Uploaded April 2024 | Updated September 2026, 9 minutes ago
🧠 Start your journey into expertise now for FREE: liquidzulu.github.io
👉 Video courses available here: ko-fi.com/liquidzulu/shop
You can see all of the footnotes in the script here: liquidzulu.github.io/ai-art
0:00 The Argument Against AI Image Generation
1:38 On The Impossibility of Stealing an Idea
4:24 AI Image Generation is not Photo-Bashing
11:07 Where AI Does Plagiarise
12:24 Which Aspect is Plagiarised?
15:14 Steven Zapata on the Disanalogy Between Human and AI Art
23:58 Solar Sands on the Disanalogy Between Human and AI Art
29:38 "There is nothing it is like to be Stable Diffusion"
31:17 Stable Diffusion Copying from LAION
35:49 Over-Fitting is not the Expected Behaviour
38:29 The "Copying" of Signatures
42:08 The Poison-Pill of Hardline Anti-Over-Fitting
42:55 Consent as a Moral Requirement for Training?
48:36 The Altruism of the Art-Protectionists
53:13 The Entitlement of the Art-Protectionists
59:22 The Marxism of the Art-Protectionists
1:11:51 The Elitism of the Art-Protectionists
1:15:42 The Anti-AI Crowd are Neo-Luddites
1:18:04 "AI art sucks" + "AI art will take over"
1:23:40 People Will Still Support Humans
1:25:10 The Wynand Papers, and What Makes them Possible
1:29:06 Art as a Concretisation of Metaphysics
1:36:56 Aesthetic Value as Objective
1:39:00 Objective Aesthetic Principles
1:44:44 The Role of the Artist in an AI World
1:46:20 The Labour Theory of Art
1:48:10 The Communication Theory of Art
1:49:37 The Journey Theory of Art
1:51:01 AI as the Artist
1:52:25 The Rush for Aesthetic Objectivism
1:54:33 Art for the Severely Disabled
1:59:41 AI Art Allowing for Faster Iterations
2:01:50 Automation of Less-Appealing Parts
2:03:10 Bullying Artists for not Blacklisting AI Imgen
2:03:51 Bullying YouTubers for Automating Their Own Jobs
2:10:19 Bullying Shadiversity for Teaching People How To Use AI
2:16:47 Bullying Corridor Digital for Experimenting with AI
2:20:56 Giving Credit Where it is Due
2:23:03 The Kim Jung Gi AI
2:24:06 The Sam Yang AI
2:27:28 IP for Me, but not For Thee
Social media:
liquidzulu.github.io
twitter.com/liquid2ulu
Crypto:
BTC - bc1q9qlp7mr74d59aw8aznzfwphaw8gquee6p7mstt
XMR - 47aixTu1ZsgdVbo7oGbwCdZh75LyecL8rNoQUAWYW4MjVpbhn3Bm6ngWLc6MHaY5UU2ZWnkXiPE2dRxLX3NtdcHf5ZFoPN7
Music: pastebin.com/kTnT8JgU
[LICENSE INFORMATION: I do not consider intellectual property to be a valid form of property (youtube.com/watch?v=4xKjHHzLUQQ), therefore I hereby waive any aggressive restrictions such as the attribution requirement of the CC license that should be below this disclaimer. You can use this content for any use you see fit so long as you also do not enforce an intellectual monopoly over derivative works. Furthermore, if I have made a mistake and licensed under the standard YouTube license please let me know and I will amend it]
🧠 Start your journey into expertise now for FREE: liquidzulu.github.io
👉 Video courses available here: ko-fi.com/liquidzulu/shop
You can see all of the footnotes in the script here: liquidzulu.github.io/ai-art
0:00 The Argument Against AI Image Generation
1:38 On The Impossibility of Stealing an Idea
4:24 AI Image Generation is not Photo-Bashing
11:07 Where AI Does Plagiarise
12:24 Which Aspect is Plagiarised?
15:14 Steven Zapata on the Disanalogy Between Human and AI Art
23:58 Solar Sands on the Disanalogy Between Human and AI Art
29:38 "There is nothing it is like to be Stable Diffusion"
31:17 Stable Diffusion Copying from LAION
35:49 Over-Fitting is not the Expected Behaviour
38:29 The "Copying" of Signatures
42:08 The Poison-Pill of Hardline Anti-Over-Fitting
42:55 Consent as a Moral Requirement for Training?
