Illinois Separation Lays Out Arguments, SCOTUS Hears Migrant Labor Dispute | The States @thecentersquare
Illinois Separation Lays Out Arguments, SCOTUS Hears Migrant Labor Dispute | The States  @thecentersquare
Uploaded November 2026 | Updated November 2026, 2 days ago
U.S. Supreme Court justices appeared divided over whether a federal agency or a federal court should decide H-2A migrant farmworker disputes. The case involves a $550,000-plus Department of Labor fine against New Jersey’s Sun Valley Orchards. On The States for Nov. 12, 2026, host Greg Bishop covers the arguments, the movement to split Illinois into two states, and $1.4 trillion in federal interest costs on a national debt of $40.2 trillion.

The Center Square’s Andrew Rice explains the case. The Department of Labor found that Sun Valley Orchards failed to provide the pay, housing and transportation required under the H-2A program, and it assessed the fine through administrative judges. The farm argues it was a contract dispute that belongs in federal court.

Justice Clarence Thomas pointed to immigration as a central public right. Justices Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor suggested it is a private rights dispute. Government attorney Sarah Harris urged a narrow ruling, warning that a broad one could affect how agencies handle Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and veterans benefits.

A decision is expected by June 2027.

Lorette Newland, executive director of Illinois Separation, says 44 and a half of Illinois’ 102 counties have now approved nonbinding referendums on separating from Cook County. Approval in the latest counties ranged from 57% to 80%. Critics say separation would require approval from the Illinois Legislature and Congress, and they cite Paul Simon Public Policy Institute research suggesting Cook County sends more revenue to the state than it receives. Newland disputes that research, citing caveats in the underlying legislative data. She says about 10 more counties are pursuing the question and that pensions earned in Cook County should stay with Cook County.

Plus, America's Talking:

National: thecentersquare.com/national/article_4f6b6636-7b65-494c-a12c-822321258df4.html
Michigan: thecentersquare.com/michigan/article_bf54f8c4-ca78-4731-bc83-8a389a05c040.html
Wisconsin: thecentersquare.com/wisconsin/article_a95ac927-f51c-4e8d-bed4-5b38db502a73.html
Illinois: thecentersquare.com/illinois/article_51f37dd5-7d56-455a-882b-29e398ae360f.html
Illinois Separation Lays Out Arguments, SCOTUS Hears Migrant Labor Dispute | The StatesDemocrats Poised to Gain More Power in Olympia After Washington ElectionsWashington Election Day 2026: Voter Turnout, Ballot Returns and DOJ MonitoringTexas Turns Blue, Democrats Secure U.S. Senate Seat & Governors MansionSeattle Mayor Katie Wilsons Homelessness Plan Could Fail, Critic WarnsTrump Admin Pressures Ferguson Over School Choice Program + Wilson Grilled On Homelessness SpendingRich Residents Are Leaving New York City, Data ShowsData Centers Spark Taxpayer Revolt Across America4 States Have Banned Convertible HandgunsInitiative 638 Passes, $900M Albertsons Opioid Verdict & Gun Permit Law | Washington in Focus DailyLeft-Leaning PACs Spending to Keep a Pennsylvania Republican in Office122 Colorado Judges Named in Misconduct Complaint Ahead of Election Day | America’s Talking
The Center Square |

Illinois Separation Lays Out Arguments, SCOTUS Hears Migrant Labor Dispute | The States

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER