If God Commands an Atrocity, Is It Moral? @Skepticus.Channel
If God Commands an Atrocity, Is It Moral?  @Skepticus.Channel
Uploaded September 2026 | Updated November 2026, 22 hours ago
Join the livestream every Tuesday starting at 5PM CST.

What happens when “God can do whatever he wants” becomes your entire moral system?

In this episode of Livestream Lowlights, a Christian caller and I get into a long discussion about some of the Bible’s most disturbing stories—and eventually arrive at a remarkably simple question:

If God commands an atrocity, does that make the atrocity moral?

We start with the slaughter of the Amalekites, where Saul is commanded to wipe out men, women, children, infants, and animals. From there, we move to the story of David and Bathsheba—and the punishment supposedly imposed for David’s actions: the death of his infant son and the public sexual violation of his concubines.

The caller repeatedly admits that these things would be horrifying if humans did them.

But if God did them?

Then, apparently, they were justified.

And that creates a much bigger problem.

If your moral system says anything becomes good the moment you believe God commanded it, then morality no longer protects you from atrocities. The only remaining question is whether you can convince yourself that God gave the order.

That is precisely the problem with divine command theory.

We also get into Jesus and the Trinity, whether Christians can separate Jesus from Yahweh’s actions in the Hebrew Bible, how believers decide which alleged commands actually come from God, and why “I would know the difference” isn’t nearly as reassuring as someone might think.

Sometimes the best critique of a worldview is simply asking someone to follow it all the way to the end.

Welcome to Livestream Lowlights.
If God Commands an Atrocity, Is It Moral?Creationists Dont Understand Code - DNA Doesnt Require GodLive Christian Failures (2026-06-16)LIVE CALL IN: 255 Stupid Catholic Dogmas  (2026-09-12)The 1st Anniversary Blasphemy Celebration LivestreamBiblical Morality at Its Absolute Worst (Judges 17-21)The Truth About the YouTube Algorithm and Atheist VideosResistance Is Futile. I Will Assimilate Your Storm God.Gaslighting For Jesus (IMBeggars Faceplant On Prayer)Logic Gaps and Finding Community After FaithThe Noah’s Ark Claim That Refuses to DieYou Dont Need God to Be Moral
Skepticus |

If God Commands an Atrocity, Is It Moral?

SHARE TO X SHARE TO REDDIT SHARE TO FACEBOOK WALLPAPER