48:36 The Altruism of the Art-Protectionists
53:13 The Entitlement of the Art-Protectionists
59:22 The Marxism of the Art-Protectionists
1:11:51 The Elitism of the Art-Protectionists
1:15:42 The Anti-AI Crowd are Neo-Luddites
1:18:04 "AI art sucks" + "AI art will take over"
1:23:40 People Will Still Support Humans
1:25:10 The Wynand Papers, and What Makes them Possible
1:29:06 Art as a Concretisation of Metaphysics
1:36:56 Aesthetic Value as Objective
1:39:00 Objective Aesthetic Principles
1:44:44 The Role of the Artist in an AI World
1:46:20 The Labour Theory of Art
1:48:10 The Communication Theory of Art
1:49:37 The Journey Theory of Art
1:51:01 AI as the Artist
1:52:25 The Rush for Aesthetic Objectivism
1:54:33 Art for the Severely Disabled
1:59:41 AI Art Allowing for Faster Iterations
2:01:50 Automation of Less-Appealing Parts
2:03:10 Bullying Artists for not Blacklisting AI Imgen
2:03:51 Bullying YouTubers for Automating Their Own Jobs
2:10:19 Bullying Shadiversity for Teaching People How To Use AI
2:16:47 Bullying Corridor Digital for Experimenting with AI
2:20:56 Giving Credit Where it is Due
2:23:03 The Kim Jung Gi AI
2:24:06 The Sam Yang AI
2:27:28 IP for Me, but not For Thee
Social media:
liquidzulu.github.io
twitter.com/liquid2ulu
Crypto:
BTC - bc1q9qlp7mr74d59aw8aznzfwphaw8gquee6p7mstt
XMR - 47aixTu1ZsgdVbo7oGbwCdZh75LyecL8rNoQUAWYW4MjVpbhn3Bm6ngWLc6MHaY5UU2ZWnkXiPE2dRxLX3NtdcHf5ZFoPN7
Music: pastebin.com/kTnT8JgU
[LICENSE INFORMATION: I do not consider intellectual property to be a valid form of property (youtube.com/watch?v=4xKjHHzLUQQ), therefore I hereby waive any aggressive restrictions such as the attribution requirement of the CC license that should be below this disclaimer. You can use this content for any use you see fit so long as you also do not enforce an intellectual monopoly over derivative works. Furthermore, if I have made a mistake and licensed under the standard YouTube license please let me know and I will amend it]
![Is the State Necessary for Rights Enforcement? [DEBATE TOURNAMENT]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/hYlJktl9m9I/mqdefault.jpg "Is the State Necessary for Rights Enforcement? [DEBATE TOURNAMENT]
Debating the proposition A state is required to defend the rights of citizens on the Sola Requiem debate tournament.
🧠 Start your journey into expertise now for FREE: https://liquidzulu.github.io
👉 video courses available here: https://ko-fi.com/liquidzulu/shop
Or buy me a coffee: https://ko-fi.com/liquidzulu
Social media:
https://discord.com/invite/A9NKzQShPA
https://liquidzulu.github.io/
https://twitter.com/liquid2ulu
BTC - bc1q9qlp7mr74d59aw8aznzfwphaw8gquee6p7mstt
[LICENSE INFORMATION: I do not consider intellectual property to be a valid form of property (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4xKjHHzLUQQ), therefore I hereby waive any aggressive restrictions such as the attribution requirement of the CC license that should be below this disclaimer. You can use this content for any use you see fit so long as you also do not enforce an intellectual monopoly over derivative works. Furthermore, if I have made a mistake and licensed under the standard YouTube license please let me know and I will amend it]")
![Labour Theory of Value vs Subjective Theory of Value [DEBATE]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/jkIjf4lO3as/mqdefault.jpg "Labour Theory of Value vs Subjective Theory of Value [DEBATE]
Debating the labour theory of value and the subjective theory of value with Victor Magariño
Victors sources: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1QeDgfmctAF1q2ly7R8RMXAazLt7jQ4Wg4tioUX4z3O4/edit?usp=sharing
My source on free will: https://liquidzulu.github.io/brain/note/the-validation-of-free-will/
🧠 Start your journey into expertise now for FREE: https://liquidzulu.github.io
👉 video courses available here: https://ko-fi.com/liquidzulu/shop
Or buy me a coffee: https://ko-fi.com/liquidzulu
Social media:
https://liquidzulu.github.io/
https://twitter.com/liquid2ulu
BTC - bc1q9qlp7mr74d59aw8aznzfwphaw8gquee6p7mstt
[LICENSE INFORMATION: I do not consider intellectual property to be a valid form of property (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4xKjHHzLUQQ), therefore I hereby waive any aggressive restrictions such as the attribution requirement of the CC license that should be below this disclaimer. You can use this content for any use you see fit so long as you also do not enforce an intellectual monopoly over derivative works. Furthermore, if I have made a mistake and licensed under the standard YouTube license please let me know and I will amend it]")
![Is the NAP absolute? [DEBATE]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/joew12wjKTg/mqdefault.jpg "Is the NAP absolute? [DEBATE]
Debating NAP absolutism with Eduardo
See Eduardos links here: https://linktr.ee/eduardoyanez ?utm_source=linktree_profile_share<sid=9b2d0e29-f536-4f28-a47a-3607648f75bb
Listen to what if LiquidZulu had a low taper fade here: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/xsdlnakl3e39k4ngjma9k/low-taper-zulu-new-11-12-24-8.46-PM.m4a?rlkey=ttjnt75gm63vjasq9gc786u0b&st=bfuqvimr&dl=0
🧠 Start your journey into expertise now for FREE: https://liquidzulu.github.io
👉 video courses available here: https://ko-fi.com/liquidzulu/shop
Or buy me a coffee: https://ko-fi.com/liquidzulu
Social media:
https://liquidzulu.github.io/
https://twitter.com/liquid2ulu
BTC - bc1q9qlp7mr74d59aw8aznzfwphaw8gquee6p7mstt
[LICENSE INFORMATION: I do not consider intellectual property to be a valid form of property (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4xKjHHzLUQQ), therefore I hereby waive any aggressive restrictions such as the attribution requirement of the CC license that should be below this disclaimer. You can use this content for any use you see fit so long as you also do not enforce an intellectual monopoly over derivative works. Furthermore, if I have made a mistake and licensed under the standard YouTube license please let me know and I will amend it]")
