Uploaded July 2026 | Updated November 2026, 3 hours ago
People often point to immigrant children as proof that immersion alone works, but that is not passive learning. In school, kids read, write, listen, speak, answer questions, complete assignments, and get constant feedback for hours every day. In this clip from my reaction video, I explain why that is much closer to active comprehensible input than passive exposure.
Full reaction video: youtu.be/P9iIYlZmDxI
Original video: youtube.com/watch?v=8bbGRiJuxno
Show some love to @NaturalLanguageLearning for the original video to which I am reacting.
β€οΈ Become a member of Herr Antrim's Deutschlerner Club to get access to extra German learning materials - germanwithantrim.com/deutschlerner-club
Chat with Herr Antrim's AI Clone here: yourteacher.ai/?via=herrantrim
π Herr Antrim's Books on Amazon*: amazon.com/shop/learngermanwithherrantrim/list/1PABNMMRQO6P0
π Herr Antrim's Books on germanwithantrim.com: germanwithantrim.com/store
π Learn German with books, movies, and more: amazon.com/shop/learngermanwithherrantrim
β Recommended Playlists
πΆββοΈ Herr Antrim's Step-by-Step Guide to Starting Your German Learning Journey: youtube.com/watch?v=EDM0f5Wdc1Y&list=PLUbX6-E9GbtpRL1FN2Yh1aU5cc2zJdxsB
Full A1 & A2 Courses: youtube.com/watch?v=6Ka_3Rq8JZ4&list=PLUbX6-E9GbtopS8yWocmLgW6KPHrKBi_-
π¨βπ« German Grammar Master Classes: youtube.com/watch?v=GRYulP53Fo0&list=PLUbX6-E9GbtpaJT-2an_MXeQW8rmvfnRU
π οΈ Language Learning Resource Reviews: youtube.com/watch?v=1Z4op3PDvoQ&list=PL2554F5A87705B0A9
πββοΈ German Learning Tips: youtube.com/watch?v=SDvkPzAPVSo&list=PLUbX6-E9GbtrFXKVYl4qPSyk7rpIMHfmT
Disclaimer: Some of these links go to Herr Antrim's website and some are affiliate links. If you make a purchase after clicking on one of those links, Herr Antrim will earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.
People often point to immigrant children as proof that immersion alone works, but that is not passive learning. In school, kids read, write, listen, speak, answer questions, complete assignments, and get constant feedback for hours every day. In this clip from my reaction video, I explain why that is much closer to active comprehensible input than passive exposure.
Full reaction video: youtu.be/P9iIYlZmDxI
Original video: youtube.com/watch?v=8bbGRiJuxno
Show some love to @NaturalLanguageLearning for the original video to which I am reacting.
β€οΈ Become a member of Herr Antrim's Deutschlerner Club to get access to extra German learning materials - germanwithantrim.com/deutschlerner-club
Chat with Herr Antrim's AI Clone here: yourteacher.ai/?via=herrantrim
π Herr Antrim's Books on Amazon*: amazon.com/shop/learngermanwithherrantrim/list/1PABNMMRQO6P0
π Herr Antrim's Books on germanwithantrim.com: germanwithantrim.com/store
π Learn German with books, movies, and more: amazon.com/shop/learngermanwithherrantrim
β Recommended Playlists
πΆββοΈ Herr Antrim's Step-by-Step Guide to Starting Your German Learning Journey: youtube.com/watch?v=EDM0f5Wdc1Y&list=PLUbX6-E9GbtpRL1FN2Yh1aU5cc2zJdxsB
Full A1 & A2 Courses: youtube.com/watch?v=6Ka_3Rq8JZ4&list=PLUbX6-E9GbtopS8yWocmLgW6KPHrKBi_-
π¨βπ« German Grammar Master Classes: youtube.com/watch?v=GRYulP53Fo0&list=PLUbX6-E9GbtpaJT-2an_MXeQW8rmvfnRU
π οΈ Language Learning Resource Reviews: youtube.com/watch?v=1Z4op3PDvoQ&list=PL2554F5A87705B0A9
πββοΈ German Learning Tips: youtube.com/watch?v=SDvkPzAPVSo&list=PLUbX6-E9GbtrFXKVYl4qPSyk7rpIMHfmT
Disclaimer: Some of these links go to Herr Antrim's website and some are affiliate links. If you make a purchase after clicking on one of those links, Herr Antrim will earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.










