ▸ instagram.com/ayylmao_tv
Steam Group ▸ steamcommunity.com/groups/ayylmao
Twitter ▸ twitter.com/ayylmaotv

▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔▔
Is Jack actually Bon? Walten Files 5 TheoryWhy Mr Puzzles Was So Scary Before Calling All VillainsWhy did Gangles Voice Actor receive HATE for Shipping Ribbun?My Thoughts on HELLUVA BOSS Short 14 THE PRINCESS & THE PUPPERMy Thoughts on Helluva Boss Short 13 MISSION: BOOK REPORTThe Wacky Watch Website Drama is CrazyWhat Happened to Lackadaisy?What Happened to Lulu? Gameoverse Season 1 TheoryDid you spot these references in the New Murder Drones J Animiniz Merch?Youtubes SADDEST Digital Circus Animation (wait by the river)Is Jax Trans? Digital Circus Episode 9 TheoryWhat Happened to PLANETRONIKA?
Ayy Lmao |

Is Jack actually Bon? Walten Files 5 Theory

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER