Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 4 days ago
Is capitalism better than socialism for individual freedom and prosperity?
Steamboat Institute, in partnership with the Ed Snider Center for Enterprise and Markets, is proud to present a compelling debate on the following resolution:
Be it resolved, capitalism is superior to socialism as an economic system that promotes individual freedom and prosperity.
Arguing the affirmative is Rajshree Agarwal, Professor and Director of the Ed Snider Center for Enterprise and Markets at the University of Maryland, and Daniel Di Martino, Economist and Fellow at the Manhattan Institute.
Arguing the negative is Paul Adler, Harold Quinton Chair Emeritus in Business Policy and Professor Emeritus of Management and Organization in the Marshall School of Business, University of Southern California, and Ben Burgis, Jacobin columnist and co-author of The Blueprint: How Socialism Can Work in the Real World.
Moderator is Brad Polumbo, Independent Journalist; Host of the podcast Brad vs. Everyone; Steamboat Institute Fellow.
Recorded at the University of Maryland, College Park, as part of the Campus Liberty Tour.
The speakers' views are their own.
0:00 Welcome from the University of Maryland
8:53 Welcome from Steamboat Institute
20:40 Format and rules
21:29 Opening statement: Rajshree Agarwal
29:45 Opening statement: Paul Adler
40:41 Rebuttal and opening: Daniel Di Martino
48:59 Rebuttal and opening: Ben Burgis
56:50 Moderated discussion
1:20:10 Audience questions
1:28:39 Closing: Daniel Di Martino
1:31:30 Closing: Rajshree Agarwal
1:34:33 Closing: Ben Burgis
1:37:18 Closing: Paul Adler
1:40:00 Poll results and closing remarks
Is capitalism better than socialism for individual freedom and prosperity?
Steamboat Institute, in partnership with the Ed Snider Center for Enterprise and Markets, is proud to present a compelling debate on the following resolution:
Be it resolved, capitalism is superior to socialism as an economic system that promotes individual freedom and prosperity.
Arguing the affirmative is Rajshree Agarwal, Professor and Director of the Ed Snider Center for Enterprise and Markets at the University of Maryland, and Daniel Di Martino, Economist and Fellow at the Manhattan Institute.
Arguing the negative is Paul Adler, Harold Quinton Chair Emeritus in Business Policy and Professor Emeritus of Management and Organization in the Marshall School of Business, University of Southern California, and Ben Burgis, Jacobin columnist and co-author of The Blueprint: How Socialism Can Work in the Real World.
Moderator is Brad Polumbo, Independent Journalist; Host of the podcast Brad vs. Everyone; Steamboat Institute Fellow.
Recorded at the University of Maryland, College Park, as part of the Campus Liberty Tour.
The speakers' views are their own.
0:00 Welcome from the University of Maryland
8:53 Welcome from Steamboat Institute
20:40 Format and rules
21:29 Opening statement: Rajshree Agarwal
29:45 Opening statement: Paul Adler
40:41 Rebuttal and opening: Daniel Di Martino
48:59 Rebuttal and opening: Ben Burgis
56:50 Moderated discussion
1:20:10 Audience questions
1:28:39 Closing: Daniel Di Martino
1:31:30 Closing: Rajshree Agarwal
1:34:33 Closing: Ben Burgis
1:37:18 Closing: Paul Adler
1:40:00 Poll results and closing remarks



![Does America benefit from the end of the rules-based international order?
Does America need to rule the world to stay safe? Retired Army Col. Douglas Macgregor and Johns Hopkins professor Hal Brands debate whether America benefits from the end of the rules-based international order, live at the Virginia Military Institute.
Moderated by Washington Post opinion journalist and Steamboat Institute Fellow Carine Hajjar. Hosted with the VMI Center for Leadership and Ethics to open the 2026–27 Campus Liberty Tour.
CHAPTERS:
00:00 - 07:49 - Welcome, debate introduction, and pre-debate poll
07:49 - 12:29 - Introduction of the debaters and moderator
12:29 - 17:50 - Opening remarks by Douglas Macgregor
17:50 - 22:33 - Opening remarks by Hal Brands
22:33 - 29:12 - Can the rules-based international order be saved?
29:12 - 36:39 - What should replace the current international order?
36:39 - 46:39 - Ukraine, Russia, and America’s national interests
46:39 - 55:44 - NATO, Russia, and when America should defend its allies
55:44 - 59:01 - Does America need its allies to counter China?
59:01 - 1:02:39 - Is China really a threat to the United States?
1:02:39 - 1:11:29 - China, Taiwan, and the South China Sea
1:11:29 - 1:15:58 - Iran and the limits of American power
1:15:58 - 1:15:00 - Transition to closing remarks
1:15:00 - 1:16:30 - Closing remarks by Douglas Macgregor
Thank you to the supporters who make the Campus Liberty Tour possible: the Adolph Coors Foundation, Diana Davis Spencer Foundation, Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, Jack Roth Charitable Foundation, Woodford Foundation for Limited Government, and Bruce and Marcy Benson. [VERIFY spellings with Jennifer; these came from auto-transcript]
Make the Case for Freedom. Upcoming debates: steamboatinstitute.org Does America benefit from the end of the rules-based international order?](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/0zcQ-xNW1Kk/mqdefault.jpg)






