Uploaded June 2026 | Updated September 2026, 2 weeks ago
The Gothic 1 Remake devs made one decision that changes everything: they deliberately
rejected the Souls formula. No stamina bar. No lock-on. No borrowed mechanics.
I'm reacting to their full combat breakdown — and I have some thoughts.
In this video I react to the official Gothic 1 Remake developer deep-dive into the
combat system. We cover directional combat, how your weapon choice (axe vs sword vs
mace) actually changes your moveset — not just your damage — and why the devs chose
to treat enemy AI like a puzzle to solve rather than a damage sponge to deplete.
There's also the transformation system debate — apparently even the original Gothic
devs said to cut it, and THQ Nordic kept every single form. We find out why.
This is the kind of design philosophy content I genuinely care about, and Gothic 1
Remake is shaping up to be one of the most interesting RPGs of 2025. Let's dig in.
Want to support my work? ➡️ buymeacoffee.com/polishdanreviews
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 - Community Pushback/Feedback
00:37 - New Detail
01:11 - Differences in Combat System
07:37 - One Handed vs Two Handed
11:03 - Combat Animations
12:26 - New Skills
15:15 - Learning Skills
17:31 - AOE Magic Spells
19:49 - NPC AI
23:33 - New Armor System
26:18 - They've Removed Cheese
29:28 - Ranged Combat
32:20 - Piranha Bytes Didn't Like This...
34:19 - Magic Combat
38:47 - Climbing?
41:22 - Not Fit for 2026
43:34 - Uriziel and Ore Armor
44:09 - Thoughts on Orcs
44:58 - They've Fixed It!
🔔 Subscribe for honest, analytical gaming content every week
👍 If you enjoyed this video, leave a like — it genuinely helps the channel
#Gothic1Remake #GothicRemake #Gothic
The Gothic 1 Remake devs made one decision that changes everything: they deliberately
rejected the Souls formula. No stamina bar. No lock-on. No borrowed mechanics.
I'm reacting to their full combat breakdown — and I have some thoughts.
In this video I react to the official Gothic 1 Remake developer deep-dive into the
combat system. We cover directional combat, how your weapon choice (axe vs sword vs
mace) actually changes your moveset — not just your damage — and why the devs chose
to treat enemy AI like a puzzle to solve rather than a damage sponge to deplete.
There's also the transformation system debate — apparently even the original Gothic
devs said to cut it, and THQ Nordic kept every single form. We find out why.
This is the kind of design philosophy content I genuinely care about, and Gothic 1
Remake is shaping up to be one of the most interesting RPGs of 2025. Let's dig in.
Want to support my work? ➡️ buymeacoffee.com/polishdanreviews
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 - Community Pushback/Feedback
00:37 - New Detail
01:11 - Differences in Combat System
07:37 - One Handed vs Two Handed
11:03 - Combat Animations
12:26 - New Skills
15:15 - Learning Skills
17:31 - AOE Magic Spells
19:49 - NPC AI
23:33 - New Armor System
26:18 - They've Removed Cheese
29:28 - Ranged Combat
32:20 - Piranha Bytes Didn't Like This...
34:19 - Magic Combat
38:47 - Climbing?
41:22 - Not Fit for 2026
43:34 - Uriziel and Ore Armor
44:09 - Thoughts on Orcs
44:58 - They've Fixed It!
🔔 Subscribe for honest, analytical gaming content every week
👍 If you enjoyed this video, leave a like — it genuinely helps the channel
#Gothic1Remake #GothicRemake #Gothic
